The Best Bulking Supplements for Skinny Guys
Over 5,000 shares and 500 comments later, here’s our revised supplement guide for skinny guys trying to build muscle in time for last summer. We’ll cover supplements that speed up muscle growth, such as creatine. We’ll review supplements that help skinny guys bulk up, like mass gainers. We’ll talk about pre-workout supplements, too.
When talking about supplements, we use research, personal experience, and over a decade of full-time coaching experience. We’ve each gained seventy pounds (naturally). We’ve also helped over 10,000 skinny guys bulk up with our Bony to Beastly Bulking Program. Marco has a degree in Health Sciences, and he’s trained hundreds of clients, ranging from everyday desk workers all the way up to college, professional, and Olympic athletes.
We don’t sell supplements. There are no affiliate links.
Skinny Guys Benefit From Different Supplements
As skinny guys, or “ectomorphs,” we have the opposite goal of everyone else. They want to lose weight; we want to gain it. We’re using a different set of criteria to evaluate the effectiveness of our supplements. More calories? Good. More weight gain? Good. Does it increase appetite? Perfect!
For example, consider branched-chain amino acids (BCAAs). BCAAs are a trendy ingredient in muscle-building supplement cocktails. However, BCAAs are simply a calorie-light version of protein powder. A standard serving of whey protein powder contains the same nutrients as a standard scoop of BCAAs. The difference is whey protein also contains many other amino acids and nutrients, making it far higher in calories.
BCAAs are fine if you’re looking for a low-calorie alternative to protein powder. But you aren’t. We’re hardgainers. We’re trying to eat more calories to gain weight. The more amino acids in a protein source, the better it will build muscle (study). Forget isolating the branched-chain amino acids. Give us all of them.
BCAAs are also popular with guys who practice intermittent fasting. Having BCAAs during the fasting period is thought to be a way to stimulate muscle growth without breaking your fast. However, intermittent fasting makes it harder to gain weight. That’s not good. At least not for us.
Protein powder is better than BCAAs. It’s cheaper, healthier, has more amino acids, and has more calories. It does everything BCAAs do but better.
Food is even better than protein powder. It’s even more nutritious, full of other macronutrients, fibre, vitamins, minerals, phytonutrients, and probiotics. This makes foods like lean ground beef, chicken breast, fish, Greek yogurt, and soy absolutely amazing for building muscle.
When looking at supplements, we need to keep our specific goal in mind: we’re bulking.
Do You Need Supplements to Get Good Results?
The short answer is no; you don’t need supplements to gain weight, build muscle, build it quickly, or build it leanly. To get great results, all you need to do is follow a good workout program, eat enough nutritious food, and get plenty of good sleep.
Without getting the fundamentals down, supplements are a waste of money. After all, even if you find a supplement that boosts your results by 50%, an extra 50% on top of nothing is still nothing.
If you already know the fundamentals of building muscle, though, supplements can help you do a few things:
- Supplements can make a bulking routine easier. For example, protein powder makes it easier to eat enough protein. It’s more convenient and less filling.
- Supplements can speed up your rate of muscle growth. For example, creatine allows you to build muscle more quickly. You might gain your first twenty pounds in fifteen weeks instead of twenty.
- Supplements can keep your gains leaner. Anything that speeds up your rate of muscle growth will make your muscles more voracious. They’ll hog more of the calories you eat, leaving fewer to spill over into fat gain.
- Supplements can improve consistency. For example, caffeine reduces the feeling of fatigue, giving you more energy to lift weights. Caffeine is also addictive (which is both good and bad). If you get in the habit of having caffeine before lifting, you might become addicted to your lifting routine.
The Very Best Bulking Supplements
The three best bulking supplements for skinny guys are:
- Creatine: improves our workout performance and speeds up our rate of muscle growth, allowing us to build muscle faster and more leanly.
- Whey protein: makes it easier to hit our daily protein goals without feeling stuffed.
- Caffeine: gives us the kick in the glutes that we need to get to the gym and lift like a Beast.
Let’s go into each one in more detail.
Creatine
Creatine is the most famous muscle-building supplement (study). Hundreds of studies show that it increases weight gain, lean mass gain, fat loss, and muscle growth. The latest meta-analysis found that it increases our rate of muscle growth by around 33%, at least during the first few months of supplementation.
The only thing you need to be mindful of is drinking enough water. Creatine pulls fluid into your muscles, so you might give yourself a stomach ache if you don’t have enough fluid available. That’s why creatine is normally mixed into drinks (such as water or protein shakes).
How Does Creatine Work?
Creatine improves muscle growth in two main ways:
- It helps your body replenish ATP, which is the type of fuel that you use when lifting weights. This allows you to eke out a couple of extra reps, stimulating more muscle growth.
- Creatine also improves muscle protein synthesis and glycogen storage. This means that not only will you build more muscle via your training, but you’ll also get more muscle out of the food that you’re eating.
How Much Extra Muscle Does Creatine Build?
What results can you get with creatine? How much weight will you gain? How much extra muscle will you build? That’s hard to answer because it depends on how much creatine you already have in your system. On average, people gain a couple of pounds of muscle, a couple of pounds of water, and lose a pound or so of fat (full explanation). It speeds up your rate of muscle growth by about 33% (full explanation).
If you follow a good workout program, eat enough good food, and supplement with creatine, you’ll get great results. How much of that is from the creatine? It’s hard to say. Maybe a couple of pounds.
Does Creatine Affect Fat Gains?
Creatine can help you bulk more leanly. It will improve insulin sensitivity in your muscle cells. This means more of what you eat will be invested into muscle growth instead of stored as body fat.
Most of us ectomorphs naturally have good insulin sensitivity. Lifting weights will improve that insulin sensitivity, and gaining muscle will improve it further. It’s not something we necessarily need extra help with. But extra help is welcome.
Should You “Load” Creatine?
If you take 5 grams of creatine every day, it will take around a month to fully saturate your muscles. This will make your bulking progress seem nice and smooth. It will also reduce your risk of getting stomach aches. This has proven to be wonderfully effective for building muscle.
However, you could cut that loading period down to a week by taking four 5-gram doses per day. After that, you’d slow it down, taking just 5 grams per day. It’s unclear whether this offers any advantage.
Creatine Non-Responders
Roughly 25–33% of people don’t respond to creatine (study, study). These people are called non-responders. It’s unclear why some people respond to creatine and others don’t. If you’re a vegan or vegetarian, creatine seems to have a stronger effect. If you eat a lot of meat, it may have a weaker effect. It might be that people who eat plenty of creatine in their diets don’t benefit from supplementing with it.
Caffeine
The first and most important part of building muscle is stimulating muscle growth. You have to work out. Even when you’re tired. That’s where caffeine comes in. If you’re feeling low, caffeine will lift you up. It will carry you through your workouts.
We recommend having caffeine in normal, healthy doses. The amount you’d find in a cup or two of coffee. Something like 50–150mg. That’s enough to reduce your feelings of fatigue and improve your motivation. It’s not so much that it will interfere with your sleep or health, especially if you train earlier in the day.
Whey Protein
Our muscle fibres are constructed out of the protein we eat. That’s why it’s so important to eat enough protein (study, study). It’s also important to eat enough energy—enough calories. We use that energy to convert the protein we eat into muscle mass. That’s why a calorie surplus is so important.
If you’re eating in a calorie surplus and eating a reasonably balanced diet, you might already be eating enough protein. You only need around 0.7 grams of protein per pound of body weight per day. If you weigh 150 pounds, that’s only 105 grams of protein per day.
If you already have enough protein in your diet, supplementing with it won’t give you any extra benefit. On the other hand, if you aren’t eating enough protein, supplementing with it is an easy way to improve your results.
When’s the Best Time to Have a Protein Shake?
Most people have a scoop of whey protein right after working out, during the so-called anabolic window. That’s arguably the best time to have a protein shake, but you can have them at any time of day, ideally alongside snacks or meals.
How Much Whey Protein Can You Have Per Day?
Most people can get away with having 2–3 scoops of whey protein per day without any issues. That doesn’t mean you should have that much whey protein every day, just that it’s an option. The ideal scenario would be to get the vast majority of your protein from nutritious whole-food sources, such as lean cuts of meat, seafood, poultry, whole eggs, Greek yogurt, nuts, seeds, legumes, or even soy.
Is Whey the Best Type of Protein Powder?
Whey protein is cheap, well-studied, easily digested, and contains a great mix of amino acids. It also tastes reasonably good, at least compared to the other types of protein powder. It makes for the best default.
If you’d prefer to use a plant-based protein powder, no problem. Those are great, too. Almost all of them use a smart mix of plant-based protein sources that provide a perfect blend of amino acids.
Mediocre Bulking Supplements
Here are the supplements with a little bit of positive evidence behind them. These supplements may help you build muscle more quickly, but the effects are minor or situational.
Weight Gainers
Weight gainers can help skinny guys gain build muscle and gain weight. Most skinny guys have a hard time eating enough to gain weight. Weight gainers are packed full of easily digested calories, blowing the bottleneck off our ability to build muscle.
However, weight gainers are little more than protein powder with processed carbs. The protein generally comes from whey protein, and the carbs tend to come from maltodextrin. These powders are good for building muscle, but they aren’t rich in fibre or micronutrients.
It would be better for your long-term health if you blended up smoothies instead of shaking up gainers. That way, you get your carbs from oats and fruits instead of maltodextrin. You can get your protein from greek yogurt, nuts, seeds, and whole grains. Toss in some spinach for some extra nitrates. That way, you get all the vitamins, minerals, fibre, prebiotics, and probiotics you need.
Citrulline Malate
Citrulline malate is the best “pump” supplement on the market right now, and it’s faring quite well in the research. When digested, it converts into arginine, which turns into nitric oxide, and which dilates your blood vessels, allowing you to pump more blood into the muscles that you’re training. This enhanced muscle pump can improve the health of your blood vessels and increase muscle protein synthesis, which might help you gain a little more muscle.
However, eating a nourishing bulking diet will help you gain even more muscle and strength than pump supplements (study). If your diet includes foods like carrots, spinach, and beets, then you’re already consuming plenty of nitrates. Even better if you eat nuts, seeds, and garlic. This produces a stronger and more beneficial effect than pump supplements.
Beta-Alanine
Beta-alanine is creatine’s little brother. Both supplements improve the number of reps we can eke out while lifting weights, improving our ability to build muscle. It’s just that beta-alanine isn’t as powerful and only helps in certain circumstances.
The ideal dosage seems to be around 3–5 grams per day, taken at any time (similar to creatine). Be warned, though—it can create the sensation of being swarmed by spiders (paresthesia). Harmless but horrifying. I hate it so much.
Ashwagandha
Ashwagandha is an intriguing muscle-building supplement. The first study to make waves in the muscle-building world was this one, showing that ashwagandha can:
- Speed up muscle growth
- Increase strength gains
- Reduce fat gains
- Increase testosterone
- Reduce cortisol
To give you an idea of the magnitude of these effects, the 8-week study found a 15% greater increase in testosterone and a 44-pound greater increase in bench press strength when compared to the placebo group. That’s amazing, but if we look at a meta-analysis examining the overall body of evidence, the effects are less dramatic.
Ashwagandha may indeed help skinny guys build muscle. It might also help skinny-fat guys by improving their ability to build muscle while losing fat. And there don’t seem to be any negative side effects. On the other hand, the benefits aren’t dramatic.
Vitamin D
Vitamin D can increase our testosterone production if and only if we’re deficient in vitamin D. Most people are deficient in vitamin D, though, which makes this is a viable supplement for most people, especially during the winter.
Fish and Krill Oil
Fish oil contains healthy fatty acids (DHA and EPA). There’s a modest amount of evidence showing that supplementing with DHA and EPA can cause a small amount of muscle growth and fat loss (study). However, these effects are quite small. They’re also inconsistent.
Curcumin (aka Turmeric)
A recent systematic review found that curcumin reduces inflammation without interfering with our recovery process. It decreased muscle soreness and fatigue. That could theoretically allow you to benefit from higher training volumes. Curcumin also appears to be good for general health and digestion. These findings were mirrored in a second systematic review.
Underwhelming Bulking Supplements
Many bulking supplements are understudied and overhyped. They might help us build some extra muscle, but we just can’t say for sure yet, and it’s hard to know the downsides. As more research comes out, we’ll continue updating this list.
Ecdysteroids (including Turkesterone)
Ecdysteroids (such as turkesterone) are chemicals plants produce to defend themselves against insects. These chemicals cause the insects to moult—it makes their exoskeletons fall off. What’s interesting is that these chemicals seem to have steroid-like effects in some small animals.
Some ecdysteroids have human trials hinting at their effectiveness. For example, this study found that a spinach extract containing small amounts of ecdysterone caused the participants to gain extra muscle mass and strength.
However, the highest quality study looking into ecdysteroids for building muscle found no effects on our hormones, muscle growth, or fat loss (study). As a result, the International Society of Sports Nutrition doesn’t recommend ecdysteroids or turkesterone as muscle-building supplements (study).
This lack of enthusiasm is mirrored by experts like Eric Trexler, Ph.D., who told us, “At this time, there is not sufficient evidence to suggest that turkesterone enhances increases in strength or muscle mass in humans.”
HMB
HMB performed eerily well in a few studies, showing steroid-like muscle growth. These studies are infamous in the muscle-building community because of how suspicious they are. Furthermore, since HMB is found within protein sources, you may get the benefits simply from consuming enough protein.
Nitrates
The nitrates found in beets and leafy greens are knowing for being generally healthy, reducing muscle soreness, and even improving our lifting performance (study). However, there’s no need to supplement with nitrate. Most experts recommend eating more leafy green vegetables instead. Carrots, beets, garlic, and seeds can also help.
Collagen Protein
Collagen protein, known as hydrolyzed collagen or collagen peptides, is known for increasing gains in lean mass. Not by improving muscle growth, though. Collagen doesn’t increase muscle growth (study). Rather, it bulks up our connective tissues! It seems to be especially good for helping older lifters suffering from sarcopenia (age-related muscle loss) gain more connective tissue mass (study).
Arginine
Arginine supplements can’t be digested properly and thus cannot be effective. Researchers learned this and found another way to get the intended effect, giving us citrulline malate instead.
Baking Powder
Baking powder is beta-alanine’s evil twin. Baking powder mimics the effects of beta-alanine but with even more unwanted side effects. Not only will supplementing with baking powder make you feel incredibly sick and dehydrated, but a single dose also contains four times the recommended daily sodium intake.
Bulking Supplements for Vegans
There are a few supplements that are especially helpful for vegans. Our article about plant-based bulking has a full list of recommended supplements, as well as general best practices while bulking on a plant-based diet. Here’s a quick rundown, though:
- Vitamin B-12: The most common deficiency vegans encounter is a vitamin B-12 deficiency (study, study). As a result, most experts recommend that vegans take b–12 vitamins.
- Creatine: The more creatine you have in your muscles, the more quickly you can build muscle (meta-analysis). Since creatine naturally occurs in meat, vegans consume much less of it (study, study) and thus have more to gain by supplementing with it (study). All creatine supplements are 100% plant-based, too, so there’s no worry there.
- Calcium and zinc: Many plants contain calcium and zinc, but those same plants often contain phytates and oxalates, which reduces nutrient absorption (study, study). It’s not that plant-based diets aren’t rich in these nutrients; it’s just that vegans need to eat more of them. Mind you, bulking means eating an abundance of food and calories, so this won’t necessarily be a problem.
- Vitamin D: Most people are deficient in vitamin D, especially during the winter (study). Vitamin D is notable for vegans, though, because they don’t eat dairy that’s fortified with it (study, study). That means that they may need to supplement with it directly. Remember that D3 is the most effective form of Vitamin D and that only lichen-based D3 supplements are plant-based.
- Beta-alanine: Beta-alanine is a mediocre bulking supplement overall, causing unremarkable increases in muscle mass in most people (study). However, since plant-based diets are lower in carnosine (study), and since beta-alanine increases muscle carnosine content, this might be a more worthwhile supplement for vegans (study).
- Carnitine and taurine: Plant-based diets are also lower in carnitine (study) and taurine (study), common ingredients in pre-workout supplements. However, these supplements aren’t generally considered essential for vegans.
- Omega-3 fatty acids: vegan diets are lower in omega-3 fatty acids (study), and there’s preliminary evidence that getting enough omega-3s might improve body composition (study). It’s also a good idea to have omega-3s in your diet from a general health perspective.
Overall Supplement Recommendations
Supplements won’t make or break your bulking routine. Your workouts, bulking diet, and lifestyle are far more important. However, they can still help. Of all the supplements out there, the very best ones are:
- Creatine increases workout performance and muscle growth. Take 5 grams every morning mixed into a large glass of water.
- Caffeine can give you a bit of extra energy. Before you work out, maybe have a coffee or two. If you’re in dire need of energy, you could have an energy drink or pre-workout drink instead.
- Whey protein makes it easier to hit your daily protein goals. Try to eat a balanced diet that’s rich in protein. But if you need 1–2 scoops of whey, that’s okay.
Alright, that’s it for now. If you want more muscle-building information, we have a free bulking newsletter for skinny guys. If you want a full foundational bulking program, including a 5-month full-body workout routine, diet guide, recipe book, and online coaching, check out our Bony to Beastly Bulking Program. Or, if you want a customizable intermediate bulking program, check out our Outlift Program.
Shane Duquette is the founder of Outlift, Bony to Beastly, and Bony to Bombshell, each with millions of readers. He's a Certified Conditioning Coach (CCC), has gained 70 pounds, and has over a decade of experience helping more than 15,000 people build muscle. He also has a degree in fine arts, but those are inversely correlated with muscle growth.
Marco Walker-Ng is the founder and strength coach of Outlift, Bony to Beastly, and Bony to Bombshell. He's a certified trainer (PTS) and nutrition coach (PN) with a Bachelor's degree in Health Sciences (BHSc) from the University of Ottawa. He has over 15 years of experience helping people gain muscle and strength, with clients including college, professional, and Olympic athletes.
Muscle-Building Mini-Course via EMAIL
Sign up for our 5-part muscle-building mini-course that covers everything you need to know about:
- Hardgainer genetics and how to make the most of them.
- How to take a minimalist approach to building muscle while still getting great results.
- What you need to know about aesthetics, health and strength while muscling up.
Hoping to join in 3 weeks. But thought I would suggest you give affiliate links to more than just bodybuilding.com – how about to Amazon as well – maybe at the end of the article?
That’s a good idea Dave. We’ve personally used Bodybuilding.com and enjoyed it, as did Albert, so we feel very comfortable recommending it to others.
Have you used Amazon in the past for this? Good experience? Reasonably fresh supplements? (Hard to tell sometimes, but they should have an expiration date.) I love Amazon for books, so I’d imagine they’d be good.
Looking forward to having you join the program!
Haven’t ordered any protein or supplements off amazon yet, but my experience with bodybuilding.com was good. Their optimum nutrition protein wasn’t old. I even tried their own casein protein — cookies and cream flavor. No complaints overall, and price is generally cheaper than name brand.
Another thing I like to do is go on slickdeals.net, the “hot deals” forum. Often people will post up good sales on whey protein (amongst a million other things). I just bought 10lbs of EAS whey protein for $44 shipped to my house in 2 days. That was a good deal.
Hey Shane-looking forward to signing up on Friday-I’m 134 pounds and over it really glad I found this site-there should be a biggest gainer show on tv I reckon 🙂 I am currently sourcing the supplements recommended by you guys as most suppliers on amazon won’t deliver to Australia found a few after some trawling so all good there bulknutrients.com.au and mrsupplements.com.au for future reference have different brands but ultimately the same products..just wondering what is included for the 197 as I think I am going to do this in phases-sign up,eat well,get my form right possibly with a few PT sessions in a gym I am going to join, get the supplements and start smashing out the beastly training program-what you think is this approach a good idea?
Ah that’s great AJ – I think you’ll really like it, and get a ton out of it 😀
Ahaha I agree! I’d watch that show. I would even volunteer to be the Bob or Jillian, but I suspect I’m a little too gentle hearted and nerdy for it. I’d be the guy saying “hey man no need to go crazy – let’s master your form. Research shows that you’ll build even more muscle even more quickly that way” or “psh yeah, go out for dinner with your friends, man – plenty of room for flexibility in a balanced muscle-building diet. Check this study out that shows that if 20% of your calories come from non-nutritious food sources you can still get maximal results!”
Probably wouldn’t make for very good TV 😉
Our contestants would look and feel AMAZING though haha.
Ah Marcel, our most active Australian, has been recommending bulknutrients.com.au to a lot of our Australian guys! He likes http://www.bulkpowders.com.au as well.
We tried our absolute best to include everything you’d need. We’ve got an eBook outlining all the fundamentals of eating and training for building muscle (along with some other great stuff), we’ve got a recipe book with a ton of strategies to make the nutrition side more achievable/enjoyable, we’ve got the training program (and we just revamped it / reshot all the videos!), and then there’s the community / coaching, where we can help you track your progress, overcome any hurdles, answer any questions, and tweak and adjust to get you optimum results. (Or you can quietly prowl around to see the thousands of answers I’ve written up to every question imaginable already.)
I would recommend doing it in this order:
1. Train b2B style. We’ve got strategies for mastering form as you go. (Could also get a PT to help you with it though, if you like!)
2. Get the nutrition more or less on track – we’ll teach you how to do that.
3. Rev up the calories so that you’re gaining weight.
4. Leisurely explore the more advanced techniques, strategies and supplements.
If you start a bulking diet before you start weightlifting you’ll just get chubby. Need the workouts to get your body actively trying to build muscle with the nutrients you’re giving it. Similarly, if you start with supplements before getting nutrition / training right … you’ll just be flushing money down the toilet.
If, on the other hand, you start with the weightlifting … the worst that could happen is that you get stronger without looking much stronger (neural adaptations), you improve your technique and posture and movement patterns, you accidentally get a little more ripped (by losing fat) or you build a bit of muscle (but perhaps not as much as you’d like). All good things. Then nutrition will supercharge that.
And then you can take it to the next level with the more advanced stuff … if you want. Can make amazing progress with just a solid mastering of training / nutrition fundamentals. No need to go more advanced unless you want to.
Does that help / make sense?
Really hope you decide to join us man 🙂
Actually I checked Amazon and they were more expensive, and ended up ordering from your link.
Ah that’s awesome Dave! Thanks. Let us know how you find it!
We’ve officially switched to Amazon! Your suggestion was a good one. We price-checked first and they’re competing wickedly well now. Nearly identical prices on each.
Perhaps more importantly … Amazon has a better selection. We’ve now upgraded the fish oil to one that includes Vitamin D. (Amazon’s probably more reliable, too.)
I’ve been following you guys for a while now, and noticed that you (primarily from the looks of it) focus on the muscletone of ectomorphs… with all those extra pounds of muscle and the tough workouts, do you also feel more energetic?
The reason I’m asking is because from what I notice with myself, I really need to do some serious cardio to even feel slightly more energetic (I get tired after 5 minutes of intense cardio-biking, so that says a lot on how bad my stamina is).
Correct. Our program is geared at making an impressive visual and strength transformation first and foremost. It’s about becoming big, strong, healthy, and having great alignment and posture to support it.
With that said, all of our workouts are functional, and Marco’s specialty is athletic performance and strength. His day job is training athletes. All of our workouts and nutrition advice should increase your performance—explosive performance. You’d be able to sprint much faster (football, basketball, running, soccer, etc) but not necessarily do a better job of running a marathon or long distance biking.
I personally found my stamina and energy levels went way up after strength training, and strength training is well known to be great for cardiovascular health.
If cardio work makes you feel better keep at it! We let our guys to cardio on their off-days if they enjoy it. It isn’t necessary to get results, but there’s no downside whatsoever, and many guys get a lot of value from it 🙂
Shane is right about the increase in explosive performance. I’ve noticed I can jump much higher and run much faster after completing most of the program.
Also, how many times do you actually work out on a weekly basis? I’ve read in one of your articles that it was every other day or so (correct me if I misread though)… does that mean your program is also specifically targetted to people able to go 3-4 times a week? 🙂
We train 3 times per week for a few reasons. Some guys add in cardio, sports and recreation in between, and if they enjoy it, we highly encourage it. Jared and I just do the 3 weekly strength workouts, whereas it’s rare to find Marco NOT doing something physical.
Is 3-4 times a week ideal for you?
Hah, I guess I still have too many questions… I’ll put it all in an email 🙂
I plan on putting some serious effort in my workouts when I’m back from my holiday (in 3-4 weeks). I have a new workout bench at home (I can do plenty of different full body exercises with it), so I was also hoping that that would also be enough… anyway, writing a rather large email again!
Sorry to bother you guys with them though 😉
No worries we like comments 🙂
Benches are definitely effective, and it’s absolutely possible to get great results using a homemade gym. Our program is designed for a gym, but it’s pretty easy to modify for guys training at home, and we help a few of our members do that.
Will starting out with push-ups, pull-ups, and sit-ups help a bit at the beginning of this program, or do I strictly need to start at a gym? I really don’t have the money right now for a gym membership so that’s why I’m asking.
If that is all you can do at the moment then yes! Anything is better than nothing. I would switch the situps to front and side planks as they tend to give you a bit more bang for your buck! It would also be helpful to throw in some bodyweight squats! hope that helps Nick!
Wouldn’t slurping regular rapeseed and olive oil have the same effect or is the Omega 3 concentration so much lower?
Fats can get confusing. Olive oil is an incredible source of monounsaturated fat (omega 9), and you should definitely eat plenty. Monos should make up about 1/3 of your fats.
Saturated should make up the second third. That’ll likely happen naturally. And then you get into the polyunsaturated fats:
Rapeseed is polyunsaturated, but has twice as much omega 6s as 3s, which isn’t ideal. We already get too many omega 6s from nuts, bread, cereals, poultry and vegetable oils.
Fish oil is an omega 3, which is great on its own, but a ton of the advantages come from the high concentrations of EPA and DHA 🙂
If you’re a vegan and can’t take fish oil then opt for flax oil instead, which is also an omega 3.
Hope that helps!
Thanks. I did a little more reading and it seems the main difference between flax and fish oil is the DHA and EPA. Flax contains ALA only which has to be converted into DHA/EPA by your body and apparantly it’s not so good at it. But ALA is also needed for other fat conversions, so I probably try out 2 spoons of fishoil and add another of flax to get them all.
I just hope this won’t make digesting all the kalories even uglier.
You don’t need to get neurotic about fats. You likely already eat plenty of saturated fats and omega 6s, so if you make a conscious effort to eat olive oil and then supplement with fish oil (or flax) you’ll be doing stellar.
It’s not like we measure out our fats or anything. Our bodies are pretty good at taking care of themselves if you give them the rough ingredients they need.
Great article Shane.
2 questions:
Do you guys not use say a post workout and pre workout drink and just have the one mentioned in the article during working out instead?
Also have you guys come across Udos Choice Oil Blend for your fats and if so do you think this could replace what you have specified in this article?
Correct. That one monster of a shake is the pre, intra and post workout drink.
Udo’s is a great balanced source of fats, so if you like it definitely take it. It wouldn’t replace anything on this list though. You’d still want the EPA and DHA rich fish oil. If you had to pick one or the other go for the NutraSea.
Hey Guys, i have a few questions before i sign up. It seems as if this has been what i have been looking for. Im 20 years old now and have only been working out seriously for about 4-5 months. i have gained about 5lbs of muscle but would really like to gain another 20 or so on top of that, it just seems like im stuck now though. You can see the difference in mostly my arms. should i do my same workout and start drinking your drink during and see if that helps? any tips?
I am only 134 lbs now and 5’10” to put it into perspective. I use a pullup bar, dumbells, and my own body weight for my worksouts (pushups, dips, etc) and i primarily refer to this workout
That’s a good question. That workout looks pretty quick, pretty light, and doesn’t work your entire body, so you’d probably want to calm down with the workout drink dosage. Maybe take a single dose instead of a double or triple.
Hehe and make sure to also do a leg workout! Nothing will make you grow more than also hitting your legs, especially with squats and deadlifts. You’ll wind up with a way way better looking and stronger body everywhere. Your entire posterior chain will be much more powerful (back, butt, legs), as well as your arms, shoulders, and grip strength.
(I deleted the upper body circuit video you posted, as it was glitching out our comment box)
I hope you decide to join us man!
Hi Guys,
I’ve been following you quite from the beginning on the foxhound website. After long long time researching myself I think your program fits the gap, great work. With 169 lbs and 6,45 ft I think I´m facing a challenge. Because I´m a vegetarian on the way to vegan I would like to know, If you are planning some tips or if you have some user experiences with special veg diet plans? Do you know if vegan protein (soy, rice, wheat) supplements are as effective as the the animals proteins – like whey – are?
Thank you very much for some help, and again: great work.
mark
We’ve got a few vegetarian members who are doing great. There a million and one easy options for vegetarians. You can follow our diet verbatim as a vegetarian, as it’s flexible to begin with.
Vegans are a trickier beast, and we currently only have one vegan member. I have a feeling he’ll do fantastic, but he only joined just last week, so I can’t really report on his progress yet.
Good question! Soy protein comes from monocultures and is heavily processed, so stay away from that one. Lots of problems associated with it. (Fermented soy, like soy sauce, is okay.) Wheat I actually don’t know anything about, which makes me think it’s neither great nor disastrous. Rice protein is awesome, and that’s what our vegan member is using. He has it enriched with BCAAs, too, which makes it fantastic for strength training and building muscle mass. It’s very comparable to whey protein.
Vega also makes a “sport” protein supplement which is very effective for building muscle, but our vegan has informed us that it tastes … not too good.
You may want to supplement with vitamin b12 and flax as well, as vegan diets are low in those nutrients.
I’d love to have you join the program! I’ll be the first to admit that I’m no vegan expert, but I’d be glad to offer my two cents and help out in any way I can 🙂
Hey, thanks for the fast and detailed information, helped a lot, especially the info about the rice and the negative issues about soy. Unfortunately, my currently Work/Lifestyle makes it hard to start the full programm, but I will change that soon and I´m “warming up” ´til then now.
Thanks
Mark
+1 on supplementing B12, here‘s an article that discusses problems with vegan diets, you may wanna read it. Maybe also throw in some coconut oil just so you get at least some amount of saturated fat, which the body needs to make cholesterol, which in turn the body needs to make testosterone. And maybe some linseed oil as well to get your omega-3.
But still I don’t see why you’d want to go vegan (or vegetarian). Sure there are problems with meat production (environmental, ethical), but cutting it altogether seems a bit extreme. Better to reduce consumption and eat organic if circumstances (e.g. budget) allow for it.
Most of us agree that processed foods are not too good, but isolated protein and supplements (the only way to get adequate protein as a veggie) are exactly that. I’ve been a vegetarian from age 10-17, I can testify that it did not do me very good. Now I eat a small portion of meat once or twice a week, some fish on top of that, and lots of (organic) eggs, and feel a lot better now that I do.
I calculated the monthly costs in the case of taking the amount you recommend: about 50€ jeez 😀
Want to add a question: are the 197 USD for the program to be payed a single time? Or is it some monthly fee or something?
Just one payment 🙂
Ooo but did you contrast it against the same number of calories coming from similar whole foods? All of these, except for the creatine, replace nutrients that you’d otherwise need to consume in the form of regular food!
Hey Shane! Very interesting article. I was interested to know your measurements for this monster shake. I see you have 90g protein, 180g dextrose, and 15g creatine, but do you take this with water? If so, how many ounces? Let me know man 🙂
That’s a very good question. I fill up my water bottle with as much water as I can, which is around 12-16 oz. If you find you’re thirsty, which is quite common, you can bring along a second water bottle with just water in it. Hope that helps!
That doesn’t sound like it would dissolve at all. I use 30 g of whey protein in 8 oz and it’s fairly thick, triple that while only doubling the volume and add in the sugar and creatine, sounds like sludge.
It can be pretty sludgy, yeah, but it does dissolve! You can always, of course, use more water. Or divide it up into three servings (1/3 before, 1/3 during, 1/3 after).
I’m not going to lie though — it isn’t a fun drink to drink. It’s a lot of calories and it hits your stomach like a brick.
Works wonders at producing lean muscle mass though.
hey shane! i also have an ectomorphic body, i want to follow your supplement intakes, just want to ask if can i use Serious Mass (optimum nutrition) instead of Gold standard whey protein (Optimum Nutrition) ?
Hey Ian,
Yep! You could use Serious Mass instead of the WHOLE workout shake. The weight gainer has all the carbs you’d need, so no need to add dextrose. It’s perhaps slightly less effective than our mix, but that’s hard to say, and the difference would be very negligible. The reason we don’t use it is because it costs around $10 a serving, whereas ours costs around $2. (Cheaper than food.)
Serious Mass tastes much better though!
Outside of your workout shake I wouldn’t use gainers. Stick to whole food or smoothies instead. Healthier, and you’ll get better results.
Hope that helps, and good luck!
Hi Shane, great work as always. Quick question: Can I use cornstarch as my source of maltodextrin? If so, I’m using the scoop from my ON whether protein. Is 3 scoops of cornstarch enough for a mid sized 152 pound ectomorph?
Maybe! However generally you want to use something that’s made to be consumed raw and in sizeable amounts.
Flour, while theoretically fine to eat raw, is expected to be cooked. As a result the packaging rules are less stringent, and if you eat it raw you risk consuming bacteria inadvertently. With tuna, if you eat a couple cans per week it’s fantastic for you. If you eat several cans each day you’ll get mercury poisoning.
Corn starch is presumably designed to be eaten cooked and in smaller quantities, so I can’t say that you won’t run into an issue.
(In a pinch just use whey protein and eat some fruit. I find a couple pre-workout bananas work well.)
Wow I didn’t know that. Great point, glad I asked you first, whew. Thank you so much man. I really appreciate the advice.
I figure I should give you some more details, since this stuff can get really confusing. The number one ingredient in Serious Mass is maltodextrin, which is their equivalent of dextrose. Very similar, except it’s a starch, making it more similar to flour. It’s one of the cheapest ingredients you can buy, and it allows them to list a sugar content of nearly 0. Since people are scared of sugar on nutrition labels this is a plus for them. And that’s fine — maltodextrin contains glucose just like dextrose does, just in disaccharide form. Our body will use it in exactly the same way. No advantage or disadvantage here, just a different way of accomplishing the same thing.
Next up on the ingredient list is a blend of protein. The reason why I prefer our homemade blend here is that we use a whey protein isolate. The purity is much higher. They use a blend consisting of whey concentrate + calcium caseinate in Serious Mass. Not quite as good.
All that is relatively minor though. The main difference is that you’re paying like $8 for a couple scoops of sugar, which should cost you pennies.
Wow , thank you Shane! That’s a big help! you’re a Genius. This site is awsome. I will refer this site to all my gym buddies so they can learn also the truth about training and supplements. Thanks!
Hey bro shane, i got this 12lbs serious mass and 5lbs Gold standard whey as a birthday gift from my uncle, can i use whey along this serious mass? Just want to ask how to use these 2 type of supplements, how and when to take it? Thanks bro,
Niice.
Serious Mass makes a good intra-workout drink, so you could drink it during or right after training. The protein content is a little low, so you could drop the dose of serious mass a bit and add in some whey. You’d want to do it so that you get the carb/protein ratio listed up above in the protocol (with total calories depending on your bodytype and goals).
You can also take the whey along with meals where the protein content is low. Ideally in that case you’d mix with with milk, to slow down your digestion a bit.
Hope that helps Stephen!
thank you shane! i’m also planning to buy creatine powder and fish oil, im an ectomorph an i want to gain fast just like you. i will drink serious mass in the morning, and then serious mass again pre or intra work out with creatine owder on it, then whey protein post work out. and in bed time, serious mass before going to bed. is that ok?
I would just use the serious mass while/after working out. Maltodextrin, the main ingredient in serious mass, is basically just flour, so having it for breakfast and pre-bed wouldn’t be great for your health. Might result in some fat gains too.
There are a lot of complex issues as to why, but as a basic rule you want lots of vitamin-rich foods that digest at a steady pace. Serious Mass is like having a slice of cake with a whey shake on the side.
If you like having shakes versus regular meals, I’d suggest blending up some whole foods, like fruit and dairy, instead of the weight gainer.
oh i see, good thing i ask you first before jumping into actions, thank you so much shane! i will follow your advice.
Hey Shane what you think about casein protein before going to sleep? Is for us ectomorphs important or it dont worth that money and is better to eat some cottage cheese instead for example ?
Actually I bet casein protein is cheaper than cottage cheese. Protein powders are actually usually a pretty good price compared with whole food.
Cottage cheese would be more ideal, but probably a bit more expensive.
Greek yogurt is great, too, and also packed full of casein. It has tons of probiotics in it, which are great for ectomorphs trying to digest more food than their bodies are used to. It’s expensive though. Start mixing in berries and stuff, to make it taste better, and it gets even more expensive.
Eggs are another good source of pre-bed protein. So is milk. The sugars in milk digest extremely slowly, too, making them a great source of pre-bed carbs.
You can eat anything before bed though. So long as you plan on having breakfast at a reasonable hour it won’t matter too too much!
Hope that helps Matthew!
I’m an ectomorph weighting 155 pounds and currently have a large meal consisting of meats, mixed veg, and sweet potato about 1 hour and 15 minutes before I hit the gym. Currently I have 60g of dextrose and 35g of isolated protein straight m workout.
Should I have a 90g protein, and 180g dextrose instead split 1/3 before work out, 1/3 during and 1/3 after or instead have 60g protein and 120g dextrose due to my large meal before work out and have 1/2 during workout and 1/2 after workout? Thanks.
I’d do the double instead of the triple … if you have no problem getting in your daily calories. That pre-workout meal sounds pretty great, so if your diet consists mostly of vitamin-rich whole foods like that you should be pretty good.
If you aren’t eating enough though or struggle to, switch to a triple dose.
I eat well … but when trying to quickly build muscle I still have a huge 3x workout shake. My appetite isn’t that hefty, so even though the workout shake isn’t the most pleasant thing I’ve ever had, it helps me out a ton. These days I’ve actually grown kind of fond of it, since it seems so closely associated with my being able to consistently up my weight.
Hope that helps, Craig! Good luck!
Great article man! I’ve read a lot that just aren’t as straight to the point as yours was, so thank you for saving my time!
I am currently 70kg guy and I’m really into running long distances but now want to bulk up for football. Would it be possible to just have post workout supplements because I’m a bit low on cash so can’t afford it all, what would be the best thing to buy? Thanks!
Yep, you could buy something like Universal Torrent and take a 2-3x dose! It isn’t, however, a money-saver. Buying the ingredients separately and mixing them yourself is the most cost-efficient way to go.
The main reason for this is that when you buy pre-mixed formulas you’re paying quite a bit for the carbs, where all you’re really eating is sugar/starch. It shouldn’t be any more expensive than, say, rice. By buying the dextrose separately you’re keeping your carb costs ridiculously low, and only really paying for the protein, which is always expensive, whether you’re buying whey or chicken.
Universal Torrent tastes a whole hell of a lot better though!
And keep in mind that money spent here you’d have to spend anyway—on food. It isn’t adding costs to your life, simply replacing grocery store costs with supplement costs.
Hope this helps you kick ass on the football field!
Quick question – is the “couple of tablespoons” thing with the fish oil a typo?
It seems to me that if you want 2g EPA and 1.5g DHA, you’d need only 1 tbsp. According to the label, in a 1 tsp. serving, you get 750mg EPA and 500mg DHA. So, you’re looking for 3 TEAspoons to hit that 2g and 1.5g. This is equivalent to one tbsp. Or did I miss something?
I only ask because this stuff is so pricey, one versus 3 tbsp / day makes a big difference. You’re only getting 33 1-tbsp servings out of the 500mL, $38 bottle. At 3-tbsp / day, you’d need 3 bottles per month.
Thanks!
*correction
I noticed that the article says 2 tbsp, one morning one night, not 3. Still, don’t we only need one tbsp to get to that 2g EPA 1.5g DHA?
Gah no you didn’t misunderstand. Kitchen fail on my part—I’m going to switch it to read teaspoons, not tablespoons.
Taking 2 tablespoons would be great for you too, but it’s beyond the point of diminishing returns, and certainly wouldn’t be necessary to get killer results.
Thank you for catching that!
Hi Shane,
Thanks for your information packed articles! What are your thoughts on adding AAKG to the training drink? I have seen numerous proponents supporting AAKG specifically for ectomorphs. What say you?
Arginine? That’s a good question. I’m going to give you a bit of a long answer, but the main reason we didn’t include it is that we feel the results are too insignificant to be worth it.
There are too solid studies I know of looking into this, and one of them uses very similar conditions to the concoction we’re recommending.
The first found that there were sliiiight power improvements with the arginine, but they were so slight that it was considered
“statistically insignificant”. (study)
The second found that arginine did not change the “hemodynamic and vascular response” to training, i.e., it doesn’t accomplish what it promises to. (study)
Considering that arginine is a performance enhancer, and not a muscle builder, it doesn’t really jive with the purpose of our drink, which is muscle gains, not improved energy/power while lifting. Caffeine would be the ultimate supplement for performance enhancement there, making coffee or an energy drink a great choice. These won’t improve your gains, but they might make the experience more enjoyable.
If you want to really geek out you could check out this review into arginine, which basically says that regular protein (or BCAAs) contain everything that arginine offers and more, making arginine a poor supplement when you could use protein instead. (review)
My recommendation is to save your money. (At least until further research is done!)
I hope that helps!
As an ectomorph’s I naturally have a fast metabolism which means I burn calories very quick. Do you think it would be better as to have other weight gainer supplements during the day to add more calories to my diet?
I think there are much better alternatives when it comes to trying to eat more calories, even if you have a small appetite.
The whole food equivalent of a weight gainer would be something like a fruit/protein smoothie, and that’d be much healthier and give you way better results. I wouldn’t be surprised if it was cheaper too, considering how expensive weight gainers can be (considering you’re basically buying flour and protein powder).
A really cheap alternative is a simple PB&J sandwich. Whole grain bread, natural peanut butter and your favourite type of jam. Bonus points for peanut butter and banana sandwich instead.
I’m Blessed this morning! I’ve been on so many different protein powders, weight gaines did wonders to help me get to my small body frame goal of 105-107, however, it caused fat weight in my Gut(48) woman & bloat. I started using regular protein powders mixing it with Almond/Coconut milk, which is fine, but NOW Loosing weight again. SO MANY website promoting their products. I’ve got upset stomach from a few of the whey powders, some not. I just bought Dymitize Isolate, but little anything in it. I don’t want to go back to the Weight Gainers, but I need to keep easy weight gain on me. Busy travel lifestyle. HELP, I relate to what you are saying. I also started loosing definition & small layer of fat over it. HELP? I eat pretty clean, but never know if I’m eating enough. I feel up pretty quickly, but breakfast is my best meal of the day. Thanks so much for this AWESOME site. You know what you are talking about, that is why I am reaching out for help in what you say. I take Creatine, BCAA, FIsh Oils, L-Glutamine, CLA, I need to put on more muscle gain, but fearful of the weight gainers shakes again with such high carb content. As I have to watch for no Pre-Diabetes.I had instance two years ago. Fine now, but Im only 5’2″ and want to maintain 105-107 Lean Muscle tone, not fat weight. As I said, Im down to 102 and not happy I’ve lost. Bless you & all that have great knowledge. Goin to a health food store, it like No Help, they don’t really know.
I sense that there is a question in there … but I must admit that I’m struggling to find it.
Hello, I am ectomorphic and tired of it. I stumbled upon this blog in my quest to gain muscle. With reference to the supplements listed in this blog:
1. Should I mix the whey protein and dextrose powder before a workout, during a workout, after a workout or all of the above?
2. How should I attempt to consume creatine on a daily basis? Should I mix it with any liquids I consume?
3. Could I purchase any of these listed supplements at my local nutrition store (such as GNC), as I don’t feel like waiting for them to ship to my apartment? If so, what brands of these supplements do you prefer?
Thank you in advance for the response.
1. All of the above is good. I drink it all during my workout, but 1/3 before, 1/3 during and 1/3 after is probably the ideal.
2. Yep. You can mix it with anything. Tea, coffee, water, etc. You only need a few grams a day.
3. Yes sir! And most of the brands we list you should be able to find at the local GNC. That’s where I get my stuff when I don’t think ahead.
but of course you will most likely save a lot of money ordering online over local GNC.
Hello, I just stumbled across this blog and it’s exactly what I’ve been looking for, I am going to try and follow your supplements however I am from Australia so am struggling to find them, another thing, I read somewhere about a payment plan, I am interested if it’s still available?
Cheers.
Right on Sean! It’s a tough monster to drink, but the results are undeniable.
We’ve had a few Australians sign up recently – I’ve heard the head down under is brrrutal! You Aussies seem to kick ass at this, too. Some great transformations going on down there!!
Regarding the payment plan, shoot me an email at us@bonytobeastly.com and I’ll give you the details 🙂
yo yo yo this sounds awesome brother! not able to run “gear” because I am joining the police academy in 2 years and they polygraph about that kind of stuff. I used to run PH’s and just eat healthy foods all day and train twice a day, gained 40lbs lean muscle in 1 month! But it had it’s very horrible side effect. Saving money, energy, and my body using this post! Takes a bit longer then the banned PH gods, but it is a hell of a lot safer. Keep up the good work my dude!
Glad you like it, man! We’re fans of doing this naturally, and I’m pumped to see that you’re getting into it! As far as we’re concerned it’s well worth it, and so long as you aren’t trying to be Coleman you’ll still make a pretty beastly cop. Won’t need a custom made uniform, either 😉
Hey,
i was one of those really skinny guys and couldn’t gain weight at all so i finally decided to join the gym. I was 46 kg’s, 5’9 when i joined and now after 6 months of lifting i’m now 56 kg’s ! Till now all i have gained is because of a natural, high calorie diet with protein rich vegetarian food (pulses, nuts, cheese etc), eggs and a very basic protein supplement powder (32 gms normal protein per 100 gms)
I have gained significantly in my chest, decently in my back and have increased my tricep’s lifting capacity (although they still don’t look very big). My problem is that i do not gain in my arms, even though i pay full attention to them and they are still very thin. I don’t want to use whey protein and mass gainers (i take a good enough diet). I have a few questions and would be really obliged to get a response from you on them:
1.Can i use only creatine ?
2.Does it also help in muscle building and getting bigger, apart from providing energy to get those extra reps ?
3.If i use creatine, how much quantity is safe and sufficient ?
4.When should it be used before or after the workout ?
5.Is the loading phase necessary ?
6.Does the ability to lift more and size of muscles reduce if i stop taking it ?
7.And lastly, what are it’s side effects ? Is it hard to digest like whey protein ?
P.S i’m 20 years of age
@Sushant
5 grams pre and post workout, technically the loading faze is not needed but recommended for ectomorphs.Not really any side effects just drink a gallon of water a day and you’ll be all good dude. I’d recommend getting 100% whey isolate for post workout to mix with creatine, also I’d recommend getting a pre workout to mix your creatine with like jack3d or super pump. Creatine is a really good supp for natural lifters you just gotta stay consistent with it to see results.
Hey Will, thanks a lot for your reply mate.
You recommended me to get a pre & post workout mix as well whey but i’m actually a little hesitant using any powders right now. I had started taking Universal’s Whey Pro sometime back and it didn’t suit me much (maybe because i’m lactose intolerant) and i couldn’t get any results. Since then i’m a little worried about taking them but once i feel i’m ready to give them a shot i’d definitely go for exactly what you recommended. Creatine on the other hand i read is completely natural and found in red meat, but since i’m a vegetarian, my diet would certainly lack the sufficient quantity of it that is needed and i feel i should make up for it with a creatine supplement. Can i just go for creatine without any other pre/post workout mix and whey ?
I already have 6 eggs, protein biscuits, nuts and a very basic protein supplement (as i mentioned before) along with other protein rich food. So that makes up for about 55-60 gms of protein daily. Before workout i have 2 bananas, 2 eggs, 2 protein biscuits and almonds and immediately after workout i have 2 bananas along with the protein supplement (mixed with whole milk), 2 protein biscuits, 2 eggs and a high carb meal 2 hours later. Can i just add 5 grms of creatine to this diet ?
Hey Sushant – cool questions. First off, congrats on the 10kg! That’s a pretty sweet accomplishment. You must be pumped!
1. Yep. Vegetarian diets are low in creatine (it’s found in meat) so that could help for sure!
2, 3, 4, 5, 7. Check out the creatine section for details about what it does (it does a lot beyond helping with reps), and check out the protocol at the end of the article for how to take it. No need to mix it with anything or get all fancy with it.
6. The swelling your muscles will have from the water uptake that creatine causes will disappear (slowly) when you stop taking it, yes … but that’s not why you take it in the first place. The muscle and strength GAINS you make as a result of training/eating while taking creatine will stick around.
It seems like your real question is how to increase your arm size though, and that’s a whole different ballgame! Creatine won’t cause your arms to grow a disproportionate pace compared to the rest of your body, after all, so it sounds like what you need to do is:
a) Increase your weight on the scale by adding muscle to your frame.
b) Encourage more of that added muscle to be in your arms by increasing the training volume with your arms.
So, more chin ups, yates bent over rows, cable curls, tricep extensions, close grip pushups, etc. You could try tossing in some really high rep stuff too (50-100 reps) to build up some vascularity (if you like veins in your biceps) + get your body to store more glycogen in there (temporary, but visually impressive). And whatever you do don’t neglect your steak and potato lifts! (Squats, deads, bench, chins, carries, planks, etc.)
Hey Shane, thanks a lot for all that information man. You guys are doing an amazing work with this site, kudos to you for that. I live in Delhi, India and unfortunately the body building industry here hasn’t yet become very professional. We have a lot of gyms here but sadly not many knowledgeable trainers, so there are a lot of us here looking for professional help in trying to understand our body better and gain and this site with people like you are doing a tremendous job. Thank you for that !
You cleared almost all my doubts about creatine and i might be going for it soon after gaining a little more weight. I followed your advice about the arm training and am waiting for some good results.
And now I’ll be coming back very often to ask u lot more questions, clear my doubts and ask for advice which might help me improve my training and getting better results.
Cheers man ! 🙂
Hi, as I am from Australia I can’t find anywhere to get the allmax creatine, I was just wondering if dymatize creatine is a suitable substitute? Sorry on my phone so can’t work out how to copy in website.
@Sean
Go on bodybuilding.com you’ll ALLMAX Nutrition supplements there and even better creatine supplements for decent prices, and they ship to you. Buying products at shops is usually a rip off, trust me I worked at one for awhile Jesus would we sell supps for super high prices lol. Good luck with your supplement search brotha.
Yep Will’s right – it’s often expensive to get supplements at supplement stores. Luckily creatine is often relatively low in price, so you could probably still get a few months supply for a decent price.
Dymatize is cool, yep. 100% micronized monohydrate – exactly what you want.
If you’re buying a few things though you’ll probably save a bunch by ordering. Depends how much of a time pinch you’re in though, and how much saving a bit of money matters!
180 grams of dextrose is 45x the recommended serving size; is that right? It seems like you were only tripling the dose of whey and creatine….
Great site by the way. I just stumbled upon it after getting a gym membership and looking into supplements.
Yeah, we take quite a bit of dextrose. Keep in mind that we’re quite ectomorphic and doing fairly involved strength training. You can still do great with a much smaller dosage!
And I’m glad you’re digging it 🙂
hmm, where did you guys get your ideas to use dextrose? It sounds like it could be pretty dangerous on blood sugar levels…do you have a study reference?
Lately, I’ve preferred working out on an empty stomach. I believe the blood needs to occupy the muscle instead of aiding in digestion, but to each their own.
I’m not completely biased here…I may give this article some more thought.
Hey Brandon, that’s a really really good question.
Check out some of the studies linked in the dextrose section regarding the effectiveness of the protocol. I see what you’re saying about it being a pretty devilish prank to play on our blood sugar levels – and you’re right. When thinking of blood sugar we need to think not so much about the glycemic index and more so about the glycemic load, i.e., the quantity of quickly digested things and also how it compares to the quantity of slowly digested things in our system. You’ve probably done this and come to the horrifying conclusion that whey protein + dextrose consumed in isolation and in large quantities will absolutely spike our insulin. And your conclusion is correct – it will.
Let’s put that on hold for a moment.
You’re also correctly pointing out that blood should occupy the muscle when training. This drink won’t stop that, and that’s easy enough to test. Pump out some bicep curls at the end of your next workout and, with the help of this drink or not, you’ll pump that muscle up with blood.
Now let’s consider the role of insulin – it transports glucose, amino acids and fatty acids into our muscle cells (and other cells). By spiking our blood sugar levels and then sending all that blood into our muscles we’re creating the ultimate muscle-building scenario. We’re loading ourselves up with nutrients and then shooting those nutrients exactly where we want them to be used: our soon-to-be-bigger muscles.
This is why the studies show such rad results.
You’re worried about our health though, and that’s a very valid concern. We’re on the same page as you, too, as we think a rad physique should accurately indicate a healthy physique. This would have a negative impact on your health if you were shooting all these nutrients into fat cells, but we’re instead shooting them into muscle cells, and thus insulin is working how we want it too: as an anabolic hormone. And the healthier and more insulin sensitive you are, the better this technique will work. That’s why we recommend higher doses for the ripped ectomorphs, not the skinny-fat ones.
Will this reduce your sensitivity to insulin? No, it shouldn’t, unless you were taking it frequently (a few times a week is fine) or you were becoming obese from it. Plus, it’s maintaining high blood sugar levels that blunt insulin sensitivity, not never spiking it. (As always, though, your health is in your hands, so follow the advice of your physician!)
Does that answer your question?
Yes, it pretty much does answer my question.
One more thing. Are you advocating that this concoction is a big secret to adding weight to your muscles? Is this one of the major catalysts to quick weight gain targeted at the muscles?
I’ve researched that for every pound of muscle you gain comes with it a pound of glycogen (or
water weight) and fat. I’d have to assume that’s what the explosive weight is in the form of, not pure muscle.
Is there a reputable supplement that contains dextrose, casein and whey (or similar equivalents)?
Tons and tons of them! They’re expensive as hell though. One I recommend is Universal Torrent, just keep in mind that you may need to adjust your serving size!
Hi Shane,
I only comment on this post because it was the one that lead me to this site, I’ve been all over this site. I’m not sure if you understand the holy grail this site seems to be after never gaining and exhausted research. And after reading many of the other posts about posture and ratios and watching some videos etc… I still wanted to ask you a question. I lifted all throughout high school and then some and never gained (hence finding your awesome site) then a gym accident and I stopped going around the age of 20. I turned 23 little over a month ago and have decided to go back to the gym and incorporate it into my lifestyle as I believe yes it does in general lead to a better life and happiness. To the question. I broke my left arm at the age of 14 and I have a slight labrum tear in my left shoulder and my growth plate in my humerus (bone that connects shoulder to elbow, I’m sure you know but just in case) on that arm fused and my left arm is slightly shorter than the right and the left shoulder sits a little higher. I know that you arent a doctor but you seem like a pretty smart guy. I am just curious as to your input on the arm situation in terms of symmetry and alignment and how you think it may develop in comparison to my right arm.
And the Dr. told me the fuse meant the arm wont grow much more if at all. I dont know if that means in length or density or altogether. I also dont know if the growth plate on my humerus has anything to do with the growth of the rest of the bones in that arm like the bones in my forearms, wrists, and hands. I just figure the more info I give you the better you are able to get an idea. And sometimes I do notice differences when using an olympic bar for say some wrist curls or regular curls the bar will not be straight. I know there are dumbbells and cables but I dont want to cut out exercise where I have to use both hands on one bar. I am just kind of stumped as to the best route to take with it.
First off, thanks for the kind words! Glad you dig our style.
Second, everyone has their challenges, limitations and setbacks. While it might feel like you’re different because of your funky shoulders … you’d actually be more unique if you were totally symmetrical and uninjured! Jared has super damaged knees from skateboarding + severe tendonitis (from computer nerding), Marco has a ton of issues from sports and weightlifting, and I’ve got a shoulder that used to like to dislocate (which building up muscles via weightlifting fixed). If you play sports or lift weights you’ll eventually run into a problem (while also probably living a very healthy overall life) and if you stay safe and sedentary you’ll likely run into a slew of dastardly health problems from being inactive along with a bunch of imbalances from spending so much time sitting. Anyway, life takes a toll on us, and that’s not necessarily bad, so long as you get the most out of life while you’re at it!
As for your shoulder being higher … are you certain that has to do with your injury? Everyone has a higher left shoulder – and I mean everyone. This has to do with asymmetrical organs and innards, and how that affects our breathing.
There was ways to “fix” it and develop a more symmetrical torso, but that’s hardly the norm. Jared, Marco and I all have high left shoulders, as do 99% of our members!
And regarding whether your arm will grow symmetrically with your other arm … that’s a very good question. I would go with your doctors advice on that one, as he presumably knows your situation (and the human body) far better, and work with a coach or personal trainer while you train. We can do that online if you like – we’d love to have you, and Marco has tons of experience dealing with injured dudes – or you could seek out a more local expert 🙂
Does that help at all?
No, thank you. And yes your information does indeed help. As far as the shoulder sitting higher that could be I just dont know if the growth plate ties into muscle or tendon growth as well, just something I will have to look into. I am looking into getting a second opinion on it for sure. As far as joining I would like to but at the moment I am a little strapped for cash as in I couldnt even offer you the $200 to do a couple weeks and then do money back but when i do have more cash flow I am definitely interested if time allows (new career choice is a little rocky but it makes me happy). And also yeah I see what you mean about muscle building helping to keep the shoulder in place because it only popped out once while i was in high school and doing padded football almost everyday with people bigger than I and we also had to lift just about every day. And now it cant even hold up in a game of sandlot? Definitely a defining moment in wanting to take my fitness life back on the right track. I checked out the creatine, dextrose, whey, and fish oil and will probably be purchasing that and giving the super drink a try at least due to it being amazingly low in price and actually may be even better for me in general considering whats on the rest of the market. I just finished some Intek evolution protein powder that Lou Ferrigno at total nutrition recommended when I went in asking for the equivalent of a product I used to take and saying that was the same thing but this just has more natural vitamins and it tastes good even after I said I dont care about taste just how it affects my body in terms of health and results. But I am pretty positive he just looked at my size (males subconsciously judging other males based on shoulders etc…) and figured I was a January resolution monther and just wanted me to buy what he needed to sell. So I would rather buy from people who actually care about what they are telling people to put into their body. I can at least use your links to throw some kickback your guys way. I would like to get the largest amounts possible from those sites but like I said a little strapped lol. So I will probably get 1000 grams of creatine, two lbs of dextrose, two lbs of whey, and 200 mL of fish oil for around $100. I would love to discuss more and more like how I workout and where the hell you guys go and jump in water with icebergs in it and everything but hopefully I will be able to in the near future. Thanks for all your help and if you have anymore you feel like offering please go right ahead haha. Have a good one.
[…] this is the absolute cheapest way to crush 1000 calories of body-building nutrients. We designed our home-made workout drink for results above all else, and it’s just an added bonus that the ingredients are so […]
So you rate universal torrent better than optimum serious mass then? Or would i be better of just starting with the gold standard 100% whey (even though it has no casein/dextrose)
Hey Shane, thanks a lot for all that information man. You guys are doing an amazing work with this site, kudos to you for that. I live in Delhi, India and unfortunately the body building industry here hasn’t yet become very professional. We have a lot of gyms here but sadly not many knowledgeable trainers, so there are a lot of us here looking for professional help in trying to understand our body better and gain and this site with people like you are doing a tremendous job. Thank you for that !
You cleared almost all my doubts about creatine and i might be going for it soon after gaining a little more weight. I followed your advice about the arm training and am waiting for some good results.
And now I’ll be coming back very often to ask u lot more questions, clear my doubts and ask for advice which might help me improve my training and getting better results.
Cheers man !
Right on man, good luck packing on some muscle! Look forward to hearing about your progress 🙂
Shane-
Great read dude, Checking in here from Los Angeles. Just came across this website on Sunday and I’ve been reading all the articles. I really dig ectomorph fitness articles, as long as they’re written by actual ectomorphs, which upon thorugh reading, I can see is the case. There’s just some things only another ectomorph would know or understand, and you guys obviously understand and have dealt with these issues personally. Honestly, every single thing you described in the video (on the product description page) has been a feeling or experience that I have gone through personally. Props to you for speaking the truth.
I’ve been training for 5+ years but I’m just working my way back from a year long battle with Crohn’s Disease, where I fell from 6’2, 173 lbs to 147. I wasn’t able to work out in the gym for the entire 2012, so 2013 is my redemption year. This is my first month back in the gym and I’m back up to 160 after 4 weeks of training, solely from compound lifts.
Just ordered my Dextrose, Creatine, and Protein from the links and I’m pumped to get started with that. I used to make a similar drink with gatorade/juice instead of dextrose, but hopefully this will be a little more efficient and better tasting. Should be a lot better and more legitimate.
As far as the program, I’m curious. Gonna have a sample sent to my email from the product description page. I’ve been working out with mostly compound lifts for the last couple years, with decent success, and they’re pretty much all I believe in, for the most part. But the program I use (Stronglifts) is not necessarily tailored specifically to ectomorphs. It works, but I feel if it was more personalized, I could legitimately have a chance to reach my goal of 185 lbs, with a nice body (not a fat ass).. I’m wondering if you guys have ever seen Stronglifts, and some of the key differences from you program and Stronglifts? I’m tempted to join your program, but just want to know a brief outline of how it’s structured.
Otherwise, great work guys. Thanks for keeping it real on your site. Hope to hear back from you soon.
-Jay
First off congrats on the gains! Everyone runs into a challenge at some point, and I’m really glad to hear that it sounds like you’re already overcoming yours! That’s a huge accomplishment man. Congratulations!
That’s a very good question, and I have to admit I don’t know much about Stronglifts. I mean, know a lot about 5×5 training plans, and strength training in general … but not much about the Stronglifts brand.
I gave the site a look and it looks like classic strength training, which is pretty badass. It’s not tailored for ectomorphs, no, but strength training has positive effects on nearly everyone, as you know obviously know 🙂
I’m a fellow 6’2 ectomorph who’s gone from 130 to 190ish so I can definitely relate to your goals and your struggles!
Let me try to answer your question as best I can, but go easy on me, as I’m only guessing based on a cursory look through the Stronglifts material. I can’t really pinpoint differences, but here are some things you may love:
1. We’re a program for naturally skinny guys – ectomorphs. I find it’s a pretty different perspective, and we run into some unique challenges, both with nutrition and training. We also have some cool things we can take ADVANTAGE of. I don’t see being an ectomorph as being a disadvantage. I quite like it.
2. We place a big emphasis on nutrition, and mastering things from that side as well (results, health and feeling great). If you’re having trouble getting to 185 I can almost guarantee that smart ectomorph-style nutrition is the fix.
3. We aren’t just a strength training program. Marco’s big into athletics, postural correction, alignment, mobility AND strength. You’re going to get strength, athleticism and aesthetics.
4. We try to make it easy and enjoyable. We’re all about cooking food in bulk (or cheap, or easy, etc), avoiding unnecessary restrictions, loving the gym and building a fun lifestyle around it.
5. You get as much coaching as you need/want. This isn’t a program where we hand you a pdf and bid you good luck. We can help you track your results, tweak the program to fit your goals and situation, and give you feedback and suggestions as you go through. Our members are all great guys too – I love it.
6. You’ve been at it 5 years, so I think you’d learn a ton and enjoy the change. Training in a slightly different style could give you some sweet results, too, as it gives you a new arena to master.
7. I agree with you – I think we can get you to 185 and looking rad 🙂
I hope that helps! If you’re curious about anything just let me know and I’ll answer any specifics you’re interested in.
I hope you decide to join us man, it’d be great to have you!
-Shane
Fantastic article, Shane!
I weigh 148 lbs and stand at 5’11. My blood glucose level has always been normal.The last time I ‘d consumed Serious Mass, I gained 22 lbs. But it caused my fasting glucose level to shoot up to 103. Ever since I gave up Serious Mass, my blood glucose level has returned to normal. My question is, can I consume your ‘training drink’, without the dextrose? Or how could I safely substitute the dextrose?
Hey man that’s a really good question! If you scroll up to a couple questions above you’ll see that this shouldn’t have too much of negative effect on your blood glucose levels or insulin sensitivity, since you’re doing it just a couple times a week and combining it with physical exertion.
With that said, there’s no need to take a risk if you have a history of having glucose issues when dealing with this kind of thing. Truth be told this is quite similar to Serious Mass, just a bare bones cheaper alternative with dosages designed for ectomorphs. Some questions – were you taking the serious mass peri-workout, or as a meal replacement? Were you taking it in a fasted state, i.e. first thing in the morning, or in combination with other foods? I’m very curious, as I want to do everything I can to make sure that the things we recommend are, in fact, good for people’s health, and not just their muscles.
Can you ditch the dextrose? I wouldn’t, as you need those carbs! Those are possibly responsible for even more muscle growth than the protein! But you can certainly replace them. Bananas, bread, fruit, potatoes, ground up oatmeal (as some of our members do) … or even milk. A popular bodybuilding trick among the DIY crew is to buy a litre of chocolate milk and have that as their post-workout shake. That’s a valid approach, so long as you aren’t intolerant to lactose.
One benefit of these workout drinks is that you do get an insulin surge, which, combined with training, is extremely anabolic – some bodybuilders even inject insulin to achieve an exaggerated effect – but in order to get a hearty anabolic effect you don’t need to worry too much about the glycemic index or anything. Using casein, milk, non-dextrose starchy carbs – it’s all good.
If you’re looking for a powder supplement, you could always go for waxi maize. Expensive, but it’s one of those big-ass heavy starches that takes longer to digest.
I’m not sure what affect subbing this out would have on your glucose levels, if any – I’m not expert when it comes to that – but I hope my 2 cents help!
Thanks bro, for your reply! I will certainly try out the dextrose- substitutes suggested by you. Could you please suggest a few more subs? Looking forward to gain some lean mean muscle.
To answer your question, I used to take Serious Mass as a post work out shake, thrice a week. On the days I didn’t work out, I took take it either with breakfast or after dinner.
im 15 is that to young to start?im tired of calling me weak im 5 9 and skinny i need to gain weight need bigg time help can i take the stuff above
@livestrong
mate, i would suggest you to indulge in all kinds of physical activities rather than starting with gym at this age. Play basketball, tennis or any other physically demanding sport and take proper nutritious meals with a balance of protein, carbs, vitamins and minerals. You are at a stage of your life where you will notice a lot of changes in your body, your muscles will naturally get bigger, you will become broader and grow taller. Don’t worry about your weight as at this age, the metabolism rate is usually very high, so even if you eat a lot you won’t gain much weight.
Play as much as possible, run around a lot, keep your physical activities high and eat well (especially meat, eggs, green vegetables, fruits, whole milk). Rather than having 3 big meals a day, try to eat 5-6 medium sized meals everyday
But if you still want to go for supplements, there’s definitely a strict no-no for creatine until you’re 18, about whey and other stuff, Shane would be able to tell you better.My advice to you would be to eat naturally nutritious protein and carb rich food and play physically exhausting sports or do any physical activity regularly, you’ll definitely be big and strong by the time you’re 18 and come through puberty ! 🙂
Can I take nutrasea?
Lots of relatively young guys get into weight training, especially if they’re heavily into sports (football, wrestling, etc). I know Marco trains some high school sports teams in the gym to improve their performance on the field and help keep them injury-free.
Weight training, while it has a badass rep, is actually pretty safe compared to sports that are often assumed to be kid-friendly, like soccer.
Here’s a study looking into weight lifting in school-aged children (6-18). Out of over 4000 participants who had engaged in weightlifting, only 3 reported an injury. One was serious. Only 500 participants had engaged in rugby … but 50 of them sustained injuries. 10 of them were serious.
This matches my personal experience. I dislocated my thumb playing dodgeball (hospital, quick recovery), tore my calf muscle running (hospital, long recovery) and cranked my shoulder being a goof in the gym without proper instruction (university health clinic – quick recovery). Of all of my friends in high school, none had any real weight lifting injuries, but concussions and torn muscles were popping up everywhere on the sports field.
There’s a risk of injury with every physical activity … and problems that could results from AVOIDING engaging in any physical activity. (Look at all the health problems out of shape people have.) Generally in the sports world weight training is seen as a way of improving performance and protect them against injury! Marco coaches a pro football player and an olympic athlete doing exactly that: keeping them in perfect condition so that they can compete injury free.
In the end it’s up to you (and your parents, doctor, etc) to weigh the risks!
Regarding supplements though you could always try milk! Drinking tons of milk, if you tolerate milk well, would have a very very similar effect (and even some advantages), and your mum might be more inclined to supply you with it 😉
Fish oil might be a good bet. You could ask your family doctor about NutraSea + vitamin D. I would imagine that would be a solid supplement for you … but this is just a guess!
Thx dude, I always thought sups were the way to go because my friend always gets free samples at gnc and he gives them to me and I took c4 for a bit but that did nothing because I stopped. so fish oil and milk? Could I eat stuff off your diet tho?
Yeah of course!
And I mean if you struggle to eat enough protein you could definitely grab some whey. Nothing too sinister about dextrose or anything either. These aren’t crazy experimental supplements or anything.
Marco started training at about your age, and he slowly grew to 6’3 and 200+ pounds. I wish I had started younger.
Could you send me a gourshy list so my mom can go to the store what about creatine
Creatine has proven to be safe in every study I’ve seen … but I haven’t seen anything about younger guys taking it. I’m not sure.
If you want to make it easy on your mum, and she shops once a week, just tell her to get a litre of milk for every day of the week. Drink a litre of milk a day, in addition to what you’re already eating, and see if that moves your weight up.
Some extra fruits and vegetables won’t hurt. Maybe some whole grain bread, peanut butter and bananas, so you can make peanut butter and banana sandwiches.
Okay sounds good
Do you mix your (creatine/dextrose/protein) workout shake with water or milk?
I mix it with water, although many recent studies are showing that milk, while it digests slowly, is actually pretty good as a post-workout drink. Lots of DIY guys will either make a drink like ours our down a bunch of chocolate milk! So hey if you want to mix it with milk more power to ya! Just use a bit less powder to take into account the nutrients coming from the milk 🙂
(Skim or 2% is fine, but I wouldn’t go for whole fat post-workout.)
Hey guys,
First of all, a MASSIVE thanks for this site. It’s so refreshing to see scientifically grounded advice given by real ectomorphs who also have anecdotal experience. Following your guidelines, I’ve gained 15 pounds in a month and couldn’t be happier. Excellent articles, and really love the fact you’re intelligent guys who want to help others through what you’ve learnt. So thanks! I’ve also got a specific question or two…
Regarding creatine: do you guys cycle it? If so, how long are you on and off it for? And, is there a noticeable loss in mass and strength gains?
Cheers guys
Hey Sam so glad to hear you’re doing such a rad job! Congrats man, that’s awesome! Glad we could help 🙂
Cycling could be good, yep. We often recommend holding off for a few weeks and building muscle sans-creatine to get a better idea of what just food and training will do for bumping the scale up. Guys will often gain 10+ pounds in the first 5 weeks and realize they can kick ass with or without supplements, which is reassuring. After that, if they hop on creatine, they usually get some sweet creatine “honeymoon” gains and love it. The 0-10 pounds from the fluid uptake will disappear (very slowly) when you stop taking creatine, sure, but the gains made while on creatine (often quite significant!) will remain so long as you keep eating and training well!
You could do a couple months on and a couple months off. As far as I know research isn’t very clear on creatine cycling. I haven’t ever heard of downsides from continued use – except to your wallet – but the acceleration of muscle gains from the creatine definitely definitely slows down. Cycling is more of a theoretical danger-dodger as far as I know. Better safe than sorry though!
Plus, unlike exercise and healthy whole food, creatine and supplements aren’t necessarily something you’d want to work into your lifestyle forever. We suspect that after our 5 month program most people will ditch most of the supplements. I regularly take fish oil and I often use whey protein … but that’s about it these days.
Does that answer your question?
Amazing, that more than answers it! I definitely think a good amount of the mass I’ve gained is due to the influence of the creatine although I only started using it recently. Eating like a beast is certainly the way to go!
Thanks again for taking the time to respond – you guys put in a hell of a lot of effort helping others and it really has transformed my whole mindset when it comes to getting in shape.
Cheers bro
No problem Sam! We’re pretty passionate about this stuff, and we love working with all you guys.
Good luck man!
Hey guys, I’ve been reading throuh your articles for the last few days and have found them throughly enjoyable to read and full of useful information. Thanks for all your hard work, it’s given me the motivation to try harder and hopefully put on some weight.
I’m 5′ 9″ and have always been skinny with small muscle structure, I weigh 58.5kg. I decided to start bulking up recently and started a new high calorie diet last week. Full of protein and carbs. I’m hitting about 3500 – 4000+ calories a day, I am almost a week in and I am waiting for my gym induction before starting strength and weight training.
I was wondering, what would be a good regime to get me started in the gym, what exercises are good to start with/what exercises should I avoid?
Hey Sean glad you like our stuff! That’s sweet that you’ve decided to kick some ass and take control of your situation, too 🙂
Your question … is a big one. There are a lot of components to a solid workout program, but they can often be broken down into: squats, hip hinges (deadlift variants), upper body presses (overhead, bench, etc), upper body pulls (chins, pull-ups), core stability and anti-rotation (e.g. planks, pallof press) and loaded carries (e.g. farmer carries).
I’d try and find a program designed by someone you trust that includes all of them, and then just follow it to a T! Workout programming is something I’d leave to people who fully understand it, or you might not get the most out of it.
If you’d like to join our program, we’d love to have you! Marco’s a champ at building unbelievably smart and effective workouts. Otherwise … stay tuned because in the next couple days we’ll be posting an article about weightlifting for ectomorphs and modding classic exercises to suit our anatomy. We’re always trying to put out sweet free content.
Hope that helps man, and good luck!
Hey Sean,
i read your post and couldn’t help myself but to relate to it. You’re about the same physique as myself. Great that you’re starting with gym soon and believe me no one better to guide than Shane and this site (they are definitely genius’s of this field). Adding to what Shane wrote, i would like to give you just a small advice (this helped me gain and will hopefully help you as well), rather than training an isolated group of muscles, train the whole body (or maybe upper body one day and lower body the next day) with about 3-4 sets per group of muscles for about a month. This would help you in 2 ways-
1.warm up your muscles & make them use to the exercise regime which would prevent any risk of injury when you do isolated exercises.
2.when you do mixed exercises, the body tends to release more testosterone (growth hormone) which means you’ll gain more as compared to the isolated exercises.
And eat like crazy as soon as you finish your workout.
Hope this helps you in some way. Happy gym-ing mate 🙂
Hi Guys,
I’m glad I’ve come across your awesome website. By the way, I live in the Philippines and I’m wondering if you have payment plans for your membership fee? 🙂
Also, I checked on the Dextrose brand you recommended but the site no longer sell them. Do you recommend another brand similar to NOW Dextrose?
Thank you in advance for your reply
I too would like to know if you have a recommended alternative for the NOW Dextrose?
Many thanks.
Any brand of dextrose is cool – I just selected that one because the price was good. (It’s sometimes called glucose too, so look out for that.) Other alternatives are maltodextrin and waximaize – great options both.
Any brand of dextrose is cool. (It’s sometimes called glucose too, so look out for that.) Other alternatives are maltodextrin and waximaize – great options both.
Hey Khevin, any brand should work. It’s really nothing magical – just a particular kind of sugar. Any brand of dextrose, maltodextrin or waximaize will do 🙂
I’ll shoot you an email with the payment plan info!
Hi Shane,
What about women who are ectomorphs and would like to build a great posterior? I do not gain muscle easily in my lower body.
Thanks!
We’ve had a few requests from women looking to do strength training and build up some muscle … but with the goal of getting curvy, not beastly. So. We’re beta testing a strength training, athletics and aesthetics program for women called Bony to Bombshell. It’s still in development, but we’re taking on beta testers. Check it out:
http://www.bonytobombshell.com
If it sounds like your cup of tea shoot me an email! (us@bonytobeastly.com)
Hi Shane,
Ill try and be brief so that I get the best answer from you.
– Im 26, 5 foot 6, 122lbs – small boned or slim. I dunno if im skinny fat because I do have a bit of fat around my stomach & chest area (nipples), however struggle to gain and retain muscle.
My questions:
– Ive read that protein consumed over your recommended is taxing on your kidneys and leads to issues..Is that a fact?
– Also is there any damage done to your heart with excess of protein?
– Im also a bit skeptical about not working out enough to the protein i take and this leading to becoming fat. How long does your program recommend a single training session? Or does this depend on your body type etc etc??
– I can’t afford the gym but I do have a home gym which i train on. Is this ok??
Thanks for the help
Jake
Hey Jacob, good questions man.
Check out our article on protein, and you’ll see that for us slim guys we don’t need THAT much. You’ll likely be better off getting around half of your calories from carbs and just 20-25% of your calories from protein.
The kidney/protein thing is largely a myth. I mean if you ate a ridiculous amount of calories to the point where you became obese and developed diabetes, well, you’d be at a huge risk for kidney disease. And yep, you can become fat by eating tons of calories – whether from protein, fat or carbs – so becoming fat from protein, while unlikely, is possible.
It’s unlikely because:
-Your body doesn’t convert protein very easily into fat.
-Protein, unlike, say, cola, is very filling, so it’s quite hard to consume “too much” of it. You’d almost certainly run out of appetite first.
-Around 25% of calories from protein are burned off as you digest them, due to the thermic effect of food – the highest of the macros.
Check out this study. A bunch of obese people at risk for kidney disease were put on a high protein diet (33% of total calories) and their health improved in pretty much every way versus the control group.
Taking it even further, many athletes and bodybuilders eat upwards of 2g/lb/day of protein and are in stellar health.
There are many factors at play here though, including our training, our bodytypes and our goals. Most guys in our program are trying to gain weight overall, too, which means we’re “bulking”. When bulking we need a smaller percentage of our calories coming from protein, as we’re playing with so many calories.
(We train for about an hour at a time, and we train three times per week.)
A home gym is great! I personally prefer the gym, but we’ve got a ton of guys using home gyms.
Hope that helps Jake! Does that answer your questions?
Hi Shane,
The issue I run into when lifting and drinking supplements is that my body looks fine but I start putting on alot of weight in my face. any advice on how to handle this?
One solution would be to not take supplements, if that’s what’s causing the problem. Supplements aren’t by any means necessary – just the cherry on top of the cake. If they don’t suit you, ditch ’em.
It’s possible your face is bloating up because of water retention or some such when you start eating more calories … and it’s also possible you’re allergic to something that you’re drinking and you’re swelling up. (Check this allergic reaction out ahaha.) Hard to say without knowing more.
Does that help at all?
Instead of consuming the Dextrose…Can I substitute it for the brand Universal Nutrition : Carbo Plus???
Yeah for sure. We just chose dextrose because it’s the cheapest and most generic. You can really use any type of carb with an underlying glucose structure for the same effect, whether that’s dextrose, maltodextrin, waximaize, etc – they’re all either straight glucose or glucose polymers. (Carbo Plus lists “glucose polymers from maltodextrin” as the carb source.)
Hey Shane,
Great site and great article. As a long time ectomorph (now 34), I’ve always struggled with adding muscle. I’m very tempted to try your plan as I plan on hitting the gym again after a 4 month hiatus. I’m been out due to a herniated disc in my lower back. Prior to the injury I did p90x and classic power lifting techniques. P90 killed my back with the plyometrics. It sounds as though some of the complex movements (ie squats, powerlifts) would put a lot of strain on my injured disc. Do you guys have other excersises you could recommend that would be more safe with my ailment? I was planning on doing leg press instead of squats, but it doesnt seem to be as much of a complex movement. Thank you so much and again great job. The video hit home.
Hey Eric, have you read out latest article? (Ectomorph Weightlifting.)
Many back issues can be corrected over time by strengthening the musculature in your back and working to improve your posture/alignment. Exercises like deadlifts, done correctly and with care, can often work magic on back health. That isn’t always the case, but I wouldn’t necessarily prematurely start totally avoiding training your back.
Avoiding exercises that strengthen your lower back won’t do much good if you do exercises (e.g. a military press) that require stability there.
If you think of your body like a 2 story house with a damaged first floor … the solution wouldn’t necessarily be more mass in the basement and second floor – you may want to fix the damage on the first floor.
I would recommend getting your back checked out by an expert and seeking out a solution that sees it getting stronger. Chances are you’ll be back to performing perfectly with a little bit of a smart training and some patience 🙂
link for dextrose:
NOW
Dextrose
IS A DISCONTINUED PRODUCT !!!
danger ?? useless ??
🙁
I got my NOW Dextrose 10lb from Amazon today. I believe the order was fulfilled by NOW. I think Amazon may have stopped selling it themselves so you couldnt get it via prime. Checked the NOW website and their still selling it.
Whoops good catch!
They replaced it with Maltodextrin. Probably not a bad idea, as we’ve had tons of guys having a hard time with the sweetness of the drink, especially combined with the sweeteners in whey protein.
I just updated it to their new product: Carbo Gain. Dextrose, if you can find it, is still a totally valid option though.
Hey, question. I’m naturally a pretty skinny ectomorph but I’ve managed to put on 7 lbs in 3 weeks with the right eating so I’m not sure how much of an ectomorph I am, but anyways. With the training drink what do you suggest a double dose or your suggested triple dose? Almond milk? 16 oz? 8 oz?
Thanks!
That’s awesome man, congratulations! 7 pounds in 3 weeks is badass.
I think there’s a tendency to think that ectomorphs suck at building muscle. That’s not necessarily the case. Most of us, once we start training and eating well, can pack on muscle at alarming rates.
Almond milk? Why almond milk?
A double dose, or even a single dose, is fine if you’re already succeeding at gaining weight at a sweet pace like that. The main advantage of going beyond that is simply the calories, and you’re obviously already consuming enough of those! 🙂
Great article. I am very interested into your mid workout drink – did i read it was 1000 calories! :O ! I am 6ft2 and 150 pounds and my strength has been increasing however I know that my calorie intake is no where near bulk stage. I find it difficult. What makes your mid workout shake so high calories and do you need an post workout shake after it?
When doing a single dose you can do it right before, during or right after working out. If you’re doing a triple dose I’d say drink a third of it before, a third during, and a third after.
What makes it so high in calories? The carb and protein powders 🙂
Yeah … not consuming enough calories is something most of us skinny guys struggle with. This is one creative way of helping to solve that problem. I hope it helps you man, good luck!
Hey and thank you for this great website!
I just tried drinking the triple dose and luckily I don`t find it that hard to drink. I`ve actually found it more practical to drink it all up right after my workout. Is this bad/less fortunate for my muscle growth or do you recommend drinking it before, during and after because its easier for a lot of people to drink it if they split it up? Hope this question makes sense 🙂
Hey Tord, the “anabolic window” you’ve got for getting your protein/calories/carbs in surrounding your workout is actually pretty wide, and you’ve got a lot of flexibility there. I prefer to start sipping right before training and finish sipping it as I finish … but chugging it all afterwards should be equally as effective 🙂
(The one downside I can think of is that if you struggle to consume enough calories overall each day, that might fill you up for a little longer after training, since you’re drinking the shake later. If you’re trying to fit a dinner in afterwards or something that might be tricky. But that’s just a lifestyle/preference thing.)
What if I’m 17, is it bad to drink whey and creatin seeing as my body isn’t fully developed
I haven’t seen any research indicating that creatine is bad for guys who are still developing, and quite a lot of research has been done into possible downsides. I also haven’t seen any research indicating that it’s safe for guys still developing either … so that’s a toughy. Creatine is hardly necessary though so if you aren’t comfortable using it, just ditch it.
Is whey bad? Nope. It’s just a processed form of the protein found in dairy. Having a solid protein intake is likely more beneficial for guys who are still growing, if anything. (Getting most of your protein from whole foods though, since whole foods are higher in vitamins and minerals, is still a good idea.)
Does that help at all?
Yes, thanks a lot my older brother has a jar of whey protein I might use that in a couple months after I develop more muscle at least
Thx for super posts. Feel I’m at Supplement Overload, listening to too many w/out checkin sites as this due to body structure.
I’m still 5-7 lbs away from goal. I’ve just stopped gaining & muscle definition/tone is less. Even tried N.O.only 4 terrible Side effects. I’m 48, having hormone issues, so that can be the case. I’d appreicate any “Advice & Direction” on Pre-Post-Supplements & Diet. Even considering IGF, which is last resort for a lady. Thanks much.
Hey Tammy,
I’d say supplements are a great bet for healthy people who are already getting the results they’re looking for, and just looking to take things to the next level. If you’re struggling to see progress I’d look at the foundation of your diet and training plan first – that’s where the real results are made!
Hormonal issues can definitely throw a wrench into things, and we’re no experts at dealing with abnormal hormones. I would trust your doctor for advice on that one. Whatever issues you’re dealing with though, don’t let that become an excuse not to accomplish your goals. Everyone has challenges, whether that’s hormones, time, money, appetite, injuries, etc.
Keep in mind that if your goal is a very lofty one, that it takes more time, effort and sacrifices to reach it!
I hope that helps!
My best,
Shane
Shane, with reading all the suggestions you’ve given to many, you seem to Rock at helping others. Great job!
Thanks for the kind words Tammy, I hope it helps!
Shane, It truly does help. I’m enjoying reading many of your articles and putting them into practice. Thanks again.
Shane –
In your training drink you mix whey + dextrose + creatine, but in the text of the post you mention malodextrin? Are you recommending malodextrin in the training drink, or dextrose, or are those terms somewhat interchangeable? Great advice, looking forward to giving this a try! Thanks!
Gah – we just switched the above link to maltodextrin. Forgot to switch it everywhere, I suppose. I’ll fix that up.
To answer your question though – you’re correct. They’re quite interchangeable (in this context) and either will do the trick. They’re both made out of glucose, and that’s what really matters.
Hey Shane, nice article. I’ve been following the blog on here for a while and taking the advice on board and incorporating it into my lifestyle and training. I am a 5ft10 ectomorph that weighed 130lbs. I started training in mid January this year and since then I have managed to gain 20lbs. Mostly through eating lots of whole foods and upping my calorie intake and incorporating compound lifts (bench press, barbell squat, deadlift, chin ups and t-rows) into my training plans following your advice.
I have now reached a point where I have decided to start taking supplements and being in the UK I couldn’t use the links you posted in the article so I decided to source some alternative brands/products but still follow your advice.
Just wanted to throw a recommendation out to any other UK people that myprotein.com products are pretty badass and very reasonably priced.
I bought their Impact Whey Protein (Cookie and Cream flavour), Maltodextrin, L Glutamine and Creatine Monohydrate. Mixed up the double dose (slightly concerned about the triple dose making me fat) and it tasted good! Either I have weird taste buds, or these products seem to go together well. Mixed up great to my surprise with no lumps and wasn’t as thick as I expected either.
Plus I worked out that it only costs me £1.45 to make this shake up, so doesn’t break the bank at all!
Not so much a question in here, just thought I’d recommend the above products for UK based people and say keep up the good work!
Money is tight so can’t afford to buy the program yet, but definitely interested in getting it soon. Can you shoot me details of the payment plan, if there is one?
Cheers
Not so much a question
Hey Steve, glad you’re liking our stuff man! Your results are awesome! 20 pounds is totally badass.
That’s awesome man, thanks for the tips! That stuff’s really helpful. We’ve got a few UK guys doing the program, and it seems like every continent has to adjust things ever so slightly. Our Australians have been buying ground up oats instead of maltodextrin, for example, and our Germans are getting dextrose from DIY beer breweries (for unbelievably cheap). Pretty cool.
Yeah man, I’ll shoot you the payment plan info. Hope to see you on the other side!
Is it safe to drink 50g whey protein, 100g maltodextrin, 10g creatine and 5g glutamin mixed with 450ml in one serving?
Do you mean from a hydration standpoint? I would recommend drinking plenty of water. Maybe that means bringing a water bottle with you. We have water fountains at our gym, so if we make a particularly hearty concoction we also mix in some sips of water.
If it’s especially hot and sweaty you might want to be extra careful to avoid dehydration.
I hope that helps!
Hey, great site! I had a few questions as I really don’t know how to go about getting to where I want to be physically. I’m 22, ectomorph, 5’10, around 60kg, i’ve always been about the same size. My body is out of proportion. Luckily i’ve been blessed with naturally large calves and my legs are a nice size generally, it’s just my torso and my arms. My arms are so skinny and always have been and I have NO chest and my stomach is fairly flat, not much really going on, so I know that if I can do things right, I could end up getting a pretty decent body. As for now, it seems like the bottom half of me doesnt match the top. I’ve tried gyms before but never managed to get it right, ending up in no improvements and giving up.
At the start of this year I’ve moved to Mexico, Playa del Carmen, so for anyone who knows this place and who are also in my position phsically will understand that after the first day I went to the beach it started a new fire in me to really do it this time. So I spoke to friends, watched endless youtube videos on workouts and diets and read endless articles. Money right now is a bit of an issue so the gym was a no no. The first 2 months went ok, a lot of different variations of push-ups and squats, changed my diet, started eating a lot more, I noticed some kind of improvement in muscle size but in weight I have no idea as I have no scales in my apartment to keep a check. As I wasn’t seeing as much improvement as I wanted to I had a lapse and gave up again for about 3 weeks and then after going to the beach again I kicked myself and realised i’m not gonna get anywhere if I keep giving up and I pushed myself back into it, this time changing what i’m doing working out, adding burpees, mountain climber, other push up variations, sit-ups, planks and squats, i’ve been doing this new routine for 2 weeks now and I definatley feel like its working out better this time. So right now I find your site and all this great advice and all these questions with great responses and I feel like I can get some genuine great advice now.
So first I wanted to ask about the supplements. As I feel like this new routine is working for me and will have some money in a few weeks I want to invest in a these suppliments and this great recipe for a training drink, but is it really necessary for me to get EVERYTHING mentioned above to really get great improvement that I want?
2. What else could you recommend for how I could get a workout better without any equipment (as I don’t have any)? and how long a good workout should be?
3. How many calories should I be consuming daily and how often do you think I should be eating?
Also after explaining what it is i’m doing, do you even think its gonna get me anywhere at all and do you think I should even be going anywhere near supplements yet?
Any response would be greatly appreaciated as I am so clueless about what I really should be doing and how!
Thanks in advance
Hey Sambo, thanks for taking the time to write us! That’s a pretty hefty message! Congrats for finally taking control of your life and trying to accomplish your fitness/strength/health goals, too!
Let’s see what we can do about those questions.
1. None of these supplements are necessary no, and regular whole food has a whole bunch of advantages too, like being unprocessed and packed full of micronutrients. These supplements may be cheaper than food, so in theory they should help you save money though. Whole food protein is usually more expensive than whey, and whole food carbs are usually cheaper than dextrose/maltodextrin. This presents an advantage as far as appetite goes, too, as it’s relatively easy to consume and very easy to digest.
2. Calisthenics (working out using your body weight) is cool, and you can make muscle gains at first. At a certain point the exercises become too easy, and it becomes less about strength and more about endurance. (Going from 15 pushups to 30 pushups, say, will increase your endurance, not your muscle size/strength.) You can be constantly making things more difficult (having someone push down on your back, doing explosive clap pushups, etc) but it quickly becomes complicated, and often takes a lot of athleticism (handstand pushups, say). With weights you can constantly be increasing the heaviness, resulting in progressively bigger muscles as your strength increases – much simpler and more reliable. But, as you probably know, sometimes the cheaper route comes with more challenges. That doesn’t mean you can’t accomplish your goals though … it will just be trickier.
3. How much should you be eating? Enough for your weight to increase! There are some advanced ways of figuring that out, like what we use with our members, but you can often get a rough idea by taking your weight and multiplying it by 20. If that still doesn’t have you gaining weight … then you need to eat more. You also need to make sure that your weight is coming in the form of muscle though, so you’ll need to make sure you’re giving your muscles a reason to build strength, not just endurance.
Does that answer all of your questions? I hope that helps man!
Hey, ha thanks for the reply, I realised after that the last message was an essay!
But yeah everything you said makes a lot of sense, I’m gonna see what I can do, mainly I think now I just need to maybe get a gym membership more than anything, calisthenics are gonna have to do for the time being though but better than nothing at all!
By the way I forgot to say before, that video is very impressive and really sold me and if I was in a better financial situation right now I would sign up. I’ll put some money aside when I can and if I can’t get any improvement alone I’ll sign up for sure, finally the real deal!
Thanks for the help and good luck man, I’ll spread the word!
Great article. Just wanted to ask for your opinion on using waxy maize starch as opposed to dextrin or maltodextrin in post-workout shake.
Yep, that’s totally cool. It’s a “heavier” starch, which just means there are more glucose molecules connected together. It’s sort of a more slowly digested form of maltodextrin. Great substitute.
Hey Shane,
how’re u doing mate ? I started with creatine a couple of months back as per your suggestion and have noticed gains in my lifting capacity but not so much of muscle gain. I also took a gainer called N-large 2 by Prolab but i didn’t gain much at all. It seems like i’ve probably reached a plateau. I am now looking to gain some big ass muscle and hence have a few questions..
1. How effective are the gainers available in the market ? Are they really effective ? I’ve heard people saying that they are useless and one should rather make their own using whey and adding stuff like peanut butter, oats, bananas ets to make a gainer. So should i buy a gainer or whey, considering that i’m looking to bulk up ?
2. What is the best gainer out there in the market which is really helpful for ectomorphs like us ?
3. How much of it should be taken per day ? Is 1 scoop after breakfast and 1 after workout enough or should i be taking more ?
Hey Sushant, glad you got some gains man! Everyone responds to creatine differently … and it isn’t magic. So if you aren’t gaining weight and building muscle it won’t make any results burst out of thin air. If you’re ALREADY building muscle though it can certainly accelerate those gains. Does that make sense?
1. I agree with what other people are saying. If you look at what’s actually in them, gainers are like eating cake + a protein shake. It’s mostly maltodextrin (very similar to flour) along with a bunch of other cheap processed calorie-heavy carbs. You’d be better off having the protein shake along with peanut butter, oats, bananas, etc. Some other favourites of mine are: yogurt, milk, other nuts, coconut milk, dark chocolate and raw eggs.
(If you’re into cake, you can, of course, actually have cake along with a protein shake. Ironically, it’s cheaper than most weight gainers and just as effective … but it tastes better. Still not as good as making your own though.)
2. Optimum Nutrition is a very professional company that produces products that actually seem to be “as advertised” perhaps not in terms of results, but at least in terms of ingredients. If their mass gainer (Serious Mass) says that it’s got 30g of whey protein it will actually have 30g of whey protein … which is surprisingly rare in the supplement world.
3. If you’re making your own out of whole foods, you can eat as much of it as you want – it’s healthy afterall! If you’re buying a store bought one that’s heavily processed … then it’s kind of like junk food – you want to eat it in moderation. When bulking you’re probably cool getting 20% of your calories or so from “empty” calories, i.e., calories that aren’t nutritious. As for how much you should consume to grow? You don’t need to consume ANY. But your overall intake should be enough for you to gain weight on the scale and improve on your strength in the gym.
Surrounding training though you can take advantage of a pretty potent advantage that nutrient timing offers. Studies are pretty promising there (as explained in this blog post) so I’d take a hearty amount. You could use it as a more expensive version of what we’re recommending, so just read the end of the article to figure out the dosage that works best for you 🙂
Hope that helps man! Good luck!
My best,
Shane
Hello,
I’m 118lbs and 5’7” and I would like to gain at least 15 lbs by Mid August when I go to college. Would it be possible, especially increase my arm size. Any advice helps I’m pretty desperate.
Yeah man, I’d say that’s definitely possible! You should get started soon though!! That’s no small amount of weight and August is getting closer each day 😉
We’d love to help you get there so I hope you join us!
I’m sure you’d be able to do it yourself though, given enough motivation and effort!
Hey Shane,
I’ve been concerned about taking too many calories because I’ve heard high calorie diets increase risk factors for type 2 diabetes, heart disease, cancer…basically decreasing longevity. Now I don’t believe 1000 calories for a workout shake is too crazy. It’s what you’d find in a typical Five Guys bacon cheeseburger. However, if I wanted to workout 4 times a week, do you think there would be any negative high calorie effects associated with taking that many calories?
That’s an interesting question, because the main point of consuming a shake that large is because we’re actively TRYING to eat more calories.
My understanding of the health component of consuming a lot of calories is that it depends on where those calories are going. It also depends on whether you’re consuming too little, enough or too much, not whether you’re consuming a little or a lot. Does that make sense?
Overeating > obesity > diabetes.
Eating enough to build muscle but not so much to get fat > lean muscle gains > beastliness.
Does that make sense?
Hi guys,
What a great article, I love the fact that you use research studies to back up your claims. Your photos are also a great testament to your hard work.
I’ve been a skinny guy my whole life but have recently, through training and eating, started to increase in size. My situation is made more complex by the fact that I’m gluten intolerant which rules out wheat pastas, lots of training shakes, bread, and many of the easily available carbs.
I’d love to get a little more info from yourselves relating to the ingredients that you use in your recipe book before I go ahead and purchase your product. How gluten free friendly are you guys?
I’m currently working on a few recipes using quinoa is a flour substitute for protein bars and cakes. Nutritionally they should be very beneficial with the complex carb and protein base of the quinoa so I’d be happy to keep you posted.
If you do have any advice relating to gf training I’d love to hear it.
Kind regards
Alex
United Kingdom.
Hi guys,
What a great article, I love the fact that you use research studies to back up your claims. Your photos are also a great testament to your hard work.
I’ve been a skinny guy my whole life but have recently, through training and eating, started to increase in size. My situation is made more complex by the fact that I’m gluten intolerant which rules out wheat pastas, lots of training shakes, bread, and many of the easily available carbs.
I’d love to get a little more info from yourselves relating to the ingredients that you use in your recipe book before I go ahead and purchase your product. How gluten free friendly are you guys?
I’m currently working on a few recipes using quinoa is a flour substitute for protein bars and cakes. Nutritionally they should be very beneficial with the complex carb and protein base of the quinoa so I’d be happy to keep you posted.
If you do have any advice relating to gf training I’d love to hear it.
Kind regards
Alex
United Kingdom..
Hey Alex, glad you like our stuff man!
Being gluten intolerant actually isn’t all too bad for bulking up! I had a girlfriend who was gluten intolerant for a while … at which point I realized I ALREADY wasn’t eating any gluten. I eat a ton of beans and plenty of potatoes. Lots of guys eat tons of rice and quinoa. Flour isn’t all that nutritious, and, well, I haven’t found it all that delicious either. Pizza and pasta have never been big favourites of mine even from a taste perspective. I’d much rather have chili (beans+corn) or stew (potatoes). At restaurants I always go for the meat+potato meals, too. Or seafood.
So I’d say we’re very very gluten-free-friendly 🙂
Does that answer your question?
I hope you decide to join us man!
My best,
Shane
Hi Shane! I’m really tiny. I’m 120 lbs at 5′ 9″ and I want to start this plan soon. What dosages do you reccomend for me personally?
Very good article though.
Thanks!
Hey Tremayne, I’d start with a regular size drink and then, if you feel good, increase the size of it up to the 3x size 🙂
Hey Shane again. I was re-reading the article and was wondering, do I mix 90g of protein, 180g of carbs, and 15g of creatine also or triple it so it would be 270g of protein, 540 grams of carbs and 45g of creatine? I don’t want to mess up. As I said before I’m 120 pounds at 5’9″. What’s the regime you use? Would I mix the 3, drink it before, after or during my workout? When would I have to drink the fish oil?
Thanks!!
I would start with 30g whey protein and 60g maltodextrin. If that goes well and it comes time to increase, then up it to 60g whey protein and 120g maltodextrin. Then, finally, up to 90g protein and 180g maltodextrin … but that’s a hefty drink so I’d work up to it!
Hey man, I started taking 2 2.5g of creatine in chewable wafers daily for the last 5 days. I’ve noticed that it makes me much thirstier than usual so i’ve been drinking a lot of water. I know that creatine has a unique relationship with water but if i have a lot of water, will i flush the creatine out of my system when i go to the bathroom?
Some, sure! You want to take in a bit more than you need for that reason. For your body to take in 3g (which is around what you want to be giving it) you need to consume 5-6g 🙂
What is the best dosage for the NutraSea Fish oil? Just pour into a tspoon and consume once a day?
Yep, consuming once a day is perfect. You’d likely want to pour it into a tablespoon though, not a teaspoon.
—-“That bad boy racks up 1080 calories of exactly the kind of nutrition we want when training.”—-
– One question, are you factoring in the calories from whatever it is you’re mixing it with? –
I ask because I normally like using a half a liter of whole milk (~300 calories) as the basis for my own workout shake.
Or are you just using water in your shakes? Are there any advantages or disadvantages to using milk instead of water?
So many questions…
Milk is a surprisingly potent workout drink, considering how ridiculously slowly we digest it! It has a lot of muscle-building benefits built into it, since there are so many rad vitamins and minerals in there, alongside a great source of protein.
The protein shake we drink, however, is mixed with water.
If you’re mixing yours with milk just use a bit less protein and maltodextrin in your mix so that you wind up with the same total amount of carbs and protein in there.
You may dig this article, too:
https://bonytobeastly.com/milk-muscle-and-marcel-the-ectomorph-dairy-guide/
Does that help?
Hi there. I have a very limited budget so I would just like to ask if buying creatine and whey protein will be enough? Or should I buy whey protein and fish oil isntead? I am a beginner when it comes to working out so forgive me for this question. I also read that there are harmful side effects when using fish oil, are those claims true? thank you.
If you’re using a quality fish oil like NutraSea I can’t imagine you running into any harmful side effects at all … it’s pretty universally considered an incredibly healthy supplement. You can certainly ask your doctor though! (With any exercise or nutrition program that’s always a wise idea, as everyone is a little different.)
Creatine is cheaper and is absolutely incredible at building muscle, so if that’s your main goal I’d go for that one.
Fish oil is great for your longterm health though, so perhaps that’s something you’ll want to incorporate into your diet down the road if you ever have a bit more disposable income to invest in your health 🙂
Does that help?
Hey I had no idea what an “ectomorph” until yesterday
I watched your video and like yourself I struggled for years gave up tried again and to avail came close to my aspirations.
I tried protein drinks but I’m not sure what happened once I stopped sweating.. I would also get kidney stones.. Or bowel movement would stop or go crazy if you get what I mean lol..
I even messed up my back by doing squats and slipped a disc
I’m 6ft and 140lbs and man I’ve tried it all!..
You think this program can help me
Hey Rafeh, it sounds like you’ve had a rougher than average run of things! Almost all of us run into our share of mishaps, struggles and challenges with this stuff—I know I did!—but you seem to have struggled with quite a few!
Yes, I think our program could help. We take a pretty methodical approach to this and the goal is to make you even more resistant to injury, not set you up for it. We’re also trying to recommend a healthy diet that has you naturally building muscle, not one that has you sacrificing your health in order to look a certain way.
I haven’t ever heard of whey protein causing kidney stones or causing people to stop sweating though. Stopping taking whey protein sounds like the right idea, especially since having bowel issues makes me think you may be allergic or intolerant to it, but you may also want to ask your doc just incase it’s something unrelated to the whey protein.
You may want to get clearance to do squats and deadlifts again, too. When done properly these exercises have the potential to fix disk issues, or at least remove the symptoms, since you can build up a lot of protective muscle surrounding your spine + learn how to move better / more safely / more athletically / more naturally … but if you have a pre-existing injury you should definitely get it checked out by a medical professional.
The good news is that a couple months or years from now you can be a fearsomely healthy, strong and athletic dude with a body that makes you proud of what you were able to accomplish … and all these struggles could be something that you affectionately laugh at 😉
Does that help?
And I hope you decide to join us man 🙂
You may find value in this article, too:
https://bonytobeastly.com/ectomorph-weightlifting/
Do you take the maltodextrin on days you don’t lift? If so, how much do you take?
No sir! On non-lifting days I try to eat as much whole nutritious food as possible. When it comes to starches my go-to favourites are: legumes (e.g. beans), whole grain bread, peas, potatoes and fruits. There are tons of options out there—another big favourite for a lot of healthfully-minded dudes is quinoa.
So long as it’s a real food and it’s been minimally processed you should be good to go! (So processed white rice and processed white flour aren’t ideal, while, say, oatmeal and whole grains would be.)
Hope that helps!
i would like to know more about your products
Right now we’ve just got one landmark program: Bony to Beastly. Check it out:
https://bonytobeastly.com/the-program/
I think you’d get a lot out of it. Give it a read and see if you’d be a good fit?
If you are, we’d love to have you man 🙂
Do you consume the same amount of supplement servings on your rest days as well, or is it only on workout days?
Only workout days. On rest days it’s best to stick with nutritious whole foods 🙂
Are there any alternate body building supplements without Creatine, because doctor suggested me not to use because. Creatine is not suitable for me.
For sure, just don’t add the creatine 🙂
Maltodextrin + whey protein still makes a fearsome workout drink. And fish oil is still a great addition to your daily nutrition.
Does that help?
Hi. I’ve been following your website, and am considering getting your program, but I have a few questions.
I’ve a skinny skinny ectomorph (quoting what was said in the article). I’m ripped skinny, and I’ve been trying to do body weight exercises and compound exercises like squats, pull ups, crunches, but have not added much to my mass. It’s a little hard for me to prepare high calorie meals because of family members (and I cook for everyone), so I was considering supplements to aid me.
However, the protocol seems a little scary. I’ve had reservations about supplements for years because people kept telling me that I’d be fat when I’m older (I’m 23 now).. What do you suggest? I was thinking of going for whey protein first. But would that not add a lot of gains? I’m 174cm, weighing 54kg? 5’9, 121 pounds. I hope I converted that right. I wanna gain muscles so bad..
Hope to hear from you. And thank you for this article, and for helping me.
That’s sweet Ree, glad to hear you’re considering our program. I hope you do wind up deciding to join us 🙂
Bodyweight exercises are a good place to start, and they can often spark some initial gains and get things going … but since they aren’t necessarily “heavy” it’s often hard to keep your muscles growing beyond a certain point. You begin to build up muscular endurance instead of muscle strength / size. Guys who can do 50 pushups don’t necessarily have bigger chests than guys who can do 20. Does that make sense?
We’ve got a lot of sweet strategies for eating more calories, so I think you’d be set there, whether they come from supplements or not. On that note, I’m a little confused by your concern with supplements. What do supplements (like creatine, whey, fish oil, etc) have to do with becoming fat when you’re older?
Haha I know what you mean about wanting to gain muscles so badly! It’ll happen.
hey shane,
thank you for the great article
I’m considering joining the program. I went through the comments and i hope that you reply on the few ones on top. That will clear out and help me a big time.
Hey Sultan, I try to answer every single question! Sometimes they slip by though on here, so if I’ve missed anything give me a shout and I’d be happy to answer it 🙂
hey shane the article is quite impressive definitely going to try it, I just want to know one thing you said to consume 3-5g of creatine a day.
Do i have to take creatine dosage plus add creatine it to my drink for workout day or the drink is enough?
The workout drink is more than enough creatine for the day! If you’re taking a triple dose of the shake and you triple the amount of creatine that’s likely enough creatine that you don’t even need to take it on rest days!
Hi Shane my name is Ryan,
I just so happened to stumble across one of your articles a couple hours ago and since then have thoroughly enjoyed most of what your website has to offer. Must say very impressed! 🙂 I normally dont comment on websites but seeing how thoroughly you respond I figure I will give it a shot; my apologies however on the length of my post before hand.
A lot has changed since high school, I am 20 years old now and 5 months away from shipping out for basic training for the military (cant enlist until braces are off).
high school I played a lot of sports ate healthy and was incredibly skinny couldn’t gain weight. 5-9 100 pounds. Def ectomorphs.
Now couple years later terrible diet, virtually no excersise, and no supplements. I am 6foot 1 and 190 pounds. Not chubby at all but def fat has hidden my 6 pack away :/
As I said I have a few months to jump back on board and I am dead serious about getting in the best shape of my life. I just bought YMCA membership and signed up for swimming lessons. I don’t want to spend more than $1,000 in the next few months on supplemts/your program and food but will if thats what it takes.
My question for you is your program the right fit for me?
I want to bulk up with some serious muscle mass and burn some of this 22 percent body fat and get it back down to healthy level.
And will your workout shake/supplements work for me even though I am no longer a twig ( 🙂 my shoulders finally broadened out!) Or will I need to make adjustments?
Again, sorry that was alot…
Hey Ryan glad you took the time to write that epic message up, and stoked that you dig our blog.
They don’t take guys with braces? Hah that’s wild—who knew.
Props for getting up to 190! You’ve gained 90 pounds! That’s crrrrazy.
On some blogs that might not be admirable, but here that makes your stomach a hero 😉
Most people need to make some adjustment or another, as everyone is a little different. That’s one reason why I think the community/coaching is so important, as it’d give you a chance to get things customized until they fit you perfectly.
Gives with a higher body fat percentage are often less resistant to fat (for one reason or another) so depending on why that is there’ll be some changes that we recommend, whether that’s to your diet or training or both.
Yep, the workout shake will still work. Just stick with a single dose—for now at least. If you’ve really got a tendency to overeat feel free to skip it though—you can just as easily have whole foods instead, which are more satiating (and probably more enjoyable).
Hope you decide to join us man! We’d love to have you, and I think you’d get a lot out of it.
hey, i just stumbled upon this site because i am looking to find some information on how to gain serious muscle. i am currently 18 years old 115 lbs and 5 foot 6 inches do you think your program will help?
Muahahaha packing fearsome amounts of muscle onto thin ectomorphs is our specialty!
18 is a great age to start, too. Hell, I wish I’d started that young (or rather I wish when I’d tried at 18 I hadn’t failed so miserably and given up so prematurely!).
Your hormones should be doing wonderful things for building muscle right about now, too 🙂
I think you’d get a lot out of our program, so I hope you do decide to join!
-Shane
bro I weight 52 kg and I’m 5’11 and I am 17 and need to gain some serious muscle..what would be the best way bro?And I’m confused wheather to take serious mass as I play football and burn alot of calories..please help me bro 🙂
You’re a football player looking to build serious muscle? You sound like you’d be perfect for our program. Marco’s huge into strength and athletics and coaches a ton of football players — right up the professional level. Our program will work wonders at getting you into wicked shape to kick ass on the football field 🙂
17 is a great age to start into all of this stuff, too (with your parents’ permission, of course).
I bought everything. I’m 5’10 / 135 / 21 . Lets fucking rock and roll
Young, lean and well equipped — right on man.
Good luck! Let us know how it goes! 🙂
Great article! I’m a fitness buff who’s a trainer for equinox in Toronto, and I commend you on your information. Quick question: in regards to fish oil, I haven’t quite found a reputable source that suggest a best time for it to be taken? What would you suggest?
Ah that’s sweet man! I checked out Equinox’s website and it looks like a pretty badass premium club. And it’s right here in Toronto! (We live in Toronto too.) Seems like a great place to train at!
With stuff like that, when no one can agree what the right answer is, it often means that there isn’t one superior option. Fish oil timing is one of those cases. So long as you take it each day you’re set — timing doesn’t really matter.
I take it first thing in the morning just because it’s easy for me to remember that way.
This program sounds awesome! But the links you attached with the four supplements you recommend aren’t valid any longer, could you maybe fix it or something? And man, looking at this site just makes me so excited to join and try!
Thanks for the heads up Oliver! You’re right—it looks like Bodybuilding.com switched service providers. This will take a couple hours to update — we’ll try and tackle that tomorrow!
Hey Shane, thanks for your reply. I noticed that you have updated the links, but not all of them. The ones of whey protein and Maltodextrin are still invalid.
What kind of drink do you use in the shake?
Do you mean what do we mix the powders with? I recommend water. Some of our guys use milk though (and use a bit less whey and maltodextrin so that it has the same overall nutrient breakdown).
Hey shane
I’m from India.Read your article it’s so helpfull.
But I’m confused with buying supplement.
I only weigh 47kg.Can you please suggest me a good one.I already used BSN TRUEMASS but it’s didn’t show any results.
Thanks
Hey Sujith, we’ll be updating the supplement links tomorrow. They seem to be broken right now, as bodybuilding.com switched their service provider. Sorry for the confusion!
Ohh thanks for replying,but my point is I used bsn truemass 4 months ago but it didn’t show any results.So which one will give me better result.
Hehe I think the drink we recommend making in this article will give better results!
If you aren’t making gains though the problem isn’t with your supplements, it’s with your training or diet. Supplements accelerate gains … but if you aren’t making gains to begin with, they won’t be the magic solution. It’s all about the fundamentals for that!
Am I understanding your question correctly?
Loud and clear 😀
Did you updated the links !?
Still working on it! They changed their system up and we’re still waiting to hear back so we can put in the new links. I’m hoping we can get it handled in the next couple of days 🙂
Man please name the supplement which should I buy.
Hi Shane, thanks for the great post here. The info you guys provide has been very helpful in my quest to gain weight. I just started using the fish oil that you have recommended ( thanks for the links ) and you were right, this stuff is really quite easy to take. However, I just read a study which links omega 3s to a higher risk of prostate cancer. I was wondering if you have read this study yet? I’m not sure what to think about it yet. I figured I will talk to my doctor about this one before continuing with the omega supplements. Thanks again.
Oh man that study has been making waves! For other guys reading this, I’m thinking you’re talking about this study.
First, it’s a correlational study so you always need to take those with a grain of salt. Correlation doesn’t prove causation, so those are a starting point at best … and when compared with the overall body of research into omega 3s and fish oil in this case it really doesn’t measure up. There are many other studies that were conducted in a much better and more conclusive manner that haven’t found the same.
Second, this study measured BLOOD SERUM levels of omega 3s, not DIETARY CONSUMPTION of omega 3s. The two are very weakly related … so this study really doesn’t really even say much about supplementing with omega 3s at all. (Plus the researchers, apparently, don’t think these guys were even supplementing with fish oil.)
Interestingly enough, fish oil actually reduces your chance of getting prostate cancer in several other ways: improving your hormonal profile, reducing risk of obesity and reducing inflammation.
Aaaaand keep in mind that MOST studies still show that consumption of omega 3s reduces your risk of prostrate cancer!
The media is always coming out with sensational stuff like this, as this new research is shock worthy and increases readership. It’s usually best to let the dust settle and THEN evaluate. So far it’s seeming like when the dust settles on this one fish oil will be back in the clear 🙂
With that said, always check with your doc!
Thanks Shane, what a great article! As a ectomorph struggling to put on weight this is very helpful.
I was going through the comments and must appreciate the fact that you take the time to answer all questions your readers have. Most of my doubts got clarified as I went through your answers. So, thanks again.
No problem Misha, glad it helped! Stay tuned for the new articles we’ve got coming out for ectomorphs struggling to put on weight 🙂
And if you’ve ever got a question always feel free to drop a comment.
You realize that your website isn’t even indexed in Google?
And this post is broscience all the way. You don’t need supplements at all. Just eat and lift heavy.
Stan, did you even read the article?
Hey there, I’m 5’7 and jump around between 155 to 160 pounds. I’ve been working out for a few years and have gotten pretty good upper body definition. My legs could use a lot more work though. I’m still not quite satisfied. I looking to gain another 10 to 15 pounds of muscle. I train for strength as well for definition. I’m on Creatine and a Mass builder protein supplement. I don’t have a great diet, because I eat whatever. I’m what you call a hard gainer. Even though I know I’m stronger I still want the mass to go along with it. I’m wondering if you have any advice for me or if a program like this would work for me?
It’s refreshing to hear a guy say that they need more LEG work! That’s sweet.
If you’re a guy who doesn’t eat well … you may be selling yourself short as far as your genetics go! You may not be a hardgainer at all, just a poor eater! 😉
You sounds like a good fit for this program, yeah. We can definitely bulk up the stilts, and nothing will do a better job of giving you a strong balanced physique than squats and deadlifts!
Check out some of the transformations here. You can see some thighs absolutely explode:
http://www.facebook.com/bonyToBeastly
Hey Shane, what is your opinion on oatmass as an alternative to maltodextrin? (Or, rather, blended oats, as they are essentially the same, right?) It’s just all supplements cost a ton in Australia and I was wondering about other options. Cheers
Yep that’s totally cool. The main thing is that a) it’s made to be consumed raw, and b) that it’s a starch.
You’re not the first person to ask this – we’ve got a lot of Australians in our program doing the same thing 😉
Yo Shane I’m a month in and gained 8 lbs double dosing. I’m tripling up to hit 150. This stuff is working!
Niiiiice! That’s awesome man, keep it up!
8 pounds in a month is amazing 😀
I’m interested in taking your program, but I wanted to confirm that I was, in fact an ‘ectomorph’. I’m 6’2, and I’ve been naturally skinny my whole life. However, Ive gained unwanted fat in my middle section, and thighs, where that was never happening in the past.I weigh now around 165 lbs. I still appear skinny to most, but I may be average. Do youvthinkbthos program is right for me?
Thanks!
It’s very rare that someone is a total ectomorph is every way. Most guys have a bit of this or that mixed in, often in the form of carrying a little bit extra around the middle hehe.
I’ve been overweight back in the day too, back in one of my failed weight gain attempts.
I think you sound like a great fit, and we’d love to have you man! I hope you decide to join us 🙂
Dudes,
I’ve been reading a lot about muscle building recently, and I very much started seeing some patterns in “what is the fastest rate in which you can build muscle?” It seems that you can around 0.5 to 1 lb of muscle per week if you’re a newbie (my case) and about 20-30 lbs in your first year of training with proper nutrition.
Now, I’m not saying that gaining 20-30 in 12 weeks isn’t possible. I’m actually looking forward to that. I’ve been gaining about 1 lb of muscle per week for about three months (gained aprox 12 lbs of muscle in that time span) WITHOUT taking ANY supplements. Now, here comes the problem: it is becoming unsustainable EATING all those calories and I pretty much reached my (eating) limit (for now), so I started thinking about taking supplements.
I’l probably go with malto + whey protein. Considering that that will almost certainly boost my muscle building rate, I’ve been wondering:
Does you guys or any one of your clients ever got ANY stretch marks on your skin due to rapid muscle building?
12 pounds in 12 weeks?! Niiice! Congrats man, that’s amazing!
Sounds like you’ve got a great handle on this 😀
Hmm no I’ve never heard of stretch marks from growing outwards. (Even my tattoos seem to be doing fine, and I’ve gained 70 pounds!) A lot of us ectomorphs have stretch marks from growing UPwards though. A lot of us take to puberty by rapidly shooting sky high instead of getting muscular, it seems.
If you’re worried about stretch marks you can just use a moisturizing, drink plenty of water, etc. So long as your skin elasticity is good you won’t get stretch marks. You can google tricks for pregnant women if you like 😉
There are a lot of problems with those max-rate-of-muscle-gain studies and I won’t really get into that here, but I’m glad you’re already proving them wrong, as many many guys have, both inside this program and out!
Replacing whole foods with whey and maltodextrin won’t necessarily boost your muscle-building rate … but you’re right in that if it allows you to consume more calories, then the extra calories certainly will!
The supplements that improve your body’s ability to build muscle are rare, and for that I’d recommend creatine!
Congrats again on your gains!
Shane, dudes, thank you!
It awes me how much you guys are into this for us, ectomorphs. It’s incredible to find this community of ectomorphs that you were able to built. It’s nice to see that you’re open for our questions, too 🙂 I’m a student, so it’s kinda hard for me to pay for the program right now, but I guarantee I’ll buy it in the future just to show my support!
Haha, thanks, but as I said, it’s been difficult for me to put all those extra cals in. The past two weeks I merely stood at my current weight. Hopefully the malto + whey drink will help. I’m planning to adjust my diet to go a little bit higher in cals, too. Even being a skinny skinny ectomorph, I feel afraid of gaining fat (I must confess that the TRIPLE dose scared the hell out of me! hahaha), and was a little bit conservative about eating too many calories. I want to have the leanest possible bulk ever (cutting being an ectomorph? Nah, I’ll pass that haha) 🙂
I’ll step back from creatine for now because I drink SO MUCH water naturally that would bug me to drink even more due to use of creatine. If the malto + whey doesn’t prove to be helping a lot, maybe I’ll give it a try.
I know what you mean. Sometimes when you’re impressively lean it’s tough giving that up on the way to becoming buffer. You wind up passing through that “average” zone where you’re neither impressively lean nor impressively healthy, and that can be a bit of a bummer. By super leanly bulking you can always maintain your strength of being lean while adding on the new strength of being strong and healthy.
Don’t let it undercut your gains though! You need to gain weight to grow, so a calorie surplus is your friend!
Marco has the “always see your abs” rule that he follows. I like to track using the vein on my bicep. I’d find something like that on yourself and then start ramping things up and up, while always tweaking when necessary to make sure you aren’t getting too “fat” for your preference.
Sounds like you’re on the right track already 🙂
Good luck man!
Bought some:
– Creatine
– Dextrose
– Maltodextrin
– Whey
Bodyweight 64 KG – 1.85 M tall
I take creatine with some food and use whey after workout but how to use dextrose and maltodextrin:
-Pre or post?
-Mix dextrose with maltodextrin?
-Mix both with whey is better?
– how much g/KG(Bodyweight) of both
Just let me know so I can begin, Thanks!
Hey HK, that’s sweet!
Read the “the protocol” section of the blog post and that should give you all the info you need 🙂
Shane, I read that you use 15g of Creatine when you try to gain some weight. But people say 5g is the max because if you take more, you’ll just pee the rest out and your body would see the other 10g as trash. Is this true or is our maximum of creatine as being an ectomorph much higher?
Yeah I used to take 15g of creatine spaced out over a couple hours. I’d take 5g half an hour before training, 5g during and 5g after. Some creatine might have been flushed out, yeah. It’s pretty cheap and safe so I’m not all too concerned if that’s the case, but you can definitely use 5g of creatine in your workout shakes!
That’d be interesting to follow up on and see if any new studies shed some light on that!
Hey Shane I wanted to know other than the days im working out and making that double dose shake, should i be having just a regular whey protein shake the days im off? And is having all that protein healthy for you?
Shane also why not just use a weight gainer protein shake as opposed to the whey protein
You could use a gainer if you like, but they’re much much more expensive and might not have quite the right breakdown.
Universal Torrent is a pretty good gainer, although once you start having several servings at once the cost quickly adds up!
With something like Torrent you’re paying a fair price for the whey protein (although it’s often a lower quality whey in gainers) but you’re getting totally ripped off on the filler ingredients. The maltodextrin they load the stuff with costs them pennies and costs you several dollars. I figure may as well just buy it yourself, mix your own perfect ratio, and save a bit of money.
It’s versatile too. Can trim the doses down and fiddle with things if you ever decide to cut or anything.
Getting your protein from a variety of sources is best, and yep whey protein is a totally valid place to get it.
On rest days you can absolutely use whey / supplements if your diet is otherwise lacking. If you’ve got tons of protein coming from whole foods already … probably not necessary
When bulking I find I don’t ever really need whey protein on rest days, as I eat plenty of meat, dairy, beans, peas, etc. I get more than enough there.
Does that help / make sense?
Can you refresh the links of the lists of supplements please.
Thanks in advance for your reach article that helps me a lot.
Hey Mohannad, we’re trying our best to get the links up and running again. Bodybuilding.com switched all their supplement affiliate stuff around and we’re still getting re-approved and all sorts of not so fun stuff.
I’m hoping we can get it running in the next couple days. If we can’t … we’ll just scrap the whole affiliate thing and just link out to the supplements normally. I’m still hopeful we can make it work though!
Sorry for the inconvenience, and thank you for the support!
Hey Shane! I just want to say that I’ve spent a lot of time reading your articles and they are truly amazing, I cannot describe how much you’ve inspired me, and the information you provide is pretty wise and quite easy to understand, I just wanted to ask you a question that has been stumbling my mind for a few months now, I am currently taking gold standard whey protein, and for my post workout drink I blend about 48g of whey, add in 2 bananas which contain around 28g of carbohydrates each, and finish it off with a Gatorade which has 30g of carbohydrates, I read that in order to achieve greater results your carbohydrate intake should double your protein intake, but I was wondering can you develop tolerance from taking in the same amount of protein everyday? Lets say will I have to increase my protein intake overtime? And I also read that your body absorbs about 25g of protein in an hour so what would be the point of doubling your protein intake if it would all be converted into waste? I am looking forward to stop drinking Gatorade as it contains quite a lot of sugars, and buy maltodextrin instead as it looks much healthier, thank you Shane for your time and keep it up! Your site is great.
Juan
Thanks for the kind words Juan! Comments like yours are why I love writing blog articles so much.
Gold Standard is sweet. ON is a good company. Bananas are sweet too, and a great source of vitamins and minerals as well as being a good source of carbs. I don’t know why you’re using Gatorade as a carb source exactly – the flavour? I think Gatorade is made out of sucrose, which contains fructose. Fructose is absorbed very differently from glucose and not necessarily in a beneficial way. Not the best thing to be taking in high doses while training. I mean, 30g isn’t that high a dose, and bananas have fructose in ’em too … but as far as empty carbs like Gatorade go, you could probably do better! I mean bananas have so many amazing things going for them. I’d go for maltodextrin, dextrose or waximaize over gatorade. If you like the flavour of Gatorade, you could try adding a scoop of Xtend to your drink. Some quality amino acids and some berry / citric acid taste. (You can buy flavouring like citric acid separately too.) I’m nitpicking though, and what you’re doing sounds pretty good overall.
Yep, you can develop an intolerance from eating too much of anything, really! It’s common with nuts, berries, milk … and whey protein (among many others). We train three times per week and recommend taking this just three times a week when bulking … which isn’t that often to be having whey protein. If you’re consuming whey protein more often than that and/or in high doses you can buy a couple different brands at once (maybe grab some IsoNatural or something) and cycle ’em. Your body will no longer be getting the exact exact same type of whey over and over again, and it should solve that (if it’s even a problem to begin with).
If your body can only absorb 25g of protein in an hour then drinking more than 25g of whey in an hour will just mean that it takes longer than an hour to digest all of the protein! That’s not an issue. Most meals take 10 hours or so to digest if I’m remembering correctly!
(If we just peed calories out if we ate them too fast that would be the best news ever for chubby guys and gals, who, presumably, could eat entire cakes just fine so long as they ate them quickly enough. Sadly, for them, that isn’t really the case.)
Does that make sense / help?
Sorry for the bad english*filipino here 🙂
Hi! How much oz. of water needed for the Whey + maltodextrin + creatine. I use a protein shaker(20oz.). Thanks in advance 🙂
A lot of water is needed!
I’m Canadian so I had no idea what 20 oz meant … but it turns out my shaker is American and it says 28 oz. 28 is enough for me to baaaarely get in the triple dose, and I also sip from a water fountain sometimes, as it’s still thick enough to make me thirsty.
With a 20z bottle you’d definitely be able to fit in a single dose, which is where you should start anyway. If you wanted to do a triple you’d need to batch ’em. You could drink 1 in the change room beforehand, 1 in the gym and 1 after. Three is overkill for many/most guys though, so see how one treats you!
Thanks Shane for all the help and advice. Can i make this with milk or is the taste not gonna be as good? Also how much milk would you use if you use 28 oz of water?
You could probably make it with milk so long as you feel good while drinking it. I don’t know how much you’d use – maybe a similar amount? You’d reduce the amount of protein / carbs from the whey and maltodextrin though, as you’d be getting some from the milk.
Admittedly, this would digest more slowly (milk digests very slowly) but you’d also be getting lots of benefits from the milk, so the net result would probably be great.
Also if you’re going for milk you might be getting some fat in there (if you use a fatty milk) which, again, isn’t necessarily the best … but then you have studies showing that whole milk is the most anabolic type of milk taken post-workout, so again, the net result is probably good! (Could be that fat soluble vitamins, like vitamin D, work better in whole fat milk.)
Got it! Thanks Shane! 😀
Shane im sure you answered this somehwere but since carbo gain doesnt have a scoop how do you measure out a serving size? Or how many scoops would i use if i used the scooper from the gold whey box
Haha nope – we haven’t answered that question elsewhere on the blog. The tub should have nutrition information on the side … but who weighs their food? Not me …
So that’s a reallllly good question. I think the scoops we had for another brand of maltodextrin that we tried was about the same size as the whey scoop, so I imagine the calories/scoop would be similar.
Right now Jared and I are trying waximaize (maltodextrin is way more enjoyable – waximaize seems to be the twin of corn starch) and it came with a scoop.
I think the correct answer is to weigh it, but I’d use the whey scoop. This stuff isn’t SO finicky that messing it up by a few grams would screw you over anyway 🙂
Sorry Shane so its give or take 1 scoop of the carbo gain using the whey scooper right haha?
Yeah it should be close to that!
Shane which is better MP-Combat or On-100%Gold Standard. Dextrose or waximaize. And can you help me choose the best creatine brand? Thanks Shane!
Hey CJ,
I don’t know what MP-Combat is, and ON does wickedly well in independent consumer lab tests … so I’d go with ON.
Dextrose tastes like milk sugar, and waximaize tastes like cornstarch – up to your taste buds! I’d go with waxi, but I don’t really like sweet things. (Might be better for the teeth, too?)
Allmax and ON make good creatine. Any Creapure micronized monohydrate should be good though!
Hope that helps!
Thanks Shane! Keep up the good work!
Hey Shane,
great article ,it’s the first article i read in a while that has all the information i need….
i just got small problem,as english isn’t my first language i got confused about the amount of supplements i should take and when??…could u please mention that in a brief…Thank you 🙂
btw im 135 lbs and 5’6″
Try 60g maltodextrin + 30g whey protein isolate + 6g creatine. Have it right after you finish your workout.
If you feel great, you’re skinny and ripped and itching for quicker muscle gains … try drinking a second one during your workout. That will double the dose and give you some extra calories and extra protein to play around with. (No need to double the creatine, although you could!)
Does that solve ‘er?
That really helped 🙂 ,
About the fish oil,when should i take it?…and that’ll be all 🙂
Anytime you like. I’d take it at a time that you remember to take it, so perhaps first thing in the morning or right before bed.
Thanks alot Shane….keep up the good work
I am 17 years of age.my cheeks hv got a litttle bit sunken and I want a supplement. plzzzz email me the name if the supplement
Sounds like you need to find a way to consume more calories if you’re losing weight / your cheeks are becoming sunken. Supplements might be something you want to look into down the road, once you’ve got the nutrition fundamentals figured out.
Not a glamorous or exciting answer, perhaps, but I think you’ll see much better results 🙂
Good luck man! I know eating more and being beastlier in the kitchen is easier said than done, so just take it day by day and try to build up progressively better and better habits!
i used to be worried about my skinny body but after i read the above, i stop this thought of buying suppliments, i ll focus on eating god food and training program
Right on man, that’s definitely definitely the place to start. Supplements are the gravy on the steak, not the steak itself 🙂
Good luck, and let us know how it goes 🙂
Dudes,
After all your gains, do you still take supplements? I mean, when people reach their goals in terms of bodyweight, do they stop taking supps easily?
I ask because in my country supps are overtaxed, so I see it as an investment, instead of a cheaper alternative to food. I don’t want to become dependent on supps.
I’m gaining weight reliably, but I’m sincerely tired of being scrawny, and there is still 20 lb to go. I stress constantly about it, and I just been thinking about anything that could help me with building muscle (drug-free) is a go, so supplements are my first choice.
Buuut… people become hostage to this shit. They won’t have the willpower to go to the gym without it after using it a couple of times… and I’m not talking physiologically, but psychologically. I wonder if it would be possible to drop naturally, with ease, them once I packed those 20 lb. Would you guys mind telling me a little about your thoughts and experiences?
Jake 🙂
That’s a really good question!
I used to wonder that all the time myself. First off, let’s break ’em up into categories and then see what I can do.
Ergogenic supplements (SuperPump, NO xplode, jack3d, etc): These are the performance enhancing pre-workout supplements … and they’re the hardest thing to stop using ever. I felt like I went from being superman to a weak old man when I stopped training with them. They’re also WICKED expensive, don’t contribute to gains at all, and aren’t necessarily the best for you … so we don’t even recommend them. The solution: have a cup of coffee instead. Much better for your health, even offering some advantages, tested for centuries, still very effective (caffeine is great for working out) and if you ever decide to stop it’s pretty easy. I don’t feel compelled to have it or anything pre-workout.
Intra-workout nutrition: These are the caloric ones that actually contribute to your gains, as they’re comparable to food in that they actually contain muscle-building nutrition. This is what we heartily recommend in this post, but it isn’t in any way NECESSARY in order to get rad gains. The pre-made premium intra-workout / recovery drinks like Universal Torrent, Surge Recovery, etc – those are very expensive. The homemade ones are very cheap, and, for MOST people, cheaper than their whole food equivalents. (If that isn’t the case for you and you find yourself able to eat enough calories day by day … I’d just go for whole food always.) These aren’t addictive at all, either physiologically or psychologically. You can accomplish your gains and then use very minimal dosages or stop using them entirely.
Creatine: kind of deserves a category of its own. In most countries it’s dirt cheap. It’s safe (and arguably good for your healthy). It’s very effective. It’s not remotely addictive at all in any way, and you can stop it at any time.
Gainers (QuickMass, Serious Mass, etc): Kind of useless to begin with and massively overpriced. I don’t really recommend ’em. If real food is cheaper for you you’d get waaaay better results from whole food smoothies anyway.
Food replacements, like whey protein: You can just use whole food … so there’s no use for these. Plus, once you accomplish your goals your protein requirements drop by about half, so chances are you won’t need to supplement with protein anymore anyway.
Health stuff: Stuff like fish oil you might want to take forever. It’s kind of difficult to get in a balanced fat intake … although you could certainly eat more fatty fish and algae and stuff. If you’re a guy who loves salmon that’s covered. (If salmon is cheaper than fish oil that’d definitely be the way more awesome way to get that in anyway.)
Deficiency stuff: Stuff like vitamin D is tricky to get naturally, as you need to be outside a lot to encourage your body to synthesize enough of it. Most people need to supplement with it (or drink milk, which is fortified with it).
Anyway, the short answer to your question is no: you don’t need to take supplements once you accomplish your goals. Hell, you don’t even need to take supplements BEFORE you accomplish your goals. If nutritious whole food is cheaper and more accessible for you (and you have the appetite to eat it) then you could forget about supplements altogether!
(And if money is a concern don’t ever waste it on pre-workout ergogenic stuff. I suspect this is the psychologically addictive “must have before training” stuff you’re talking about anyway.)
Does that help?
Good luck gaining your final 20!! I recently finished gaining MY final 20 (bringing me from 180 up to 200 – a total of +70!) so I know how satisfying that can be.
Let us know how it goes!!!
Supplements are still cheaper than most whole foods, but not as cheap as you might think. It is still cheaper taking malto than buying whole food (price per calorie), but in the specific case of whey and pre-wo, they are way off the range.
Yeah, that helped a lot! You see, creatine is still cheap enough for me to take regularly, so I’ve been thinking about it, but I’m afraid that:
a) I become more round due to water retention
b) I might lose something when I stop taking it
c) It might make that placebo effect where I can’t ever go to the gym without creatine anymore (with a little bit less of drama! haha)
Also, how much lean mass one can expect to gain while taking creatine?
Thanks brother! 70 lb is some serious mass you put on there! So, did you stop taking supps entirely now that you reached your final weight?
I wouldn’t say I’ve reached my “final” weight, I’d say I’ve reached a weight that I’m really psyched about. With weightlifting I think I’d actually be pretty bummed if I ever totally “finished”, you know? I really like it, and I like having goals to work towards.
Right now I’m trying to work on my hip mobility, core strength and I’m trying to improve my bench form so that I can lift more through a wider range of motion.
I still take supplements. I take fish oil + vitamin D still. I always have whey in the cupboard, and some days I’ll use it.
It sounds like things are different where you live – I do know that food in Canada is expensive relative to other countries – but whey here in Toronto is muuuch cheaper than, say, chicken breasts, steak or ground meat. It’s the most cost-effective form of protein (price per calorie) here … as far as I know. It’s definitely not increasing my living costs!
If you call it a supplement I also absolutely adore coffee! I have a nice hot mug before pretty much every workout and love it pretty heartily.
As for your creatine questions:
a) If by round you mean more muscular looking, then yes, that happens to some people. Not everyone gets water retention from creatine. (I don’t.) If won’t make you round like a chubby person looks round (i.e. saggy). The water is drawn into your muscles after all, so it’s your muscles that will inflate.
b) You’ll lose the water retention and the extra strength that comes along with having superhuman levels of ATP when you stop taking it. All the extra muscle you built while on it … that will stay. Keep in mind that the point of taking it isn’t to temporarily increase water retention, but rather to improve the rate that you can build muscle.
c) In this case the placebo effect could be a good thing! If creatine works AND you believe that it works you’ll probably get EVEN BETTER results. Creatine, unlike something like caffeine, isn’t an energy high or anything – you won’t really feel any different on it or off it. I really really doubt you’ll have any problem training without it. I’ve never heard of that happening to anyone.
How much lean mass can you expect to gain? I went in an added a bunch of studies to the creatine section today. You could check ’em out!
How much you’ll build really depends on how good your training program and how good your diet is. The studies up above might give you an idea about how much creatine factors into that 🙂
Why not build some muscle without supplements and learn that it’s achievable. THEN, when you buy supplements – if you still even want them – you’ll always know that you can do this without ’em.
Shane, man, it’s been a long time!
Well, that was the original plan. Turns out that after what, 7 months, I haven’t packed any of those 20 lbs. My routine it’s pretty solid, based on big moves 3-4x times a week, etc.
To be completely honest, I did take around 120 g of malto after workout days for a few weeks and gained some weight. Not that much, though, never passed on my max weight. Maybe 1 or 2 lbs. I slowly started eating more, and at 145 lbs I’m eating around 3100 kcal/day (logged) and still no results.
What bugs me the most is that my number are coming up, but my weight doesn’t. VERY slowly, way slower than I would see elsewhere. For instance, I’m benching around 90 lbs for 6 reps and I’ve been working out almost a year. But I can’t understand why my weight doesn’t come up at least a couple of grams…
I did take ON’s whey too, but it left me COMPLETELY bloated. I mean, took 2 scoops at 1 pm, didn’t eat anything till the next day. 1 scoop was slightly more manageable, but I still couldn’t eat until very late that day. I can drink 1 litre of milk with ease, but I made a point to test hydro whey and see if it’s something with lactose.
Anyways, my point. I think I’m eating enough to build muscle, my numbers on big lifts are going up, but I don’t see results now and haven’t seen for months. I think it’s worth giving creatine a go by now, otherwise I’m just wasting my willpower at the gym. (I realize that going anyways it’s good for your health, but I’m sure you can relate my lack of willingness to go the gym, given that I can’t seem to pack muscle.) I’m just afraid that the 5 lbs or so that I might gain leaves me “addicted” to that look, because, let’s be honest, 5 lbs is a fucking lot to someone who weights 145 and don’t pack muscle easily despite eating way more than his chubby friends.
To summarize:
1) My routine it’s pretty solid, my numbers (or reps) on lifts goes up, but I don’t see results;
2) I think I’m eating okay. May not be optimal, but it seems to me that 3100 kcal/day for someone who is 145 is decent. One thing is the scale moving slowly, other thing is the scale not moving at all! I can really eat 1 and 1/4 of a pizza even if I ate other shit throughout the day;
3) I didn’t take supps regularly, but gave malto a try at 2x the dosage and no reliable results. Had problems with whey concentrate, might try isolate. Didn’t take creatine afraid that I could be “hooked” not to it as a supplement, but the water retention it might provide.
4) I literally don’t know what else to try, and it’s demotivating.
Oh no! Sorry to hear you haven’t made any gains, man. The good news is you’ve been exercising consistently. While you may not LOOK the way you want, at least you’re taking advantage of the numerous health, cognition, energy level, etc benefits 🙂
1. Sounds like you’re making neural gains. Since your body doesn’t have the nutrients it needs to construct new muscle, it’s learning to use the muscle it ALREADY HAS more efficiently. This is similar to what someone who’s trying to stay in the same weight class would do – keep bodyweight constant and work on improving relative strength.
2. It may SEEM like you’re eating enough, but you need to trust the scale! If the scale doesn’t show you gaining weight … you need to listen to it.
3. Maltodextrin won’t create gains out of nothing, it will just make it easier to push your carb/calorie intake higher. It’s not much more magical than a potato, just less filling (and perhaps cheaper). If it isn’t pushing your carb/calorie intake high ENOUGH … you still won’t make gains. I wouldn’t recommend turning to supplements to solve your problem. It doesn’t sound to me like that’s what you’re struggling with?
4. If you’re confident your training routine is decent enough to promote muscle growth, keep at it. Focus on moving up your weight on the scale each week instead (i.e. focus on nutrition). To me it sounds like you’re struggling to consume enough to get your weight consistently moving up. I’d check out this article.
I hope that helps, Jake!
PS: When I say “numbers”, I’m actually making a reference to how much weight or plates I put on the barbell to lift.
Shane! I live in a place where there’s not much meat, only fish, green vegetables, tofu,eggs etc. Meat is expensive plus I can’t cook, so I’m thinking of incorporating Whey protein into my daily diet.
I already have the Universal Nutrition Creatine, but I’m pretty sure it’s not gonna help without the supps/eating extra(which I can’t really). I’m around 6’0 and at 150 pounds, having gained a little fat recently(by fat I mean my skinny guy 4 pack is now a flat stomach).
I love your article and the genuine commitment to help fellow ecto’s and have come to trust your opinion.
Now that you have my info, my questions: I want to order 1 supplement only, and I’m thinking “ON Whey”. Do you recommend otherwise, and how many servings per day(and when is the best time)? Please mention the creatine servings too. I noticed last year, although not sure, that briefly taking Whey with milk induced mildish stomach pains. Any opinions?
Also, how much cardio should I do? Is jogging/biking for 5 minutes prior good enough? Last Q : Is a 30-40 minute session good enough? I usually go start with 1 set wide pull-ups, 1 set push-ups, then 1 set dumb-bell chest-press, 1 set crunches. REST, repeat 3 times.
I substitute the chest-press with the lat pulldown on alternate days, and also include bicep curls, and traps sometimes, and holding a dumbbell while squatting. I make sure I exhaust myself + use heavy weights without losing form, breaking down as many muscle fibers as I can. What do you suggest overall, and how is my plan looking? Where would I be in 3 months? Thanks bruv.
I’m 21 years old.
Hey Jas,
You live in a place where you pretty much only have access to fish, green vegetables and eggs? That’s pretty cool. Sounds like some sort of super-health haven!
If you’re having trouble hitting your daily protein goals than whey protein would definitely be a great supplement to get! It’s caloric, too, so it’ll help boost your calories higher – great for an ectomorph.
As for creatine, you want around 6g a day. Your body needs about 3g per day, but we lose a few grams when we take it. 6g a day should get your levels up and keep them there 🙂
(You don’t need to take it with milk or anything – perhaps try water!)
It sounds like by cardio you’re talking about a pre-workout warmup, yeah? If it’s really cold out or really early in the morning you might want to do that just to literally warm up … but otherwise you don’t need to.
We do some dynamic stretches, a few mobility drills and practice our lifting technique at the beginning of every training session.
You don’t really need to exhaust yourself or worry about “breaking down” muscle necessarily. The goal is to BUILD muscle, not destroy it, after all. I like the mantra of “stimulate, don’t annihilate.” That depends on what methodology you’re following though. Different programs are constructed in different ways.
As for a specific workout program for you, I would follow one made by an expert! You could use our program (which I obviously think is the best one out there ever), or any other number of great programs out there.
Where will you be in 3 months? You’ll have to stay in touch and let us know! 🙂
Hey Shane, I’ve been reading through the website for two days now. Definitely thinking about joining the program but have some questions about what I can expect in your program.
Would love it if you shoot me an email with some info.
Ahahaha you’re just packed full of questions, eh?
Shot you an email 🙂
Nevermind – the email bounced from the account you have attached to your comment. Shoot us an email at us@bonytobeastly.com
Hey shane i was wondering how many scoops of the carbo gain using the scooper from the gold standard whey is equivalent to 1 serving? If i am trying to put on a good amount of weight do you sugesst using the 3x dose ?
Hey Mike,
It should say on the container how much is in a serving … so it’s a bit of a bummer that it doesn’t. It’s also a bummer that the servings are measured in grams (weight) rather than by scoop size (volume). That means that a scoop of whey isn’t necessarily going to hold the same amount of grams of maltodextrin – they might weigh different amounts.
It’s definitely a little frustrating.
A whey scoop holds about 30g (24 of which is protein). That same scoop of whey would get you “about” 30g of maltodextrin (29g or so of which is carbs).
For every nice full scoop of whey you put in the drink, put 2 kind of wimpy scoops of maltodextrin in.
Does that help?
As for how much you should take, I would let your abs decide. It’s largely a matter of insulin sensitivity and how well you handle carbs/calories. I handle them well, as do most naturally lean super skinny dudes, so a triple dose works well for me.
Not all slim dudes are super lean / tolerate carbs brilliantly well though, so if you don’t “effortlessly” have abs you might want to go easier on the serving size, taking just a single (or maybe double) dose.
It also depends on how much you’re able to eat elsewhere. If you struggle to get in enough calories, well, this’d be a good place to add more in!
Start with a single, scale it up. It’s a brutal drink in large servings sizes so you almost need to treat it like lifting weights: work up to it! 😉
Thanks a lot man that def helps…Il be putting in 4 wimpy scoops of cargo gain then for a double dose!
No problem Mike, good luck!
Great article! Are you drinking this concoction only on workout days? If so, does this mean your daily caloric intake swings quite a bit between workout days vs. non-workout days?
Yes and often yes! If you were to keep your other meals pretty steady from day to day with only the workout drink changing you’d be creating a carb cycling / calorie cycling effect. It wouldn’t be anything crazy or magical or anything, but generally that’s considered a good thing, especially for youngish dudes. We seem to respond pretty well to cycling carbs and calories.
That doesn’t mean you NEED to though, so you could always shoot for the same total calories from day to day, using the workout drink as a tool to make your daily eating a little less extreme. (You could skip a snack or shrink the serving sizes of some meals, etc.)
Oh – and thank you for the kind words Phil! Glad you liked it 🙂
Excellent article with studies. I read most of them and went out to buy the 8 lbs of Maltodextrin. I went to research more into Maltodextrin and came across this study (http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/?term=23251695) which says that “MDX-induced E. coli biofilm formation was independent of polysaccharide chain length” and is associated with Crohn’s disease.
This is a petri dish experiment, so it’s preliminary. We’d have to wait until there are more studies before we really come to any conclusions. A lot of what they’re saying totally makes sense though. Our diets DO affect our gut flora, and the healthier and more balanced our diet tends to be the healthier and more resilient that flora tends to be.
I’m the furthest thing from an expert on Crohn’s disease, what causes it, and what needs to be done to treat it. People with Crohn’s do, I believe, have a lot of restrictions about what kinds of starches and sugars they can consume though. WebMD is telling me that these foods commonly cause symptoms to flare up:
alcohol (mixed drinks, beer, wine)
butter, mayonnaise, margarine, oils
carbonated beverages
coffee, tea, chocolate
corn husks
dairy products (if lactose intolerant)
fatty foods (fried foods)
foods high in fiber
gas-producing foods (lentils, beans, legumes, cabbage, broccoli, onions)
nuts and seeds (peanut butter, other nut butters)
raw fruits
raw vegetables
red meat and pork
spicy foods
whole grains and bran
This seems to be along the lines of what the introduction of the study is saying as well:
“Current disease models hypothesize that genetically susceptible individuals develop abnormal immune responses to bacteria in response to environmental stimuli, resulting in inflammatory bowel disease. Currently, it is unclear how environmental factors contribute to the development of disease.”
Sounds like, similar to how a small subset of people don’t handle gluten well, that those with inflammatory bowel disease (or with a genetic predisposition for it) don’t handle maltodextrin well (along with a slew of other things that are generally understood to be unhealthy when eaten in disproportionate quantities).
“The factors which induce this dysbiosis are unclear, but genetics, lifestyle and a “Western” diet (a diet high in fats, sugar and protein but low in fiber) are all proposed to play a role”
“One factor which clearly influences the composition and characteristics of the microbiota is diet. Dietary studies in both mouse models and humans demonstrate large shifts in the composition of the microbiota dependent on diet [16], [25], [26], [27]. Comparisons of 16 S rRNA gene profiles between mice harboring a humanized microbiota and fed a high-fat/high-sugar diet (“Western diet”) versus those maintained on a low-fat/high polysaccharide diet revealed shifts in Bacteroidetes and an expansion of Bacilli and Erysipelotrichi [25]. Likewise, human studies comparing obese and lean twin pairs demonstrated changes in Bacteroidetes prevalence and a decrease in microbial diversity in obese individuals [47].”
The last line says:
“This leads us to postulate that consumption of MDX could increase bacterial loads in the ileum and prime these individuals to have a greater translocation of bacteria after intestinal injury. If these individuals carry other risk factors for CD (genetic variants of anti-bacterial response genes such as ATG16L1 or NOD2, for example), this may result in the development of disease in these susceptible individuals. These findings describe a potential disease mechanism linking the ubiquitous dietary additive MDX to microbial changes in the intestine of CD patients and suggest a novel therapeutic area for the prevention and treatment of inflammatory bowel disease.”
I’m not trying to play doctor here though – a lot of this stuff is waaaaay over my head – and this sounds like a question for your doctor (especially if you have Crohn’s Disease or you’re genetically predisposed to get Crohn’s Disease).
You are also, of course, perfectly welcome to play it safe and get your carbs from somewhere else! 🙂
It’s not like maltodextrin is necessary when it comes to building muscle or anything, it’s just one of many options!
What do you make of the study?
Hi,
just a quick question: What changes did you make in the October 2013 update? I might have a bad memory, but could it be that you had glutamin in there before? If so, why did you drop it?
Hey LJ, the changes are prrretty small. We added in a little excerpt from Alan Aragon, explained the methods behind our madness a little more clearly, and we added in a couple more reference studies.
There’s still a tiny little bit on glutamine in the whey protein section, but it’s a really really minor player in all of this.
Last month we made a slightly more significant change though – we added a TON of new studies, we switched over to recommending Amazon.com instead of bodybuilding.com, and we can now recommend a fish oil supplement that includes vitamin D! (Amazon is one of the few sites that stocks it.)
The basics are all still the same:
Consume lots of easily digested proteins, carbs and calories surrounding your training (and in general) … but still get the majority of your calories from minimally processed nutritious whole foods.
Creatine is the most powerful legal muscle-building supplement out there, and it also happens to be cheap, healthy and very very well researched for decades now.
Fish oil helps you get a more balanced fat intake and it has a bunch of promising effects on your health and body composition.
Now we’ve added in vitamin D though, which is fourth on the list of badass healthy muscle-building supplements. Almost everyone is deficient, it’s safe even in relatively high doses, and fixing the deficiency has a bunch of health benefits. Plus, it’s often a limiting factor when it comes to testosterone production. Eliminating the deficiency allows your testosterone output to reach higher/healthier levels. Vitamin D is a fat soluble vitamin, so taking it alongside a fat like fish oil allows it to be properly absorbed. (Vitamin D fortified whole milk is another effective way to get your vitamin D in.)
Hey really interesting article man,
Having gone through most the stuff on this site, it’s been really helpful.
I’m a fellow ectomorph like yourself, a really skinny one (58kgs at 5’10).
I’m looking to purchase the program soon even though I live in the UK, I was wondering whether you could help me out with a payment plan? as the one off payment is quiet alot for me (I’m a student short of cash atm lol) or if not I hope to make the purchase in the coming year where I have abit more money.
Anyway for now i was really hoping if you could help me anyway with some tips, having just bought some malto and whey i made my first post workout drink of double dose, and for 30 mins afterwards i felt pretty sick lol.
I train 3 times a week doing all the major compound lifts, I eat around 3000-3500 calories a day but it seems nothing is paying off right now, being stuck at this size is becoming really disheartening, really knocking my confidence man.
I was wondering if maybe you had any tips for me, tired of being this skinny where i can see my hip bones lol
a response from yourself or anyone would be greatly appreciated, and i really do hope to join you guys soon, Thanks
Hey Aaron, glad you like our articles.
Being in the UK is great. One of the strongest and most helpful guys in the community, Steve, is British.
Yeah some people handle the drink better than others. I’d just trim down the dose until it feels healthy-ish. Try a 1/3 dose and see how it goes.
(Was there creatine in there? Were you adequately hydrated?)
Muahaha we’ve got a LOT of tips for you! The best thing though is to get a really firm grasp on the fundamentals of lifting and eating to build muscle. We’ll teach you all that in the program, and then we can give you some individual coaching to make sure it’s working for you personally 🙂
And yeah we can set you up with a payment plan – I’ll shoot you an email with the details.
Hey shane can you please tell me does cargo gain cause man boobs ?
Hey Mike,
Hehe no it won’t.
Carbs wouldn’t make you grow man boobs.
Man boobs have to do with hormones and/or body fat, not macronutrients.
Don’t fret 🙂
Shane I think you saved my life…
I started bodybuilding a few times, never really bulk any weight…
So this time I was determined to use steroids…
Gladly I found your website.
THANK YOU!!!
Now I would have a question…
In my country gainers are much more cheaper than protein, so I will use Serious Mass.
The serving size is 195gr.
Could you tell me please how much sould I take during a day, and if I must take-it in non-workout days too?
Thanks again.
PS: I have some financiar issues, but when I will overcome those, definitely I will sign up for your program. Then I will hit the gym HARDDDD
Rock & Roll \m/
Hey Snake, glad we could help!
Gainers are usually cheaper than protein but more expensive than maltodextrin. Buying protein and maltodextrin and mixing it up yourself is often cheaper.
If gainers are cheaper though that’s obviously totally cool. Definitely the same idea – the ingredients in Serious Mass are first maltodextrin and second protein (albeit a blend). There are perhaps some iffy ingredients in there, but ON’s a good brand and I’ve heard good things about Serious Mass.
The same protocol still applies, so you’d want to take between, say, 360 and 1080 calories. (1/3 to a full serving.)
I wouldn’t take it on rest days unless you need to in order to hit your calorie goals. Whole foods will be markedly better.
Good luck man! Hope to see you in the community soon 🙂
Hey Shane
Wassup mate ? I’m back to B2B seeking some more cool advice from you. I just noticed the new pictures that u put up of yourself..dude u’ve buffed up ! Who would say that you’re the same guy as the one whose pictures you put up in the video. Awesome gain man ! I wud also like to share that i gained 5 more kgs since i last messaged you so i weigh in at 61.5 kgs at the moment.
I had reached some sort of plateau at 57 kgs and then last last month i decided to get a weight gainer (ABB Xtreme XXL) and creatine (Scitec 100% creatine monohydrate) and in about 15 days i gained close to 4 kgs (don’t know how much of it is water due to the creatine though)
So now i’m about to finish my bucket of Xtreme XXL gainer and have a confusion whether to buy ON Serious Mass or Musclepharm’s Combat powder. My aim is muscle gain (especially in the arms). Can i mix whey or a protein blend and mix it up with milk, bananas and peanut butter to achieve the same effect as Serious Mass ? Have you used Serious Mass or Combat before ? I’ve heard good things about both
Please advice me what to buy ? Musclepharm Combat 4lbs (blend) or Serious Mass 12 lbs ? Keeping in mind my aim of muscle gain and of-course cost effectiveness.
Eagerly waiting for your reply.
Rgds
Congrats on the 5kg Sushant, that’s amazing man!! 😀
No, the effect would be different. Bananas, milk, peanut butter and whey will not only likely be cheaper, but they’ll also give your body tons of micronutrients. You’ll likely see BETTER gains 😉
Weight gainers do work for ectomorphs – they provide carbs, protein and calories, after all. That’s often what us skinny guys need most in a supplement. I find them kind of expensive though, and I’m not the biiiiggest fan of getting so many calories from processed foods. Taken surrounding a workout they can be convenient and exactly what we need … but even then I prefer our homemade concoction, since we have more control over the quality and quantity of the ingredients (and it’s waaay cheaper).
I’ve used Serious Mass, Mutant Mass, Myoplex, and QuickMass … so I’ve definitely been there and done that. I don’t ever plan on using them again or see the need to though. If I could go back in time I’d save myself the money and stomach aches. Man, I felt like such crap after taking them.
I’d really recommend your homemade whole food option. Bananas are badass at building muscle. Their satiety score is moderate at best, so it’s they’re easy to eat without filing up, and they contain a ton of micronutrients that are useful when it comes to building muscle. Same deal with peanuts and milk – totally badass in all kinds of subtle ways in addition to being great sources of macronutrients and calories.
As for gaining in your arms, stay tuned! We’ve got a new little add-on program coming out in January (I hope) for ectomorphs looking to build muscle size in their arms. A lot of us skinny guys have long lanky arms and struggle with catching them up (myself included), even after gaining a bunch of proportional weight. It wouldn’t be good for a beginner, but as a guy who’s already gained a fair bit of muscle and who’s noticing his arms lagging behind it might suit you well! We’ve already begun beta testing it with some of our more experienced members and it’s going even better than we expected – and we expected a lot 😀
Good luck man!
Thanx a lot man ! And yes..i’ve also got really long arms which don’t seem to grow at all..especially the biceps. On the other hand i gain quite quickly on the chest (which reminds me the pic you uploaded for the home gym article shows what badass chest and abs you’ve developed dude..truely amazing)
There’s one more question i wanna ask..will using amino be beneficial for me ? Is it really needed or is it available in a sufficient quantity in the protein drinks or gainers ? Also do u guys use them ?
And as a fan of Bony to Beastly i’d like to thank you for the amazing advice that you give. Also i would like to make some requests..
1. Can you please also make a page where you review various supplements in a video form and discuss about its effectiveness, cost effectiveness and profile ?
2. Please upload some videos showing the proper form and movements with which exercises should be done..atleast for the basic exercises.
3. Please upload some pictures of your own transformation over the years and last few months..it really motivates us ectomorphs to hit the gym hard and be like you guys 🙂
*your big fan*
Thanks man 🙂
We’ve got a YouTube channel and we’ve juuuust started uploading some exercise videos. We’ve got chin-ups and deadlifts up so far, with more in the works!
As for shooting videos reviewing the best supplements for skinny ectomorphs, building muscle and health in general … that’s not a bad idea.
As for BCAAs and other amino acid supplements – don’t bother. No need to worry about them. That’s what whey is made out of, and you’re already getting way more than enough if you’re hitting your protein goals (which aren’t even that high when trying to build muscle).
The only two significant supplements I can think of that aren’t mentioned here are beta alanine, which is sort of like creatine’s younger brother. It’s not as effective as creatine, but if you’re trying to spend more money … it’d definitely get you further than BCAAs. I bought a little tub today to give it a try. I’m toying with the idea of adding it to this article.
The other is caffeine. It makes a pretty potent pre-workout supplement. Won’t necessarily help you build more muscle, but it can do a good job of making workouts more enjoyable. No need to get fancy – a cup or two of coffee is fine.
We downplay vitamin D a bit here too. You really do want to get your vitamin D levels in order. If you get that NutraSea supplement we recommend then you’re covered … but otherwise get some D3 separately. It’s cheap and very helpful/healthy.
More pictures and experiments to come!
Stay tuned 🙂
Hi Shane,
I Have been drinking the shake for about a month now and still cant seem to gain any weight. I use 2 scoops of the whey and 3 scoops of the carbo gain using the whey scooper. Any recommendation of what I can do to increase my weight gain?
Sorry also can you send me the link to where you have posted some of your workouts.
Thanks
Hey Dave,
Man that’s pretty much the most frustrating thing ever. I’ve been there way too many times in the past. Nothing worse than pouring money into all kinds of supplements and not getting anything out of them at all.
Did you read the beginning of the article? Taking supplements without first mastering the fundamentals is like upgrading the engine of a car that has no fuel in it. I mean, the car still won’t go anywhere.
Supplements work well in that they can increase the rate that you build muscle, but if you’re struggling to build muscle they won’t really help very much, if at all. As skinny guys / ectomorphs that’s especially true.
We’ll be releasing more free information in the future, although I don’t know if we’ll ever come out with a free workout program. We’re perfectionists with this stuff, and we really try to do it as absolutely perfectly as we possibly can. We’ve got a full muscle-building program for skinny dudes / ectomorphs, and it includes everything you need to totally master the fundamentals of lifting weights and eating to build muscle.
If that isn’t up your alley, a couple years ago when we first started trying to transform we made a video documenting what we were doing. It’s not the best program – we were pretty new to this stuff at the time – but it IS free, and it did work well enough to get us results 🙂
I hope that helps man. And don’t give up or lose hope! We’ve all been there.
Shane
I want to buy the program. Can you tell me how many days a week are you at the gym for the program?
That’s awesome, Dave!
We train three times per week, each workout lasts about an hour, and we hit each major muscle group each time.
Hope to see you on the other side 🙂
Hey Shane.
It’s me Snake again.
As you know already my budget is very tight (me and my dad are building a bench), and I also found a very cheap maltodextrin in my country (more than half of the price of NOW Carbo Gain – the one that you recomended). BUT here is the description:
“Glucidex maltodextrin is a slow absorbtion carbohydrate recomanded for long-term physical activity…”
Supplement facts: 400 Kcal / 100g and of course 100g of carbs.
Now I saw at Carbo Gain supplement facts that it’s made of 100% pure maltodextrin (from corn).
On Glucidex there is no such detail… do you think this maltodextrin is good?
By the way when i’m joining (in january) i’m gonna put some pictures with my home made bench, pull up bar, and dip station… ha ha ha I can’t wait.
Rock & Roll \m/
With supplements it’s not time to go bargain hunting. You always want to buy from respected brands – ideally big companies that are getting tested by independent consumer labs. The bargain basement price supplements are notorious for being devilishly shady, so I’d stay away from ’em.
The brand we recommend, NOW is one of those respected brands … but I’d look into the one you’re thinking of ordering from first.
I hope that helps!
See you on the inside soon I hope 🙂
Hey Shane.
I would like to get your opinion on these studies….
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/15212752
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/15105028
http://www.livescience.com/8086-protein-supplement-myth-revealed-body-work.html#
thank you!
Keep up the good work!
PS: My dip station is already done 😀
I’ll be the first person to admit that a) we don’t need protein supplements if we get enough protein from whole foods, and b) we don’t need an especially high protein diet. We need enough protein, not as much protein as possible. Check this article out:
https://bonytobeastly.com/bulking-macros/
With that said their numbers seems a little off. You’d probably have better luck looking at meta-studies into protein requirements – studies that look into ALL the studies done concerning protein and muscle.
It also very much depends on your goals. If you’re building muscle rather slowly your requirements go down, whereas if you’re trying to build muscle rapidly (as we’re doing) then protein requirements are slightly higher:
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/11023001
This study explains that as we’re building muscle and adjusting to having more and more lean mass our bodies need to become more efficient at using protein, but until that’s taken place we need a little more:
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/17374665
Basically in order to rapidly build muscle you’d want a protein intake more like 0.8 grams of protein per pound bodyweight, not 0.5 grams.
That article seems to be trying to be controversial. I mean, you can get your protein from chicken or protein powders. There’s nothing wrong with taking protein powders or anything, and given that they often cost less than whole food protein, it’s not like it’s a waste of money – they can often even save people money! Their claim that people already get enough protein and that protein supplements don’t help I would also argue is factually wrong:
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/23134885
(For us skinny ectomorphs protein powders also help on the appetite front, since they’re liquid.)
Can definitely get your protein from whole foods if you prefer though.
Greetings, Shane & guys!
Bro Shane, I wanna ask does taking vitamin C (1000mg) a day actually affects the creatine intake I am consuming right now (2 times, 5g per intake daily) the brand’s ‘Muscletech’ from GNC. I will get those from your link once I get a credit/debit card haha.
Also what I’m concerned about is will I clear out the creatine or nutrients from breakfast in the morning when I clear my bowels approximately 1 hour after that?
Thanks for taking the time to read this, you guys rock! I will see you guys on the beastly side next month after my payday LOL!
So long as you get your 5g in per day you should be okay.
(It takes many hours for things to pass through your intestines, so absolutely no worries of it coming out the other end that quickly after you ingest it!)
See you on the other side man 🙂
Sorry it’s me again. I hope a brief description of my current physique weight/situation could help contribute to my fellow ectomorphs here (B2B is a touching and awe-inspiring article to read haha).
I’m a 5 feet 8″ Asian male. 6 months before I was struggling to add mass to my small frame at only 123lbs (56 kg) before discovering the B2B website (seriousy it’s like a holy relic I never knew I had been searching for) and things changed after that.
It made me realized that I’m actually less committed to gain mass than I truly wanted to. Thus I started lifting much heavier weights and eating seriously as much (as we all know, nutrition and workouts can’t leave without one another in order to gain muscle mass).
I have at least 5 meals per day with at least 3 being lots of white rice as it opens up my appetite too. The other 2 consisted of olive oil tuna + wholemeal bread. Coupled with 1000mg of vitamin daily, I gained about 20 pounds of lean muscle mass.
As Shane mentioned before, things will really change. People are taking me much more seriously now not that they are shallow but in a natural human reaction kinda way. Our pyshique and confident attitude plus aura we exude really tells alot about us.
Being 143 is no biggie to me yet but it made all the difference when everyone who knew you WILL notice and the compliment they give only serve as further motivation. Sorry for the long comment but I just wanna encourage all my comrades to be strong, literally 😀
Cheers, I’ll check out this awesome site often.
Thanks for sharing man. Really really stoked to hear that you’re making awesome progress, enjoying the results and that we could help!
Is carbo gain similar to the dextrose you recommended before?
Very similar, yeah. Either dextrose or maltodextrin would be fine, although this one certainly tastes much better!
Hey Shane, good blog! I’ve been working out for 2 years now and it is only since I saw bony to beastly 2 months ago I actually started to gain some weight. Big Up!! Now I have this question:
1. I use dextrose instead of maltodextrine. Whats the difference between using dextrose in the shake instead of fine (powder) oats? Is it better to use dextrose in the training shake and fine oats after training or vice versa?
2. A friend of mine also uses amino acid tablets instead of amio acid powder. But he’s not an ectomorph. Which one do you recommend for an ectomorph?
3. I also use this supplement called Anabolic ZMA ( Zinc Monomethionine Aspartate, Magnesium Aspartate and vitamin B-6) combined with A casein shake before going to bed. Whats your thought on this ZMA supplement?
Thanks in advance!!
Hey Gio – greetings from Canada.
Really stoked to hear our blog has helped you gain some weight! Congrats man 🙂
Dextrose and maltodextrin are both fine. Both are rather quickly digested sources of glucose. Very similar. Dextrose is a sugar, so it’s sweet. Maltodextrin is a starch, so it’s more flavourless (and digests ever so slightly slower). Both are easy on the appetite, too, since their fibre content is, well, non-existent.
Powdered oats are cool too, and a lot of our Australian members go that route, for some reason. They’re digested more slowly, less refined, more rich in fibre and micronutrients – all good things. Less easy on your appetite perhaps? Hard to say. You could definitely go for powdered oats.
I would recommend protein powder for an ectomorph, not BCAAs. (See the beginning of the article.)
ZMA is okay. I presume you’re doing it to try and eliminate any nutrient deficiencies that could reduce your testosterone production? Vitamin D is easily the king in that regard, but if you’re deficient in zinc or magnesium, then ZMA could help (a little bit perhaps) as well:
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/6361778
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/3053862
(If you aren’t deficient it won’t really do anything. It’s not like creatine, where boosting it to superhuman levels helps.)
What do you suggest for pre workout?
Mine is:
1. 3 in 1 Coffee mix with 1 heaping teaspoon of creatine.
Coffee is great pre-workout! That’s almost always what I’ll have. During cold Canadian winters it’s nice to trek to the gym with a nice warm mug of coffee in your hands, too 😉
(Creatine you can take whenever, so I usually just mix it into my workout drink or have it with breakfast.)
If you want the caffeine and creatine in a non-coffee format there’s this muscle-building pre-workout supplement you could opt for instead:
Tier One Pre-Workout Supplement
Ideal dose of caffeine, ideal dose of the best brand of creatine and the ideal dose of beta-alanine (which is promising but not very well studied). The guys that make it are great, the flavour is delicious, and they’re an extremely evidence-based company with a great reputation … which explains the ingredients that actually line up with the studies.
Hey Shane,
How many calories do you estimate you were eating when you gained your first 20 pounds? And did you use supplements then?
Your website rocks. Happy almost new years!
I really have no idea how many calories I was eating. I wasn’t counting calories back then. If I were to guess I’d say 3500. For a 130 pound guy that’s quite a bit, but I’ve got one of those highly adaptive metabolisms – very ectomorphic in that regard – so I’ve always needed to eat quite a bit in order to be able to build muscle.
Nope, no supplements! I could have saved myself some time, money and trouble had a I bought supplements, but back then I was eating tons and tons of whole foods – lots of chicken, fish, whole grain bread, cheese, milk, potatoes, etc. In retrospect, even just whey would have helped a ton. Preparing all that meat was expensive and a huge hassle, and the chicken and fish leftovers I was warming up in the microwave tasted pretty awful …
It worked, since I had the fundamentals more or less down, but oh man I’ve learned a lot since then about making things easier, cheaper and more enjoyable 😉
When is the proper time to take this shake? Is it 1-2 hours before going to the gym or during your workout? Also, should i be taking another shake after my workout? With 30 grams of protein and 5 grams of creatine?
I have taken this shake once before with 30 grams of protein, 60 grams of Cyto Carb and 5 grams of creatine and the shake seemed kind of thin, should i be increasing my dosage?
Thanks.
Hey Sal,
The “anabolic window” that a lot of the nutrient timing stuff is based on is pretty large. There’s a good study on that here by Alan Aragon and Brad Schoenfeld. 30g protein a couple hours before and 30g of protein couple hours after would be pushing the limits of that window … but you’d still be in it. So yep, that would take care of the nutrient timing benefits.
You’d be missing out on arguably the best part of the shake though – that it frees up your appetite. If you have a meal a couple hours before training, a shake while training, and then another meal a couple hours after training (which is probably possible, given that the shake shouldn’t fill you up for that long) then it’s a great opportunity to get in more calories/protein/carbs easily and comfortably, which is often a bit deal deal for us skinny guys.
As for the dosage, that depends. If you’re consuming enough calories comfortably then you can probably stick with the smaller dose. If you aren’t, then you may want to up the size of the shake to make hitting your calorie goals easier.
Does that make sense / help?
I start sipping on it while doing my warmups and I finish whatever’s left after I finish my last set of the day. So I have it during. That’s about as smack dab in the middle of the anabolic window as possible 😉 I also suspect that’s the best way to take advantage of the beneficial insulin sensitivity that comes along with weightlifting, although that’s just an educated guess.
thanks for the reply Shane. I will defiantly start taking my shakes while at the gym. i hope someone here can answer my next question. my biggest issue is with meal timing especially in the evening hours. i have a typical 9-5 job and i usually goto the gym around 7-730 pm. most of the time my pre-gym meal is at 6-630 ish. does my body have enough time to digest my last meal and will my body take full advantage of the shake i take during my workout? i also take another protein shake after my workout with a piece of fruit, or carbs. Just before bedtime i have some plain yogurt with a sprinkle of Protein powder.
thanks everyone, this site is amazing.
Most of the research into nutrient timing is done on people in a relatively fasted state, which is why it’s so commonly thought to be incredibly important. In a fed state (aka “post-prandial”) the importance of nutrient timing is actually pretty small if you’ve got your nutritional fundamentals down pat, because there’s an abundance of nutrients already being digested and absorbed. These two studies summarize that well:
http://www.jissn.com/content/10/1/5
http://www.jissn.com/content/5/1/17
So no, your last meal definitely won’t be digested by the time you hit the gym … and that’s totally cool.
And yep, you’ll still see benefits from your intra- and post-workout shakes – if they help you achieve the overall nutrition goals that you’re shooting for that day 🙂
The nutrient timing component is a very small part of the benefit of workout shakes, since what us skinny guys are trying to do is spike the OVERALL amount of protein/carbs/calories that we consume. Given the insulin sensitivity in our muscles that comes along with training, the fact that the drink is liquid and quickly digested, etc, it makes it an amazing way to get in the nutrients we need to build muscle leanly in a way that won’t destroy our appetite.
Hey Shane,
This website is freaking amazing!!! I am a 24yr old ectomorph weighing in at 54kgs and haven’t budged from that weight in years. I have always been skinny, not only skinny but the skinniest amongst every group I have ever been a part of :(. A couple of years back I joined a gym and initially had some small gains but they slowed down and eventually to my disdain I gave up! But I’ve been thinking a lot lately about starting again and have been reading a lot of your articles lately which have definitely inspired me. I am seriously contemplating joining!!!
My main question is that I am from Australia and I’m wondering how this will affect me and whether it’s still worth joining? I clicked on the links and was about to purchase all of the products but found out that they don’t ship any of them to Australia. Do you know of anywhere I can get them from? Or any equivalents that an Australian ectomorph could get his hands on? :P. I have also recently become a vegetarian and was wondering whether your program is ok for my lifestyle?
Thanks,
Adam 🙂 🙂
Hey Adam, thanks for the kind words man – glad you like it!
Ahh yeah that was me back in the day too. I was always the skinniest and it made me feel like I was the little brother in my groups of friends, since I’d always get playfully pushed around. My friends weren’t malicious or anything – they treated me wonderfully – that’s just the role I stumbled into, and it wasn’t the role I wanted.
Lots of our raddest members are Australian! Marcel, for one. As far as supplements in Australia goes, he recommends bulkpowders and bulknutrients.
(Many Australians go for powdered oats instead of maltodextrin, and that’s totally cool.)
Yep! We’ve got a fair number of vegetarians and a bunch of vegetarian recipes and such, too. (And some vegans.) No problem there either. We aren’t a very restrictive or rigid program. We’re very very tailored to skinny guys looking to build a ton of muscle, but regardless of where you live or whether you eat meat or not (or have food allergies, gluten intolerances, etc) you’ll fit right in 🙂
I hope you decide to join us man!
Thanks for the quick reply!! The bulkpowders website looks great!! I shall definitely get my supplements from there 🙂 :). Do you know of any equivalent fish oil/vitamin D blend that you can get in Australia?
Thanks again,
Adam
Hi Adam – This is an awesome site – thank you for creating it. I’m in my mid 30’s and weigh exactly what I did in HS @ 126lbs – ugh. The only changes I’ve seen is that as I’m getting older, my shape is changing (i.e. love handles and missing the bottom of my six pack), but my weight is still the same, my waste is still the same, etc. I’ve been hitting the gym pretty hard recently (2 months), taking pre workout supplements, etc and now I’ve recently added the formula you have above. I’m still trying to find my balance of how much of each to take along with timing to my workouts. I’ve noticed over the past few weeks I’ve seen a little size/definition change (fiance has too) and increase in strength, but weight is still the same. Does that mean supplements wouldn’t work for me? I guess what I’m trying to find/figure out is if joining the program is right for me and how to set my expectations. Again, not having any real gains since HS (18 years ago), I do have a lot of reservations about what I can do and what’s possible…Thanks in advance for any insight and direction to the program.
Hey Shane – Hoping for any insight you can provide. Would love to join the program if it’s right. Thanks in advance. CG
Hey Craig,
Adding supplements in on top of a routine that isn’t working doesn’t usually help. Usually it’s best to fix the kinks in the system and THEN worry about optimizing your plan further with things like supplements.
Some supplements, like creatine, may have non-responders. It’s possible that it won’t work as well for you as it does for someone else (although until you’ve got your muscle-building fundamentals in order it’s impossible to say).
Other supplements, like whey protein and maltodextrin, well, they’re pretty much food. They’ll certainly contribute to your daily calorie/macro totals, and make eating enough to grow much easier, more convenient and probably even more affordable. Again though, without the fundamentals down, they aren’t magic.
Does that help at all?
As for not gaining weight, I’d check this article out 🙂
https://bonytobeastly.com/hard-to-gain-weight/
And as for b2B … we specialize in guys who are naturally skinny and who have struggled to put on muscle mass / gain weight. That’s who we’re BEST at helping. If you’ve read my story you know that this didn’t come easily to me either. I’ve got tons of failed attempts under my belt, as do Marco, Jared and almost everyone in our community.
If your worst fears are true and you really are a “non-responder” as far as lifting goes … we’d help you tweak things until you start responding. We leave no bony behind!
Thanks!
hii… i wanted to know how much creatine does an ectomorph need per day… standard creatine says to have 5gms daily….. does having more really help?
what else do u need to have apart from creatine… I eat rice daily which helps in the intake of carbohydrates and drink one glass of milk a day….. and eat meat regularly but not daily… atleast 3 to 4 times a week.
i train 6 times a week plus play other sports
Hey Aliraza,
How much creatine you’d want to take each day would depend. I’d recommend taking the standard 5 gram dose per day, but if you wanted to load up your creatine levels even more quickly you could take several 5 gram doses each day. I don’t know of any real long-term muscle-building advantages to doing it that way, but you’d get your creatine levels higher faster. I think 5 grams of creatine per day is a pretty solid bet.
You don’t need to have any supplements. If you struggle to reach you calorie, protein or carb goals you might want to try incorporating the workout drink that we recommend. If you don’t eat much protein/carbs/calories surrounding your workouts that would be another reason to incorporate the drink into your routine, in order to take advantage of the nutrient timing component.
I hope that helps!
I’m just curious, how do you mix all that powder (30-90 grams Whey + 60-180 grams maltodextrin + 5 grams creatine) together. I’m already having trouble dissolving 1 serving of the whey, there will be chunky bits floating about.
I have a 28 oz shaker, and to get rid of the chunks I just shake harder and longer. Sometimes there will be chunks, too, which doesn’t really bother me. (Further shaking tends to get rid of them.)
Some of our members mix the shake up earlier in the day and let it sit in the fridge, which apparently lets things dissolve pretty nicely.
I think the easiest way to solve the problem is just to get a shaker that comes with one of those whisk balls. The little whisk thing breaks up all the chunks 🙂
Can anyone recommend a good calorie counter app for android?
I really like MyFitnessPal!
Hi,
You say that protein intake should be 30-90 grs. According to another system, my intake (depending on heigh, age, etc) should be 300grs (workout days).
Can you help me clarify this? I feel lost.
Thanks!
Hey Francisco,
We’re recommending supplementing with 30-90g of whey protein while training, not as a daily protein goal.
If you were a lean-ish 200 pounds then 300g of protein per day might be helpful (1.5 grams of protein per pound bodyweight). That would be at the very high end of what would be considered maximally effective, but there is indeed reason to believe that a protein intake that high may result in (albeit very slight) improvements in the rate that you can build muscle.
Most research points to 1 gram of protein per pound day (or even 0.8 grams) as being optimal for building muscle. Hard to say though. We have a much better understanding of protein requirements in deficits than in calorie surpluses right now. I’m hoping more studies shed more light on this soon. I suspect they will! Eating up to 1.5g per pound though is cool. The benefit is theoretical and slight though 🙂
Hi Shane,
Let me see if I got it right….I’m 165 pounds and would like to reach 180 pounds.
So my “daily” intake should be 180x1gr = 180 grams of protein. (180 instead of 165 because that’s my goal)
While “training” 90 grs only. And the difference (90 grs), take it during the day (meals, etc.)
Am I right?
Sure! You don’t need to use your goal weight, but nothing wrong with more, and like I said, there’s some theoretical potential benefit from it. So 180 grams or protein per day is great 🙂
And you’re spot on with 90g while training and 90 or more grams during the day.
Thanks a lot for your help 🙂
Hi Shane,
First of all, fantastic stuff here! I’m a skinny guy attempting to gain weight, and thanked god I stumble upon this site. What you guys are doing is great. I will join the program soon!
I’m looking for a way to make a variation of protocol drink, it suits me because it is quick to prepare and the amount of calories makes for a convenient for my working lifestyle. However, from where I came from, it’s very expensive or not feasible to get some of the products you recommend. I will be able to get alternative products that are nearly as good – except maltodextrin or dextrose, so that has to come from some other sources. The cheapest and readily available would be oats. I hope to get your thoughts on using oats in place of maltodextrin/dextrose, as well as ideas of their alternatives for the workout drink.
Thanks a lot.
Regards,
Oats have more fibre, which could be good or bad depending on how much fibre you eat elsewhere / how much you struggle with appetite (since your drink will be more filling for longer). As far as the effectiveness of the drink goes though ground oats is great. We’ve got quite a few members who go that route actually (and especially the Australian ones).
Luckily, I found a good source for waximaize at a more affordable price!
Hi,
didn’t read all the comments, so I don’t know if this has already been brought up, but I have a question re: fish oil. On the NutraSea+D product page, it says that 1 tsp. will get you 750mg EPA, 500mg DHA and 1000IU vitamin d3. This is still quite a lot, but nowhere near the numbers you report (2g EPA, 1,5g DHA, 2000-4000IU vitamin d3). So how much would you take / are you taking?
Ah we recommend taking one tablespoon!
HI, very interesting reading, considering signing up, can you send me the deets on the payment plan. ( UK here).
I’m 43, been very skinny all my life. 30″ waist, no meat, no muscle, 5’6″ and weigh pretty much the same as i did when i was 13!.. (the benefits your now missing out on ..i can fit into my kids clothes!). On a serious note.
i need to bulk up, not necessarily muscle but with my life style as a full time single parent i cant get to the gym, or have space for a home gym.
Do you recommend supplements, healthy eating and a home workout routine like the Insanity program or T25 as a route to take.
update . my weight is only 50kg!
Hey Peter, greetings from Canada!
If your goal is general health and fitness then I think something like p90x or T25 would be great. Those guys do a good job of putting together a challenging workout that will stress your aerobic/cardiovascular system. Those workouts would give you very little muscle mass, if any, but they ARE good forms of general exercise, so, as you would with our program, you’d get higher energy levels, reduced feelings of stress/depression/anxiety, improved brain power, longer lifespan, etc.
If you want to bulk up though I’d lift heavy! That’s really the only effective way to do it, especially if you’re not genetically gifted. Have you seen our post on building a badass home gym? That explains the basics of how to go about building the simplest possible muscle-building setup, why it works and what to do with it. I think you’d be pleasantly surprised at how easy it is / how little space it would take up!
https://bonytobeastly.com/how-to-build-a-barbell-home-gym/
If that doesn’t work, there’s always the dad home workout 😉
I hope that helps!
Hey guys,
I see you recommend ON whey, but I’m wondering, what is your take on Aspartame? Aren’t artificial sweeteners that are used on whey protein, such as aspartame, toxic to the brain? Do you have studies that prove that they are safe or anything…?
Hey Drake, it’s always very hard to definitively prove that something is safe, but so far after decades of research there’s very little to show that it ISN’T safe, even at relatively high doses. (To go over the safe amount suggested by the FDA you’d need to drink a dozen or two diet sodas per day.)
Some correlational studies found issues, but in this case that doesn’t tell us anything – given that unhealthy people often consume “diet” things, that would of course be true whether or not the artificially sweetened “diet” foods are problematic. Anyway, most studies find the opposite – no problems:
http://annonc.oxfordjournals.org/content/18/1/40.long
I think the worst known side effect is headaches.
But this is a question you may want to ask your doctor, and hey if in doubt just opt for an unflavoured whey protein!(That’s what I drink, although it’s a relatively unpopular choice and I don’t see much reason for it from a health perspective – I just like to put it in smoothies and having it unflavoured helps.)
Hey Shane,
Living in Japan, the range of products is quite different than Europe/US/Canada. I’m currently using Savas powder, it’s unflavoured, and has glutamine.
Unflavoured is excellent – makes it a “no limit” ingredient, can add it to anything.
But reading your suggestions I looked at the ON Natural. This has a ton more glutamine than the Savas, but unfortunately is flavoured and reports suggest it’s quite sweet.
So which is the unflavoured one you’re using?
I agree! I love the unflavoured supplements. It’s rare that guys feel that way though, and most of our members prefer chocolate whey protein and such. I use unflavoured IsoNatural or the ON one – either one.
I wouldn’t worry too much about the glutamine content. All whey protein will have enough glutamine in it, and the one you’re already using looks great 🙂
I’ve looked at the ingredient lists on the back of the packs of various whey protein powders here, and only 2 list glutamine as an ingredient.
Does that mean the others don’t have it, or is it actually a component of some other ingredient?
Another question is the cheaper powders don’t list a bunch of vitamins and minerals (B vitamins, magnesium, niacin etc). Are these vitamins/minerals actually beneficial in a powder, or should a balanced diet provide enough of them anyway?
All will have it to some degree or another! Glutamine is an amino acid, so it’s actually contained in whey protein itself. It would be part of the “whey protein” you see on the ingredient list. Some have extra added in though.
I think any will do just swell 🙂
Hey Shane, I just wanna say that I really do appreciate you sharing all this vital information for all of us. I know a lot of us have been struggling to gain weight and couldn’t find the right solution to it. But thanks to you, now we have. Just have a quick question for ya. I tried reading through this large list of comments and posts but couldn’t find this question I had for you.
I just started doing a routine which requires you to workout 6x a week. Would you recomend using your workout drink 6x a week, especially if your double or triple dosing it? Or would you recommend using single doses and doubling it or tripling it every other day so to say? I ask because I have seen that your program is only 3 to 4x a week compared to the 6x that I am currently doing. And just a quick fyi on myself, 6′ 4″@ 150 lbs.
No problem man – glad I can help!
I’m guessing it’s some sort of triple split routine or something? Legs, pushes, presses, legs, pushes, presses? Hit each muscle groups twice per week with a short 20-30 minute workout, unlike the three times that we hit each muscle group with our hour-long workouts? Similar idea to ours, just a different way of structuring it for people who like training much more frequently.
If you’re having this massive muscle-building shake every day it might be hard to get in enough calories from whole foods for your diet. You might not get all the vitamins, minerals and fibre that you need for your body to work optimally. You could use smaller doses, yep! A single dose, for example, would still leave plenty of room for whole foods 🙂
Good luck man!
Hey, amazing article! I wanted to ask you if there are any differences, maybe advantages or disadvantages between On Whey and Nitro Tech? I am trying to afford one of those, but I am not sure which one.
Thanks for the kind words man, glad you liked it! Um I’d just buy my whey protein and creatine separately, since that would give me more control over the dosages and would likely work out to be cheaper. But Nitro Tech, with both creatine and whey bundled together (and admittedly a couple other relatively useless ingredients – not sure why there’s fat in there) would still be great! It’s protein and creatine, after all, both of which are pretty much the best muscle-building supplements ever. Whichever you like 🙂
HI Shane!
Im 130Ibs. and I did a bulk last Summer from 118Ibs.-140Ibs. like a boss in only 4 months. Only problem was I had a gut so people were shocked about my arms muscles but when they go tuh touch my stomach haha! That was not so good LMAO! Anyway. Now im 130Ibs. Taking a weight loss program that does cardio and light weight lifts. Has me making veggie meals and having a High carb meal as post and pre workouts meals. the other 3 meals are low carb. Do I want this in my 130Ibs. gut situation?..or do I want Cardio every other day with Complex Movements. I just thought that with the fat and all, maybe ide want fat loss foods and such? Not sure, maybe you know which I should do. I hear a lot say do Complex Movements and Cardio every other day. I also hear do fat loss but im worried that too much cardio and veggies might make me skinnier actually!? BUT i have a gut so im confused as to what i should do. Im also worried that Complex Movements with my gut might not work and so i was thinking i should continue with a weight loss program? What do you guys think and would Complex Movements help me gain abs with my gut at 130Ibs. i have now. If i do Cardio every other day. Which between these too seems more beneficial in my case? If you’de like to see a pic of how i look. Ill post it where you want me to if i must.
Ah that’s awesome Branden! Gaining 22 pounds in four months is no joke – congratulations! 😀
You actually want to continue doing a muscle-building weightlifting program. The last thing you’d want to do is successfully build a ton of muscle … and then lose it all by doing a weight loss routine. That’s very very common, especially for guys like us. The problem is, then you get in this cycle of bulking up and gaining fat, cutting down and losing muscle, etc. It’s hard to get ahead that way. You want to keep doing everything you can to build muscle even when losing weight, because that is what will guarantee that your muscle sticks around as you burn the fat off!
So I mean … cardio – meh. I don’t do cardio when I cut. None. I just lift weights the same as ever. All I do to lose weight is adjust my diet (mainly by reducing my calories so that it brings me into a calorie deficit). Weightlifting + a strategic calorie deficit = losing fat AND ONLY FAT.
Similarly, when it comes time to bulk again (if you ever want to bulk again) then you’ll want to be a bit more mindful to keep it lean, too.
Check this post out:
https://bonytobeastly.com/should-you-do-cardio-while-bulking/
(You’ll see an example/photo of what a good cut looks like, too.)
I hope that helps!
That sort of helps man. Ive been making a diet for a few weeks now and working out. I lost muscle still because ive been looking up what exactly I need. I just spent $37 on a weight loss program cause I thought I wanted too lose the fat. Turns out that will just make me skinnier. I really need a vegetable diet that has me taking in veggie drinks called a Detox Drink in the morning (you blend up a ton of veggies for the vitamins). Then if im going for abs and muscle building. No gut popping out. For the morning meal. Would I want to start my morning with something like Oatmeal with some Whey Protein in it?..or would I want to go with a veggie drink and some Spinach Salad? I don’t mind either 1. Which ever would benefit muscle and no gut the longest. I don’t need a 6 pack but I don’t want a gut either. So do you recommend in my situation (being 130Ibs. with a gut) a Low Carb meal with half scoop of Whey Protein in the morning and High Carb post workout with a Multi-Vitamin?..OR a High Carb meal for the morning and with that Oatmeal and Whey Protein inside that? Also if I don’t want a gut. Should I do my best do get calories from FAT FREE MILK? 🙂 Let me know how you’de go about this and if I can send you a picture through email please allow me to. As I have spent about $1500 total looking for help and I just want real help now. Thanks for your time.
Hey Braden. As a skinny fat ectomorph who has lost the belly while gaining some muscle, I can understand your situation. My advice is that everyone is a little different on how their body reacts to certain foods. I’ve read a lot of advice on the web and it differs greatly. What I found that works is too experiment with your foods and what you eat. Keep the vege’s and protein constant and see if carb’s or fats make you feel more bloated. For me, I found that a lot of carbs did it to me, especially fruits. So I cut fruits out except for after working out. Now that I’m a little bigger and eating cleaner and more protein, 200g per day, I can handle and actually need the early morning carbs in the form of steels cut oats or sweet potatoes. But you may be different. Remember to try and change one thing around and see how that effects you, that way you can pinpoint it. Also, I noticed that the more food I put in liquid form, the worse the results. Eating solid foods, especially proteins helps a lot. Easier said than done when you’re trying to get to 200g of protein per day.
Wow thanks! That advise will really help me out and I heard Fish oil in liquid form is best for us. Better benefits. Also since you said stay aways from too much liquid. This is not implying water right? If it is. How much water do you recommend as I drink anywhere from 6-10 Tumbler cups worth. Let me know if that’s too much. Also look at what a tumbler cup is lol. There big but I thought that it was the right amount for each full drink of water. They say 6-8 bottles a day. Maybe my Tumbler cup is worth like 2 bottled waters. Also could you tell me what you eat daily when your trying to build yourself up (working out)? Im struggling with my Diet and I have my workouts completely written down. Here are my workouts for each week. I mix it up but not sure if its necessary. Here it is:
Compound Movements: Deadlifts, Squats, Bench Press, Clean and Presses, Close Grip Bench/ Close Grip Curls. (3 sets of 5 reps on all) I do this Monday, Wednesday, and Friday.
Then I do Muscle Groups in form like this. Chest/Triceps. I do these in movements that use both muscles at once cause I heard we don’t want isolation movements because we need our workouts to be done fast.
In order too maintain a 6 Pack you must involve abs workouts and some cardio. Just not running cardio or long cardio. I do use HIIT Cardio after Compound Workouts. Is this good use of workouts and seem just right, or do they seem like they could affect me. I heard eating is usually our problem but maybe my workout plan is too. .?
Hey Branden, I’d focus on the bigger picture first. I would worry more so about the overall quantity and quality of what you’re eating, and less so about WHEN you’re eating those things. For breakfast and every other meal you can have what you like – all your options sound great – but I would also aim to set up your meals so that they’re making it easy for you to get in the daily calories / macros you need to accomplish your goals.
So, for example, you’re having a vegetable smoothie for breakfast. Smoothies are a great way to more easily eat more calories, since they’re liquid (and liquid calories are very easy on the appetite). I would put a protein and fat source in there to fully round out the meal. Maybe some whey, milk, greek yogurt, eggs, or etc. At that point it would be helping you consume enough protein, veggies, fats, etc to build muscle and gain weight.
(You don’t need a detox drink. We have livers, urine, feces, kidneys, sweat, etc., and those bodily functions do a great job of keeping us free of toxins. You can definitely blend up fruits and vegetables though – they’re fantastic for your health.)
It sounds like you also want to trim off your belly though, so maybe gaining weight isn’t at the top of your priority list right now, and you instead want to emphasize burning fat. In that case you’d want to be consuming FEWER calories to get your weight moving down overall. You’d still want lots of protein (to maintain/build muscle mass) but at that point you might not want to be getting it from liquid sources, like smoothies, since they make it easy to eat too much.
No need to do cardio or ab workouts in order to have visible abs. Cardio is what you’d do if you wanted to build up better cardiovascular endurance. It’s not really a body composition thing, unless you’re using it to create a calorie deficit. See this cardio article for more on that.
If you’re looking for real help, individual coaching is included with the program, and we’d love to have you! It sounds like you need a solid breakdown of the fundamentals of this muscle-building and fat loss stuff, so I think you’d really get a ton out of it 🙂
Hey thanks for that great advise. So you program will cost $197? That way too much. Almost all programs that offer the same thing cost anywhere from $30-$90. If this program costs almost $200 ill have to go with a cheaper program but I like the advice. Ide rather do what im doing now and wait until I find what I need for about $100 cheaper than a near $200 program. I have a lot down well right now. So is the program really $197 did I see that correctly haha? Also doing Compound Movements 3 times a week. Then Muscle Group Workouts 2 times a week. Then repeat, is this a good set up for mass and strength. Note that between these days, I have abs exercises between workout days so that I maintain a 6 pack and don’t end up fat again. You like this set up?
Hey Branden, no worries – we’ve got the blog for guys who don’t want to sign up, and this year we’ve got plans to come out with some really cool free articles and content! I hope that helps 🙂
I’m sure there are many good programs out there at various price ranges too, so I suspect you’ll be able to find a good one for you, if you decide to go that route.
Compound movements three times per week sounds great – that’s what our program involves as well. You don’t need to do ab work on rest days, and that wouldn’t really influence how fat you’d become. Your abs are like other muscles – if you train them to get bigger and stronger they’ll get bigger and stronger. This won’t cause fat loss, it would instead cause muscle growth. As a result, causing growth in your abs would actually make your waist BIGGER. It would be bigger in a muscular sense, but if you’ve got any fat on top of the muscle it will just push it out further. On some people this can make them look fatter. If you’re lean though, a very muscular waist can often look good! It depends on your goals.
I don’t think training your abs six times per week would result in more muscle growth than training them three times per week though, just like training your arms six times per week wouldn’t result in bigger arms than if you were to train them three times per week, so I don’t necessarily think that would lead to a bigger waist … or really do much good at all!
Good luck man, and I hope you continue to check out the blog!
Wow thanks. That advice was very helpful to know. God Bless! 🙂
No problem, man – glad I could help. Happy Easter 🙂
Oh yeah thanks lol! Happy Easter 🙂
Hi! What do you think about “Carnivor Mass” as a weight gainer for ectomorph guys?
I only can afford to buy a post-work out supplement, and this one got proteins and carbs, and some other things.
Thx
Ah if you buy a pre-mixed gainer you’ll burn through it in a flurry. Since the bulk of those tubs are just dirt cheap carbohydrates (maltodextrin, usually) you’ll use up the entire thing in just a few servings. The only reason I’d recommend something like that is if you had a SURPLUS of things you can afford 😛
One of the reasons we recommend mixing up your own blend is for exactly that reason – so you aren’t wasting a ton of money being uncharged for cheap carbs. Maltodextrin on its own is crazy cheap, maltodextrin pre-mixed into a gainer is crazy expensive.
I’d go for whey protein instead, which will cost a similar amount but last you faaaar longer, and get your carbs separately from cheaper sources, like a maltodextrin supplement, rice, beans, bananas, potatoes, or etc. You’ll build just as much muscle that way and save yourself some money 🙂
I see. So i guess its better to get some protein and prepare some carbs at home. By the way, what do you think about those supplements that combine more than 1 type of protein? Something like Myofusion:
“Whey Protein Concentrate and Isolate, Egg Albumen, Milk Protein Isolate and Whey Hydrolysate”
I prefer whey, but blends are certainly good too! I’m not sure how reputable that brand is – there’s been some controversy about some of their products – but I really can’t say for sure. I’d do some research into it first, anyway.
It would be great. Thanks for your answers!
Hey,
I am a 37yo male and my height is 5ft10 and only weigh 65kg. I think that’s about 143 pounds (very thin). Is that weight very abnormal for my age and height?(medical problem) Or is it just that i am a ectomorph/hardgainer? Not sure where to even start being so underweight.
Hey Jason, I started off at 6’2 and 130 pounds, which is what my dad used to weigh back at my age too. Many of us are just thin as a body type – we’re just slenderly built. That has to do with our metabolisms, bone structures, stomach capacities, muscle makeup, appetite, limb lengths, insulin sensitivity, etc.
Where to start? You’d want to start strategically lifting weights to encourage your body to grow stronger, and you’d want to eat enough quality food to grow bigger and heavier!
More specifically, haha you’d want to start with a program like Bony to Beastly! Helping naturally thin guys build muscle and improve their health is our specialty. And on that note, I really hope you decide to join us 🙂
Thanks for the great article.
May I ask what are your comments on beta alanine and how much would you recommend taking when first beginning and what would your schedule for taking that amino acid be? (I’m intending to take it with creatine)
Cheers,
The studies looking into beta-alanine and building muscle use around 4g per day, and it seems to be effective at that dose! Not nearly as effective as creatine, and it hasn’t been nearly as well studies … but I think if you’re looking for a little extra edge that’d be a good supplement to add on top of your creatine – good call 🙂
Like creatine, you’d take it everyday and the timing doesn’t matter much. Consider it like a vitamin, where you just want chronically higher levels.
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/21659893
Hello,
This looks like a site that’s for me.
I’ve never been able to put muscle on even after years of going to the gym.
I’m 5foot 8 and 140lbs however my big disadvantage now is that I’m 51 years old.
I’m still fit but now want to at least try and bulk up.
Is my age going to that big of a stumbling block? Will I have to modify the workouts?
Richie
That’s a good question! It will probably be a little harder to build muscle than it would have been if you were starting at a younger age … but I mean it’s always best to start these things way in the distant past, and there really isn’t much you can do about that at this point in time. I too wish I’d started far younger 😛
You’ll just want to take a couple extra considerations. If you join the program give me a shout and I’ll set you up. We’ll start you off with the higher end of the hypertrophy range at first so that your tendons and ligaments get a bit of time to adapt while you’re still building optimal amounts of muscle … and then we can gradually gear you down into the heavier strength stuff so that you can take full advantage of that side of things.
The really good news is that at your age this stuff is INCREDIBLY good for your health. Maintaining (and building) strength and mobility as you age is what keeps you young. This style of training is often called “the fountain of youth”, and it becomes especially important at your age, where you risk losing muscle mass as you age if you aren’t proactive about it.
Does that help? And I hope you decide to join us!
Can you tell me why using the gold standard whey protein would be better than using isomass extreme weight gainer protein? It seems to have more protein more carbs and more of everything else than the gold standard whey.
Any advantages of using the gold standard? If im trying to gain muscle mass wouldn’t the isomass gainer be better?
It’s not that one is “better”, per say. The weight gainer you’re looking to use will probably taste pretty decent (as far as gainers go, anyway) and be very convenient. The downside is that you’ll be paying an arm and a leg for simple carbs (like maltodextrin) because it’s pre-mixed into the gainer. If you calculate out the cost per serving, and then look at how many servings you’d need to take to hit our recommended intake … you’ll find that it’s really quite expensive!
We’re essentially making our own weight gainer so that we can get the best of all worlds. We like to buy the protein separately from the carbs in part because it’s way way cheaper – wey is the cheapest and most convenient type of protein, maltodextrin is the cheapest and most convenient type of carb – and also because it’s more versatile and customizable. You can easily mix and match your ingredients to help you hit your daily macros. (You’ll have protein on hand if you need to boost your protein intake on rest days, for example.)
Does that make sense?
Yes makes perfect sense. Just seems that on the back of the gainer it has alot more amino acids and other ingredients that are not in the whey protein. They might just be fancy names on the gainer but if you can take a look at the supplements in the gainer and let me know if everything i need is already incorporated into your shake.
Ah amino acids are simply a more complicated way of talking about protein. Protein is broken down into amino acids, just like fat is broken down into fatty acids. So whey is made up of fancy amino acids too, it just isn’t bragging about it quite as well 😛
The gainer is just very well marketed is all.
hey , wat do u think about pro complex gainer is it good for us with good workout and eating ? ( i try to eat alot ) 😀
If you browse up a couple comments (or search for the word “gainer”) you’ll find a bunch of answers about weight gainers. Long story short though: I’d save your money and buy the ingredients separately, as outlined here.
what about casein protein before bed ??
Sure!
Sure! 🙂
Putting together a “supplement budget” and will be purchasing through your affiliate links. My question is this: regarding the fish oil, did you mean the serving size is a teaspoon or a tablespoon? Amazon has the serving size as tea but you have table. Just wondering which one I should go with as a 160lb 6ft ecto. Thanks for all the great info here and looking forward to the next installment. Always learn a bunch!
No problem man, and glad to hear we could help!
The dosages on the bottle don’t always line up with what the studies show to be most effective / safe. I meant tablespoon, but many of the benefits can be seen with just a teaspoon (the longterm health benefits especially) so you could use the recommended dosage on the bottle if you like! (You can also consult your doctor with this stuff.)
Higher dosage means less muscle soreness, a more balanced overall fat intake, potentially maybe some body composition benefits, etc.
I hope that helps!
Yes, that does help. Thanks Dr. Shane!
Hi Shane – First off thanks for all the amazing info you guys have put together for free on this site. I found it about 6 months ago when I started working out and was looking for ectomorph-specific advice. It really helped me make sense of things!
Unfortunately I can’t afford to do your program (yet!) but have instead been learning bodyweight progressions which I have LOVED! It’s been a great entry into fitness – I’ve gained about 25 lbs, more strength than I’ve ever had, and the changes in appearance have given me a new found confidence.
I have a couple questions for you though about this supplement protocol since I only added it to my routine about 3 or 4 weeks ago:
First off I’m taking about an equal 90g whey / 90g maltodextrin which I consume throughout my workouts. About 15 minutes afterwards though, I feel awful – like the worst sugar crash ever. Yet your reasoning for the high dose of maltodextrin seems solid – Incorporating the shake into a diet that’s reduced in carbs and higher in protein than what I’d been doing the previous 5 months has for sure produced a leaner bulk. I like that! But the crash is really rough – I even get a headache. Should I consider a different carb for the shakes or maybe just reduce the amount of maltodextrin per dose?
Secondly – Is a shake like this appropriate to accompany bodyweight exercise? I’ve heard elsewhere that creatine is more intended for traditional strength training but I don’t know enough about it to understand the reason. I work my muscles to failure as I would if I were lifting: 12 reps x 3 sets per exercise and usually 4 different exercises per muscle group 4 – 5 times a week.
Anyway that’s a lot for 1 post so I’ll just leave it at that – look forward to hearing from you when you’ve got a sec. Thanks again and hope to have some cash saved to give your program a try in the near future. Peace!
Hey Patrick,
Your rep range is good – 12 reps is heavy enough to cause muscle size growth … if the intensity remains high enough. If someone held a gun to your head at rep 12 and told you to do three more reps … ideally you’d be able to grind out no more than two more and then fail (and, sadly, be shot).
If you become stronger with your bodyweight lifts to the point where the intensity of your lifts is no longer high enough, then consuming a big calorie surplus will probably start to make you fatter, not more muscular. You’re going all the way to failure though, so you’ve even got some intensity to spare. And you’re still in heavy rep ranges. This whey/maltodextrin protocol should thus work very well.
Creatine will work well for you too – heavy/moderately heavy rep ranges are exactly what it’s for. It will help you crank out more heavy reps and build even more muscle.
As for feeling sick afterwards, reduce the dosage. Try using 1/3 the size to start, and then work up as needed/desired.
I hope that helps!
I’m about to start this protocol. I’m feeling optimistic. wish me luck!
Good luck, man 🙂
As an ectomorph who finds it hard to build muscle despite optimal exercise routines, I must thank you for a wonderful series of posts that have guided me to the best results I’ve experienced for YEARS! I have no idea if creatine and whey protein supplements had anything to do with these results (I haven’t tried them before), but if that’s the “secret”, then I owe you big time for the recommendation, Shane. 🙂
Ah that’s great, man – really glad we could help! Whey protein and creatine can be really useful muscle-building supplements indeed 🙂
Hello! I got a question and I am wondering if you an clear.this up for me. So I just finished reading this article and I am surprised.there is nothing about Weight Gainer protein supplements? Are those just out of the picture for us skinny guys? Or are they just not recommended? I know no supplements are the best. But you seem to leave only choices rather than a true recommendation? This site seems to actually give me some confidence for my gains! Planning on purchasing the ebook.
Hey Eric, good question! Far from being out of the question for us, weight gainer supplements are designed specifically for us! In fact, what we’re doing is essentially CREATING a weight gainer supplement from scratch with proportions designed to optimize results for us. A weight gainer is just protein (usually whey protein) mixed with cheap carbs (usually maltodextrin). Pre-made weight gainers are fine, and you can go that route if you prefer. This is a little more custom tailored and a little cheaper because you aren’t paying a premium for a proprietary blend of empty carbs. The maltodextrin we’re recommending is very effective and very cheap (as it should be). Sometimes the pre-made ones will add in some sort of marketing angle, like talking about the leucine or amino acid profile of the protein or whatever (although it’s just regular whey, and all whey is rad).
Having all the ingredients separately also means that you have a protein powder on hand for days when you need some extra protein in your diet, you have creatine that you can take separately on rest days, since you should be taking creatine every day. And you’ve even got maltodextrin if you need to toss some carbs into your diet in a hurry.
Weight gainers are very convenient though, and Optimum Nutrition makes a decent one called Serious Mass. It’s only a tiny little bit more expensive than buying the ingredients individually 🙂
I hope that helps, and also that you do decide to join us, man!
Shane, thanks for the response. Now I got a few more follow up questions, if I may! I really researched for the past few days and I believe you are right. I would rather stick to the “mixing my own protein shake, the cheap way” route. I ordered myself so far the the Creatine supplment you recommended, and the Whey protein so far. I could not get my hands on the Maltodextrin stuff, unfortunetly (I love in Korea). So:
1.) Are there any other sources of Maltodextrin through whole foods? (I really am trying to stick myself to a whole food diet and really would like to keep the mind set you have written about how supplements should be the icing on the cake). If not, are there alternatives or other names that I can go shopping for at my local nutritional store?
2.) At what time of the day do you recommend on consuming my shakes? For example, should I take my shakes only on workout days? So in other words, how can I maximize my proportions without going through the whole tub without being wasted…(?)
3.) Sorry! In terms of the actual shake itself, do I mix the creatine, whey, and other ingredients all in one package? I am confused as to what to mix with what and what time of day!
Once again, thank you so much.
1) Maltodextrin is just a simple starch. It doesn’t have any magical skinny-boy muscle-building nutrients in it. It’s processed and low in fibre, which is often a downside, but in this case it can mean more bioavailable calories, an easier time digesting it, and less time spent feeling full. It’s in liquid form too, so it’s very easy on the appetite in the first place – very handy for us ectomorphs. And it’s ridiculously cheap. There are other powder alternatives: dextrose and waximaize are also both made out of glucose and will work just as well. (Waximaize is expensive though, so at that point you lose the cost advantage.) For whole foods you’d lose the appetite advantage, but whole food starches will work too: rice, potatoes, flour, etc.
2. While training. Only while training.
3. Creatine + whey + maltodextrin is your workout shake.
Hi Shane!
I am willing to buy the 3 products you recommended:
– Whey
– Maltodextrin
– Creatine
I got a few questios i hope you can answer (please :D)
1.- Ill use them as a post-work out mix. I only go 4 times per week to the gym. The other 3 days, would you recommend me to use any of those? Creatine? Whey? (Maltodextrin ill use it only as a post-work supp because of carbs).
2.- ¿If i dont find these brands, could you recommend me 1 o 2 more for each product?
3.- My height is 1.75 m, and i weight 138 pounds. What proportion of servings would you recommend to me as a post-work drink?
4.- Thanks a lot!
Hey Hector,
1. Use the creatine on off days. You want to use creatine every day. You can use whey as needed to help you hit your daily protein goals. Whether you need/want to use it or not will depend on what your overall diet consists of. Maltodextrin I wouldn’t really have on rest days, but if you need it to help you hit your calorie goals then that’s okay.
2. Ah your guess may be as good as mine at that point! Just do a little research first, and with supplements it’s generally best to choose big companies with lots of independent consumer lab testing. Sometimes the smaller companies aren’t as heavily regulated/tested, so it’s more risky!
3. Start with a single dose, and increase as needed to help you hit your calorie/protein/carb goals for the day! If you take just a single serving and already easily hit your calorie goals for the day, no need to increase the size of the drink further.
4. No problem – I hope that helps! 🙂
What about “Carnivor” from MuscleMeds? Is it a good option?
Hehehe beef protein isolate. Yeah that’s cool. It isn’t necessarily the most well studied, and I can’t think of a reason to choose that over whey, which is exceptionally effective, reasonably priced and very well tested … but beef protein isolate is a valid option as well, sure!
Carnivor comes with monohydrated creatine, BCAA’s and it also has glutamine. And it has a “Carnivor Mass” line, that seems to have maltodextrin with it and some insulin spike technology aswell. The problem is that it doesnt say how much creatine and glutamine comes with it, but if the price is not the problem, i think it is a good option instead of buying 3 things separately, am i right?
thx
Much simpler (and probably cheaper) to just buy Creatine separately. You need a few grams every day, which wouldn’t necessarily line up with your protein needs.
Glutamine and BCAAs are amino acids. EVERY protein source (chicken, fish, eggs, milk, protein powders, etc) will be full of amino acids – that’s what protein is! Whey tends to have the best amino acid profile for building muscle, which is one reason it’s so popular.
Similarly, all protein sources will spike insulin. Again, this is just something that protein does in general. (Cool factoid: this is one of the reasons that protein is so filling – because it spikes insulin so effectively.)
It’s a good option – all sources of protein are good options – but whey would still be the ideal protein powder for building muscle (assuming you aren’t allergic or morally opposed or whatnot). The differences, however, will be small. You can use whichever you prefer.
Hi Shane,
At the risk of repeating a question that has been asked multiple times…
Is there a pre made product that is similar to the workout drink you suggest? I’ve researched a lot of post workout drinks and the list is ENDLESS, but they all seem to be low in calories.
Thank you
Yep! I wouldn’t look for a pre-, intra- or post-workout drink, but rather just a basic weight gainer. Most of the peri-workout drinks are designed to boost your energy levels (caffeine, b vitamins, taurine, etc), give you a pump (arginine and such), and give you some protein (often in the low calorie form of BCAAs). That’s great for your normal dude, but won’t do much to bulk ya up.
There are some good weight gainers on the market at a decent price point. Serious Mass is made by a good company, has good ingredients, it’s well priced, and we’ve got some members who have spoken highly of it. (I’ve never tried it personally.)
I hope that helps!
After following you guys for a while I decided to give this a go. I made my first drink after a workout this afternoon with rice protein instead of whey (I’m lactose intolerant)… man I was surprised how much volume there actually is!
It pretty much tastes like dirt mixed with paint but I’ll keep trying it over the next few weeks and hopefully I see some gains 🙂
Thanks for the great post.
Hehehe dirt mixed with paint. Yeah. That doesn’t surprise me. (The dirt taste is the rice protein. That stuff tastes “earthy” I like to say.)
I hope it works out well! If it allows you to hit your calorie/protein targets, and it’s combined with a solid training plan, you should see results indeed. Just make sure you aren’t relying solely on the supplements. They’re just supplements after all, not any kind of solid muscle-building foundation. They really should help though 🙂
Thanks for the tips! I started out by simply eating more the past few weeks, and I’ve been seeing some gains, so I thought I’d see if adding supplements makes a difference too.
Perfect 🙂
Added whey protein to my bodybuilding diet – and boy, near-instant impact! I’m not exactly an ectomorph, but have struggled with gaining muscle (partly because of my lack of discipline in working out). But three months ago, I promised myself to both exercise regularly and take supplements. Whey protein is the only one I started with – and already the effects are visible.
Hi there,
I stumbled across your site when searching for how skinny guys can gain muscle. Been browsing the website and reading a bunch of articles and comments for the past couple of weeks. Very impressive website and info. Really like the emphasis on research and health benefits other than just “being big” (e.g., posture is huge!). I’ve got a few questions, but first a little background about me so you know where these are coming from.
Late 30’s male, 5’6”, about 138 lbs. Never really got into working out earlier in my life, but my goal now is to be in the best shape of my life by age 40. Always been ectomorph, but I’ve gained some fat around my torso as I’ve aged…not just skin and bones anymore. For the past 8 years I’ve had a *completely* sedentary job. I literally sit for 12 hours/day. Started P90X3 (gain mass schedule + elite block) about 2 months ago and am half-way through. The *only* time I can workout is at night (end around 9:30, in bed by 10 PM). Also drastically improved my diet at the same time (e.g., only drink water, cut sugar by huge amount, more bananas/peanut butter/tuna, etc.). I’ve been using various supplements, too (Universal Torrent, ON Pro Complex, Creatine). I notice some increase in muscle, but only little weight loss.
1) The shake you recommend…WOW. It IS a beast. Tried it for the first time last night and it felt like lead in my belly. Didn’t eat until 11:30 today (more than 14 hours later). I mixed it so it had 60g of protein and 60g of carbs. I was afraid of gaining unwanted weight with the carbs since I’ve already got to lose 10-15 lbs, so started with a 1:1 ratio. Can’t imagine what it would be like if I gave it the full 2:1 ratio by doubling the carbs. Will those carbs make it impossible/more difficult to lose those 10 lbs?
2) Do I need to “downsize” the shake based on my age/height/weight and my goal to lose 10 lbs of fat while adding lean muscle?
3) Also, last night my body temp was high all night, and I think it was related to the shake (digesting it?). Any downsides to drinking it right before bed?
4) My current workout seems stalled. When lifting, I go until failure, but over time have not been able to add more weight or reps. I struggle the same amount now as I did 4 weeks ago on the exact same routines (especially with pull-ups). Yet, I have practically no muscle soreness the day after working out. Have seen slow but steady progress in the cardio parts of P90X3, though. What am I doing wrong?
My plan is to finish the P90X3 cycle I’m on, and then start your program. While I’m tempted to switch sooner than that, I feel I should complete the entire course and judge at that point. You guys seem great…really responsive, supportive, and knowledgeable. If I won the lottery, I’d pay you guys to be my personal trainers. Sorry for the length, but I’ve been storing these up 🙂
Hey Mike, congratulations for trying to get into better shape man! Going from a totally sedentary lifestyle to an active one I think you’re going to be noticing all kinds of improvements, both in your body and in your brain! More focus, intelligence, less anxiety, more energy, etc.
1) P90x is a general fitness program. That’s great – all of those benefits I describe above are due to exercise/fitness in general, and P90x is a great exercise/fitness program. Our program is all about health and fitness as well, but since we’re a program for naturally skinny guys trying to build all kinds of muscle mass, there’s also a huge emphasis on building lean muscle (or cutting while maintaining/building muscle). As such, our workout shake is a muscle-building / mass building drink. If you combine it with something like p90x, which is optimized for general fitness / convenience and isn’t really optimal for building muscle / maintaining muscle while cutting … it may not have the desired effects. For a number of reasons, your muscle cells won’t be as insulin sensitive, so they won’t be hogging all the calories you’re drinking. More on weightlifting/exercise for muscle-building here.
2) I would just have the protein. I’d get your carbs from whole food instead. As for how MUCH protein to have, that would depend on how much you’re getting elsewhere in your diet. The most important thing is hitting your daily protein goals, and yours are probably somewhere around 1g protein / pound bodyweight / day when cutting. 30-60g in the shake itself would probably be good. (Having a carby pre-workout meal or a banana or something 30-60 minutes before training might help if you find the carbs help your energy levels.)
3) No downsides that I can think of, no. Sounds like that’s what best works with your schedule. The heat could be due to any number of things. I suspect it will self-resolve as you acclimatize to a higher protein diet and a more active lifestyle … but if you’re concerned you could bring it up with your doctor.
4) Hrmm I don’t really know enough to hazard a guess there. It could be your nutrition that’s causing the plateau, it could be that you’re going to failure several times per week and under-recovering, it could be that you aren’t building muscle mass and thus aren’t getting stronger because there’s no new muscle to lift extra with, etc. If you’re maintaining strength, losing fat, and seeing progress in the cardio department though I suspect you’re totally winning at p90x, no? Sounds to me like you’re doing better than you think 🙂
(Muscle soreness doesn’t indicate all that much. It feels like it would mean a lot since it hurts, but I wouldn’t pay it much attention.)
I think your plan is a good one! We’d love to have you, and I think you’re going to love this program. Having a good fitness base from p90x is sweet, too. You’ll be joining up in pretty sweet condition to kick ass at emphasizing building muscle (or cutting while maintaining/building muscle) 😀
Well, it’s been 2 more weeks and the bottom line is you give great advice. Went to just using the protein shake (50g) + creatine (5g) once per day, and it’s been working great. The whole heat thing at night has resolved. I do notice over-all having a slightly higher baseline body temp (I used to get cold very easily ), but I suspect this is due to improved cardiovascular functioning and metabolism (?). I think the plateau was over-training. I was doing too much too quick. Could be seen as impatient, or really, really driven…I like driven better 🙂 But, I do recognize my form was suffering. Decreased the weight and focused on form, and that was it. I’m seeing visible results…muscle gain and fat loss plus improved cardio. I’m even seeing some definition in my abs. Still early on and need to lose about 5 more pounds, but you were right…I was doing better than I thought. 1 more month to finish this P90X3 program, then I’ll be ready to start the B2B program.
Perfect. Glad to hear it, Mike 🙂
I think you’re right. Better cardiovascular function (and blood flow) would help distribute heat throughout your body, and the extra overall heat is likely a result of your metabolism burning off extra energy in the form of heat. There’s a bit more on that here:
https://bonytobeastly.com/hard-to-gain-weight/
Sounds like you’re kicking ass – keep it up!
Hi Shane,
I was (am?) an ectomorph asian guy [I thought the tropical weather here might effect our body physiologically and diet]. I gained 14kg from 54 to 68kg on early 2012 – 2013. Now I am maintaining at 67.2kg, 17.6% bodyfat and 52.5(% ?) muscle mass, 29 years “young” with 23 metabolic age 🙂
I’m planning to gain more muscle,reduce fat and break my plateau using this article.
1. I am not sure if i’m still an ecto or ecto-meso type?
2. I’ll take ON whey 5x a day mixed with oatmeal and bananas for during training, is the maltodextrin still necessary?
Planned to work out 3x a week starting this fasting(tomorrow) month.
Thank you.
Hey Saleh, congrats on your gains! That’s awesome 🙂
I think wondering if you’re still an ectomorph or if you’ve become an ectomorph/mesomorph is sort of a semantics question. Is a very muscular ectomorph still an ectomorph? I don’t know. I think that depends on whether you consider ectomorph to mean skinny or to mean having a slender bone structure, small stomach capacity, fast metabolism, etc. Some things can change too, like insulin sensitivity in your muscle and fat cells.
You have whey protein five times each day?! That’s wild!
Maltodextrin isn’t ever necessary, no. If you can get those carb calories from whole foods instead that’s great!
Good luck!
I’ve just found out the real calculation of protein intake i.e : LEAN mass(lb) x 1to1.1g protein. Re-adjust the whey to 3x a day. Now I am 67.8kg, 17.1% b.fat , 22 m.age , 53.3kg lean mass, after 4 days. I also took creatine using the table here http://www.creatinemonohydrate.net/creatine_doses.html .
Hoping to get 18 m.age by Friday.
Thanks Shane ^_^
Ah right on man, keep it up! And no problem 🙂
Shane,
Curious what you think about accelerated hair loss due to creatine use. I’m 27 and my hairline is already receding pretty badly. I’d like to take creatine for all of it’s many benefits (and have already purchased it using your links) – but losing more of my hair is less than ideal. The studies I’ve read were inconclusive but it seems like a lot of people have issues with hair loss after being on creatine for a while. Any thoughts on this?
You mean because of the possible link between creatine and the masculinizing sex hormone dihydrotestosterone (DHT)? As far as creatine goes, if it affects DHT then it could theoretically have an effect on manly man things… like male pattern baldness. One older study looking into creatine’s affects on hormones found that it did have an effect on DHT. Two more recent studies showed that it didn’t. (There are 0 studies looking into creatine and hair.)
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/19741313
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/14685870
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/11252073
Unfortunately my conclusion is the same as yours — the research is inconclusive. My guess would be that there isn’t much to it. But if it were me and I were trying to hold onto my hair I wouldn’t take it, just because the worry wouldn’t be worth it.
(I should point out here for anyone else reading this that in almost all cases having hearty DHT levels is just fine — it’s what gives us our male appearance after all – and not something we need to worry about. However you’d perhaps want to worry about DHT levels in very very specific situations, one of those situations being when trying to stop the progression of male pattern baldness.)
I have a question for you. Three months ago I was diagnosed with hypoglycemia. So essentially I am not allowed to eat processed foods or refined foods anymore, all whole foods for me now (really it isn’t so bad because I will be very healthy now). In saying that I am also struggling in the gaining weight part a lot.
Is it alright for me to take creating? I do the fish oils and vitamin d routine but I can’t dive into the sugar, only complex carbs (even artificial sweeteners send me into the up and down of the blood sugar roller coaster).
Anything you would recommend for a guy like me. I’ve been the same size since I have been 16 ( 6 ft 145 lbs). I was a very promising athlete, but everything my coaches and trainers tried to pack weight on failed and made me feel miserable (12 years later we now know why).
I can’t imagine how creatine could affect you negatively… however I’m totally absolutely unqualified to speculate about that stuff. I’d ask your doctor.
Whole foods are great! Check this post out, if you’re struggling to eat enough to gain weight.
Not being able to have sugar or maltodextrin shouldn’t be a problem 🙂
Hey, Im on a nutrition thingy where I’m supposed to take cell activator pills, whey protein and multivitamin tablets and I follow a systematic routine. This sorta thing is primarily for gaining mass, my nutritionalist says. However, I would like to include muscle gain supplements with this supplementation program that I’m on and I was wondering if it would be OK to do so and if it would help me put on some muscle fast. By the way, I’m a hard worker in the gym, though I’m skinny. Please lemme know your thoughts on this and any supplements that I can incorporate into my current program. Thanks.
Hey Spurgeon,
Your nutritionist has you taking aloe, whey protein, and multivitamins as a mass gaining protocol? I can’t imagine why adding in more calories from whey/maltodextrin, and also adding in creatine/fish oil would be a problem. And that would help you build muscle, yeah 🙂 However with all of this stuff you always want to ask your doctor, of course!
I hope that helps, and good luck!
Hey there I’m having trouble finding the maltodextrin or how ever you spell it but I seen a post of someone asking if mass gainers are fine as my wife had just recently brought me some Mutant Mass, Creakong and Rehab all from Mutant and was wondering if this mix was any good and how you recommend on having these throughout the day or if whey is some special muscle building supplement, I have a very active job in the construction area and I need them easy calories as our breaks are far and few in between. I’m still guessing the fish oil and vitamins are still necessary though and if there was any special kind to get as I cannot find the labels you provide in the article as I’m from New Zealand and do not want to pay for shipping, the main supplement site for New Zealand is shotgun supplements if you’ve heard of it, thanks for giving us skinny guys some hope
Hey James, none of the supplements are necessary by any means, so don’t worry about missing the fish oil or vitamin D. These are just extra things you could add in if you wanted to slightly improve your results. Weightlifting and nutrition (and lifestyle things like sleep) will be what determine 99% of the results you’re getting (or not getting).
As for the supplements you’ve got—that sounds sweet. If you check out the ingredient list on your Mutant Mass you’ll see Waxi Maize listed as the first ingredient and maltodextrin as the second ingredient. Both are essentially the same thing—easily digested glucose polymers (aka starches). There’s also protein powder in there. So Mutant Mass would make a great workout shake. One serving is about the size that we recommend, too. (Rehab is similar, although more specifically made to be taken during the workout period and for a more general body type, so it’s lower in calories. You could take this instead.)
Could you have it instead of a meal, rather than as a workout shake? Yeah. It’s not exactly the healthiest meal out there, but it’s still a source of carbs and protein, so it would be functional as far as building muscle goes.
Similarly, the first ingredient in Creakong is creatine monohydrate, so that’s a good alternative to the creatine monohydrate that we link to.
So it sounds to me like you’re set. Good luck, man! 🙂
Hi Shane!
I am having trouble knowing what was actually updated in September. Can you please let me know how do I identify the updated parts? Also are these updates reflected in the B2B eBook?
Warmly~Rohan
So far the updates have mainly been adding in newer studies to support the existing ones. If you were to search “study” each month you’d see the list of references growing slightly longer each time 😛
(The Alan Aragon and James Krieger bits are fairly new too.)
This past month I just went in and updated the writing a little to make things a little clearer based on questions I’d been getting. I also made the article a teensy bit shorter. I think the beta alanine bit is from the September edits as well (or perhaps August):
“Beta-alanine is a similar supplement that can be taken in addition to creatine. It’s newer and there’s limited research available, but it’s very promising so far. Not as promising as creatine, but still promising nonetheless (study, study).”
The b2B book is still current, and if something ever changes we’ll update it straight away. The member content is always the most current. As far as beta alanine goes, for example, we had it in the member area many months ago! And the section on this workout drink is much more detailed 🙂
We’re releasing an update to the eBook in the next couple days, too! I’m going to update the supplement section with a couple new things, but not concerning this workout drink (except perhaps to make it more clear/more concise!).
And now that you’re a member you should post an intro!
Shane, I am going to post my intro in this week. See you in the member’s area then 😉
Hello, I am a skinny guy (unfortunately) thanks to my father that is also skinny like me. I have a few questions that I hope you can answer if you have the time 🙂 I am 18 years old, and of course at that age you want to look good and want to be confident, and obviously because I’m skinny it is quite difficult, I don’t like the fact that my legs are skinny and just the way that my body looks like…
So after reading your page, it looks that you know a lot of things. So my questions are :
1. Because my father is skinny, can I still gain weight or it is physically impossible due to genetics ? I know that I have tiny bones, like my father, so even with those tiny bones will I be able to muscle/fatten up? Also I know that if I eat a lot of food and especially junk food I’ll fatten up, but only on my stomach (not even on my skinny legs lol).
2. I work out a lot since a few weeks, maybe 6 days a week, one hour per day normally. I start to see some improvements, but even if I am more muscular it doesn’t seems that I get bigger (If you know what I mean). So should I train less? I see a lot of people saying that for skinny guys 3 days a week is good, but I want to see better improvements (I don’t want people to judge me only by my skinniness).
3. Finally, I am also intolerant with lactose and eggs…nice combo lol…I am not 100% intolerant but It does hurt my stomach when I drink a lot of milk or when I eat several eggs. So my question is because I am lactose intolerant, the milk that I drink will not convert into muscle because I have that intolerance? Also, because of my intolerance, can I still take protein supplement?
That were my 3 big questions 🙂 I’m sorry to bother you but at my age I want to look like a normal person, I don’t want to have skinny legs, I hate when people tell me I’m skinny (like if I didn’t know), especially when they tell me to eat more when I more than them (I do eat a lot, but I don’t know where the food goes).
Well, thank you, and I am ready to invest in whatever thing that can help me out of this misery ! Bye
PS: I am french, sorry for any mistakes I made.
1a. Guys with skinny genetics are actually the best at gaining weight (study). It’s harder to reach a larger absolute size, so you may not be able to beat out Phil Heath for the next Mr. Olympia title… but you’ll be able to gain muscle at a faster pace than any other body type until you reach a fit/athletic level of muscularity—looking like Brad Pitt or whatnot.
1b. Manly men store fat in their stomach first, so gaining fat thus means a larger waistline for most guys. You’ll probably find you look better if you aim to build muscle instead of just gaining any kind of weight (and it’ll be better for your longer term health as well).
2. If you’re seeming more muscular but not bigger, chances are you’re losing fat and revealing more of the muscle you already have. Better muscle definition, not larger muscle size. Check this article out as far as training for muscle size goes, and this article for how to eat for muscle size as a skinny guy.
3. The part of milk that you’re intolerant to, i.e. the part that you’re unable to digest, probably won’t contribute to your muscle gains, no, since it would be passing through your body undigested (and causing you discomfort along the way). Lactose is the sugar in milk though, so you’d still be digesting the protein… and thus still getting much of the muscle-building benefit of it. With that said, you’ll probably want to limit/avoid milk (or consume milk with lactase added—the digestive enzyme that you’re missing). Whey doesn’t have lactose in it, since whey is strictly protein, so you should be fine—especially if you buy whey that has more of the carbs filtered out, like whey protein isolate or even hydrolized whey protein (as opposed to whey concentrate). Plus, there are plant-based protein supplements, like SunWarrior! However I’d consult your doctor about this stuff.
I’m French as well, as you may be able to guess given my last name 🙂
If you’re looking to invest in good muscle-building resources, I’d also recommend our program! That’ll answer all of your questions, and a few months from now you’ll be 20+ pounds heavier—guaranteed.
I hope that helps, Damien. And good luck!
Thank you Shane for this elaborate answer !
I might buy your pogram because I’m very interested as I want to get weight + muscles ! I just need to wait to get enough money, I think that my mom can help me out as well.
Au revoir !
Right on, man—hope to see you in there soon! 🙂
Hey Shane,thanks for all the great articles. Regarding this one, i live in Europe so i can’t get my hands on the fish oil and maltodextrin you recommended. Can you give us some alternatives? A list of 2-3 alternatives would be awesome, since international shipping costs a small fortune for me so i’d rather buy from the local online shops. Thank you.
If you search for fish oil at your local shops I’m sure you’ll find a few options. Look for mackerel, sardine, anchovies, salmon. Those are all good sources. Cod, not so much. Then you just want to make sure there’s plenty of DHA and EPA in there, since that’s more or less the whole point.
As for maltodextrin, any will do. (Waximaize or dextrose would be good too.) Hell, you could even buy some oats and grind ’em up in your coffee grinder! Or have some bananas. No need to get fancy. Maltodextrin is just carbs.
When it comes to picking a particular brand, supplements are a situation where bigger companies offer some advantages. They’re more likely to be more closely monitored and thus have better practices / more accurate labels / more third party testing. I would only buy from a small unheard of company if you know and trust them.
Hello… this is my first time on this website and i had a question about the protocol to follow recommended in this article…
For the Training drink… the article says to take it 1-2 hours before working out for optimal results… but then later in the next paragraphs it says to sip it as you are working out and then finish it when you are done with the work out…
Could you please clarify this? Thanks.
Hey Roberto,
I wrote “within” 1-2 hours of training, so that’d be somewhere in the neighbourhood of 1-2 hours before up until 1-2 hours after. That isn’t what I personally recommend, that’s what the research seems to indicate—and we’re trying to avoid making claims based on speculation. However there are limitations there. It seems like to take full advantage of all conceivable benefits the best time within that window would be right before, during and right after, so that’s what we do in our protocol.
I hope that clarifies things!
It does clarify things. Thanks a lot.
One more question… Do you recommend taking the carbo gain every day on top of the training day in the training drink? and how to take it? by itself or with something else?
Taking it just on training days is plenty. You want to be getting most of your calories on a day-to-day basis from whole foods. Consuming carbo gain and the like on rest days would likely mean too many calories coming from processed foods. This could mean, among other things, that you wouldn’t be hitting your fibre, vitamin and mineral goals.
Shane – Learned a ton here and following all the tips over the past 6 months have went from 154lbs to 172lbs on a 6ft frame. By my calcs only 2lbs of that is fat. I still have bit to go before hitting my goals but over the past month or so have noticed something troubling.
Please excuse my frankness, but my urine has become cloudy. You can actually see all these tiny chalk like particles floating about. I drink plenty of fluids and am sure that is not the problem because I still have the cloudiness even when consuming a high rate of water as a test.
I am wondering if my body is no longer absorbing the protein supplements and I am simply peeing it all out. My daily protein consumption averages 0.9 to 1.0 grams/lb of body weight. That doesn’t seem excessive by my research. I am taking the ON Gold Standard Whey (per your suggestion) 3 times per day (1 scoop morning, 1 scoop lunch, 1 scoop evening). The rest of my protein intake comes naturally. (I am a hunter so always have a plentiful supply of fresh, lean protein!)
I would like to try cutting the protein powders as a test, but am concerned that doing so might impede progress. What are your thoughts? Thank you!
Hey Phil, congrats on the 18 pounds! That’s amazing, man 😀
We’re good at building muscle over here, and also trying our best to do it in a healthful way (and have several doctors doing the program and loving our evidence-based approach). But we aren’t medical professionals. We’re not qualified in any way whatsoever to diagnose your symptoms, and I feel like it would be really irresponsible if I were to pretend to be a doctor on the internet. Could be a UTI or a kidney infection or who knows what. I’d just get ‘er checked out so you can stop stressing over it and get back to normal.
I’ve never seen that happen even from a high protein intake (and what you’re describing sounds like a fairly moderate protein intake), nor seen any study mention any side effects of protein like that. But like I said—we really can’t say one way or the other.
As for what will happen to your gains if you go on a lower protein intake, that’s more up our alley! And you don’t need to worry. All the research that I’ve seen shows that an intake of around 1g / pound is healthy for most people in most circumstances, and also that it’s a pretty key factor when trying to build muscle as quickly as possible. Once you’ve built your muscle though, you can lower your protein intake down if you like! Moreover, as you build muscle your body becomes more efficient at processing protein. You don’t need that much to enjoy and maintain your gains 🙂
Will it impede your progress? Maybe. If you’re still keen on gaining muscle super fast you could see what happens, but you may run into a bit of wall—not recovering as quickly, not gaining quite as leanly or something. You could just take a slightly slower pace at that point though (by reducing your calorie intake a little).
Good luck! I hope you get to the bottom of this!
Hi Shane, I’ve been reading your awesome,research-packed website since lastyear and this is my first post. Im 18 yrs old,172 cm,trying to get weight. When i was 16, i was only 52 kg and successfully got to 55 kg by bodyweight exercise and milk+oat+peanut butter mix.
However, things got harder since then. Now my weight hovers around 54-55 kg and that’s it. I’m starting to start gym regularly 2 days ago and i made my own shake mix of milk,honey,oat,greek yoghurt, olive oil and peanut butter. My creatine and maltodextrin are on its way (credit to you!)
The thing is i absolutely have no idea how to gym properly as i tried a lot of machine and not all of them are suitable for me
I’m wondering about what exercise should i do and if my calculation is right now i consume 2400 cal a day including the mix.
And im wondering
What do you offer really in your 200 usd program?
Im kinda reluctant as im afraid my willpower will fail me
Thanks man
Hey Vito, congrats on your gains, man! That’s sweet 🙂
It’s normal for things to get harder as you get more and more advanced. As far as your training goes, check this article out for the main movement patterns, and this article out for which type of training is best. I think they will help a lot 🙂
Check this page out as for what’s included in the program. If you scroll down past the video you’ll see an explanation of everything that’s included. To summarize, it includes the main eBook, which explains how to eat and train for building muscle. It includes the workout program—five months of workout programming optimized for building muscle mass. (The average member will gain 20-30 pounds within the first three months.) It includes a whole bunch of recipes that make the nutrition side of things much much easier. And it includes a year-long membership in the community, and a year of coaching from us (in the community).
Relying on willpower to carry you through a transformation will surely fail. You only have so much. It’s more about making the process as easy as possible while still getting optimal results. This means it requires less willpower, but your progress is still maximally motivational. Many programs are bloated—full of restrictions that just make things harder for no reason, or packed full of things you “need” to do that don’t actually help. We try to keep our program very efficient. The goal is then to transform things into habits as you go along. After your first month or two of eating for muscle, it should become pretty much just as easy as your current diet is—because it becomes a habit. It becomes the default. (This is only possible if it’s an enjoyable and convenient plan though, which is where things get tricky—and where we spend a lot of time!)
I hope you decide to join us, man! I think you’d really like it.
I am exploring the option of taking the workout drink.
Questions
– if dextrose is chosen instead of malto, how many gms of dextrose would you recommend?
– why not add MCTs like coconut oil in the drink as well?
THanks
nKash
Hey Shane,
I am a 20 year-old female, about 5’5(165cm) and 97 lbs (44kg) on a good day. I looked at the results of both the beastly and bombshell programs. Since I’m more focused on muscular definition more so than curves, I was wondering if the beastly program is the one for me or if I need to go with bombshell.
Hey Karissa, our Bony to Beastly program isn’t just for guys in terms of common goals (although that’s true as well) but also in terms of physiology (there are some biological differences between men and women that apply to building muscle). Perhaps most importantly though, it’s a community of guys posting scandalously clad photos of themselves in a private community.
However, neither of our programs is a cookie-cutter-style one-size-fits-all program. If you were to sign up for Bony to Bombshell we could coach you towards your goals on an individual level 🙂
I hope you decide to join us!
Great post, I am ectomorph too, I tried your stack for a month been getting pretty good results, but it been getting super expensive buying all the food. What are the cheap foods that you recommend? I found this post on cheap protein souces, i was wondering that you thought?
Glad to hear it, man. And I feel yeah. Eating more means buying more food. Luckily cheap foods work great. Potatoes, rice, bread, beans, etc. As for the protein sources in the article—eggs, peanut butter, oats and canned fish—definitely! Whole grains, dairy, beans and peas are good cheap whole food sources of protein too 🙂
Thanks!
hey shane its me zuhaib(male) from PAKISTAN i just want to ask u that im little bit skinny n just started a exercise my age is 27 years old nd weight 65kgs and height 6feet so i need some healthy physic n build so what will u suggest me like any kind of proteins powder or routine food and the exercises basically i need 1st some kind fat that can b utilized in the exercise for better build i’ll wait for ur answer…
Hey Zuhaib,
If you’re interested in protein powders you can check out the brand that we linked to in this article. I’d recommend reading the whole article though, as supplements won’t get you very far unless you’ve got a good overall lifting and nutrition routine.
As far as what type of exercise is best for building muscle as a skinny dude, check this article out.
I hope that helps, man—good luck!
Any recommendations for us ecthomorph women? Is possible to alter the training program for a 5’0″, 105lb woman?
Hey Sara,
We actually have a sister program designed specifically for ectomorph women looking to gain weight / build muscle. Check out Bony to Bombshell 🙂
There are quite a lot of similarities, quite a lot of differences.
We’re going to be posting a supplement article on that site soon. For a cliff’s notes, I’d keep the creatine, fish oil, vitamin D, and protein powder… but ditch the maltodextrin. Your calorie needs are smaller (for example, mine are 4,200 per day when bulking) and most women don’t store as much glycogen. The mega-carb/mega-calorie workout drink isn’t needed. Your workout drink would just be protein (1-2 scoops) and creatine. If you want a fun performance booster, Tier One (bottom of the article) would be a good option.
Does that help / make sense?
Does all this apply to skinny women training to become fit too, or just men?
I do not want to be a body builder, just want to gain weight in a healthy way. I already train and eat healthy. I go to the gym 2x a week, and do weight lifting as other exercises. Do just a bit of cardio cause I enjoy it. Eat loads of veg, fruit, chicken ofc ..
I used to take the whey protein you talk in here, and it worked. But just wondering if I need all these three or just the whey protein.
So how would I take these three products on a daily basis?
And if these aren’t right for women, what do you recommend?
Many thanks x
Hey Hilaria,
We’ve gotten a few questions similar to yours, so we’ll be writing up an in-depth post about supplements for women looking to gain weight / build muscle (and be healthy). We’ll be posting it on our women’s muscle-building site, Bony to Bombshell 🙂
In the meantime, here’s how you would modify this plan to better suit a woman:
1. Creatine is the most powerful, safe, healthy and rigorously tested muscle-building supplement for both men and women. Everything in that section holds true for you. (And beta-alanine is the younger sister of creatine. Also effective, but not quite as powerful, newer and less rigorously tested. However you could stack their results by combining both if you wanted to.)
2. Whey protein is the same for both men and women too. We’ve noticed in our female community that there’s often more of a struggle to hit the daily protein goals required to build muscle, so if anything protein powders are more useful.
3. Fish oil and vitamin D are still healthy.
4. Maltodextrin isn’t needed. Women tend to have smaller calorie requirements (for example, I need to eat 4,200 calories to gain weight, which isn’t unusual in our Beastly community, whereas most gals in our Bombshell community need to eat about half that). Women also store less glycogen in their muscles. The intense carb cycling that we recommend for our guys doesn’t really work as well on women.
So your workout supplements would look something like this: 1-2 scoops (30-60g) of whey protein + 5g creatine and maybe 3-4g beta-alanine. (You could have Tier One 30 minutes before training, then a scoop or two of whey in a shaker after finishing your workout.)
Everyday supplements: 5g creatine (and 3-4g beta-alanine if you’re hardcore), a tablespoon of fish oil if you don’t eat much fish, vitamin D as needed, and protein powder if needed to hit your daily protein goals (about 1g per pound bodyweight).
Does that help / make sense?
Perfect. Thank you so much and look forward for more info in the bombshell site!!
Forgot to ask .. so should i buy creatine, tier 1 and whey protein?
Have tier 1 before workout, whey protein after and on days off gym take creatine and whey protein?
And if I decide not to have tier 1 ..
Is it creatine everyday plus whey protein. Do I mix them together on the shaker or have them separate?
Correct. Tier One has you covered with your workout creatine, but you still want to take it on rest days. You also probably want to take protein during or right after training, and then on non-gym days as needed (if you aren’t getting enough from whole foods).
If you aren’t having Tier One while training, just toss it in with your whey while training, and have it at any time on non-gym days.
Hey Shane, I really appreciate you writing up this article. This is exactly what I’ve been looking for, but I do have a question. On both workout days and non-workout days, is it okay for me to mix some of the maltodextrose in with my water so I can keep my carb count high?
Hey Chris,
It would be better to get more of your calories from minimally processed whole foods, but if it’s the difference between getting your calories in or not getting your calories in, it might be necessary in order to grow. (Ideally you want 80% or so of your calories coming from whole foods.)
Hello,
I’ve been working out for about a year and started taking supplements a few months ago. First I took a combined weight-gain mix which had protein and carbs. I used to take it after the workout, then I broke it up and took half before and half after.
Recently (after I ran out of the other thing) I bought some whey protein and some carb mix. The instructions on the package suggest to take the carbs BEFORE the workout. It also says don’t exceed 50g/day. Also the protein suggests to take 1 portion (28g) before and 1 after the workout, and 1 on off days too.
So what I do now is take most of the carbs (~40g) and 28g protein ~1 hour before the workout and then 28g protein and ~10g carbs after. I also take 50g carbs and 28g protein on off days. I noticed that taking a shake before the workout helps a lot. I used to get sick/nauseous by the end of the workout, probably for a lack of calories. Now I don’t. Previously I ate bananas or muesly bars before the workout to help with calories, but honestly the shake is cheaper and more convenient…
(I also eat real food after I get home after the workout.)
So my questions are: Is there any sense in taking proteins before the workout? Could taking more carbs/day than suggested on the package be harmful? Should I even consider taking more carbs? Should I take more carbs after the workout?
Thanks in advance!
ps.: I’m about 53kg (I used to be 50kg till a few months ago!!!)
Congrats for the 3 kilos, Galev. That’s sweet 🙂
There’s a benefit to consuming protein before and after your workout. A meta-analysis of all studies conducted into timing protein found that consuming protein (food or supplement) within an hour and a half before lifting has some benefits. And also found benefits to having protein within an hour and a half after working out. Other studies have found a benefit to having whey protein right after training, perhaps because it’s so good at stimulating muscle protein synthesis and it’s so quickly digested.
You don’t need to be super specific with your timing, you’d just want to be consuming plenty in the meal before you train, maybe supplementing with some while you train, and then having another meal with plenty of protein shortly after—within an hour or two.
Having carbs pre-workout (and a higher carb diet in general) can boost performance in the gym for sure 🙂
Could more than 50g of maltodextrin be harmful? Probably not for a skinny guy with a healthy body fat percentage, a hearty metabolism, who’s able to regulate his blood sugar (i.e. not struggling with diabetes) and who’s lifting weights. Especially in the context of an otherwise healthy diet. In that case lots of carbs can really help you accomplish your goals. So for you, mind you I don’t know much about you, I would guess that it would be okay. But as with everything, it depends. I would ask your doctor.
I hope that helps!
Thanks for the answer!
Hey, guys! I love everything you guys do! I have one question. What would happen if I were take everything (protein, maltodextrin, and creatine in a shake) but omit the NutraSea? Would that be okay? And what would I potentially be missing?
Thanks for the kind words, Matthew. Glad to hear you’ve been enjoying our articles 🙂
If you take everything else but omit the NutraSea you’d just be missing out on the healthy fats found in fish. It’s not a necessary component or anything, and you’ll still build muscle like a beast 🙂
Thank you, Shane. And may the force be with you.
Hey guys! So glad I finally found this site! Been looking for a training drinks for years now. Just have a quick question for you. I weight train 3 days a week and down the training drink just like you said to do, but I also play basketball once a week for a good 2-3 hours. I was wondering if I should be taking the training drink on my basketball days as well. Any suggestions would be awesome! Thanks in advance!
You could, but keep in mind that maltodextrin isn’t super rich in vitamins, minerals or fibre. It’s not unhealthy, per se, but it also isn’t packed full of non-caloric nutrients. I would limit your use of it. If your diet is great otherwise—made up mostly of whole foods—then I doubt it would be an issue. Having a big whole food meal after your basketball games would also do the trick though while also having the benefits of whole foods!
When you burn a lot of calories though, sometimes you gotta eat a lot of calories… even if they aren’t the most nutritious ever!
thanks so much for the reply! i’m 3 weeks away from finishing a workout from Men’s Health magazine so i’ll keep your workout on my radar when i’m done!
Great article,sort of..creatine i don’t believe is safe.Causing muscle to absorb fluid.Well your heart is a muscle,and you don’t want it bulky or filled w fluids it doesn’t normally have.(hasn’t been around long enough for long term study yet..Anything that gives you a quick result like that can’t be good long term.I gained about 5 lbs per yr naturally and kept most of it.Going from a painfully thin 6’2 and 155 to 185.I’m now 50 and 172 could get more muscle if i backed off the cardio.I bike run lift yoga and kung fu. Truthfully skinny guys need more quality food,lots of steamed broccoli and spaghetti w meat sauce is my go to gainer meal. finish w ice cream, daily eat 3 servings of fruit,tons of water(except during meals).big salad for lunch and w dinner.Protein shakes w egg or whatever too.roast a chicken 1 time a week,veggies w sweet potatoes!!! super sets of 1 muscle each gym trip too.You got to push yourself,ever feel like you want to puke after a workout,well that was a rock star workout!1 time a week kill it!!! Good luck.
Hey Patrick,
Congrats on having gained over 30 pounds, man! That’s awesome. The meals you’re suggesting are great too. I’m a big fan of eating tons of fruits and following up dinner with some ice cream 🙂
Guys can gain 20+ pounds of muscle per year even without creatine. Hell, I gained 50 pounds of muscle over the course of a couple years without creatine. I was scared of it at first, and when I did try it, I didn’t notice a difference… so I stopped. Probably a silly choice in retrospect, but definitely proves—as you have—that building muscle without creatine can still go wonderfully well.
So it’s certainly up to people’s own discretion if they use creatine, but I don’t want to spread any unwarranted fear around it. It has been around long enough for longer term studies. In fact, after decades of intensive research, it’s one of the most well researched supplements ever.
Not only does all this research show that it’s safe, they’re discovering more and more health benefits. It’s good for the health of your brain, of your cardiovascular system, of your muscles. They haven’t discovered a single negative side effect. The worst that could happen is that you get a little dehydrated and get a stomach cramp. Unpleasant, but harmless and remedied with a glass of water.
You could certainly avoid it. Perhaps it causes an issue in your grandkids or something. You’re right, in that sense it hasn’t been around long enough. But there’s no reason to believe that would be true. Nowadays, even though I’m happy with the amount of muscle I’ve built, I take a little bit of creatine along with some fish oil and vitamin D just for the longterm health benefits.
Gaining muscle with the help of creatine is still considered natural. Creatine is a safe, healthy and legal supplement that’s naturally occurring in food, not an illegal performance enhancing drug. It’s less controversial than a multivitamin, let alone steroids.
Sounds like your excellent work ethic has payed off, and you’ve grown into a wicked strong and fit physique as you’ve grown older. That’s the dream. Keep it up!
Hi Shane. First off lemme say I massively respect your dedication to this comments section! You guys are great and clearly massively patient to our uneducated news questions :b… I have a couple of these so apologies in advance! … I saw in a previous comment you said to let your body adjust to lifting before going on a gaining ‘diet’.
How long should this adjustment period be? And should I wait even longer before introducing these Supplements? If yes, how long?
I plan on making homemade gaining Shakes for (non-workout days) with whey protein powder, nat.peanut butter, milk powder, bananas, rolled oats and skimmed milk
And then something similar to your epic workout shake in this article. How often should I have either of these? (I’m also planning on 5 mini-meals of pasta/veg with other tuna/chicken/salmon and taking daily fish oil/vit C/vit D/multivitamin ) – does this look good? Also, do u guys offer the program for people in the UK? How does this work with time differences?
Sorry for having so many questions 🙁
No problem, Mike!
1. You don’t need to adjust to lifting before you can start a bulking diet. You just need to start lifting before you start a bulking diet. Same with the supplements.
2. You can have your gainer shake as often as you need to in order to hit your calorie goals. Just try to have a wide and varied diet made up mostly of whole foods overall, which it sounds like you’re planning on doing.
3. I’d recommend only having this gainer shake within an hour or so of your workout.
4. You can sign up from anywhere in the world, and we have tons of guys from the UK. (We also recently promoted one of our raddest members to a coach position, and he’s from the UK.) Since nothing we do is in real time, really, the time zones have never been an issue.
I hope that helps. Good luck, man!
Hello Shane,
First of all, the advice on this site is amazing, thanks. I joined the gym 6 weeks ago and have gained 4.3 pounds, but I didn’t have all this valuable info. However I want more gains, but I can’t really eat as much calories as suggested, I feel my capacity is full around 1700-1 800 calories, Im a relatively short guy 5’6 and my weight is around 109lbs. Buying all the protocol ingredientes seem a bit expensive, so I think getting a supplement that includes them all is a money saving Idea(or it appears )… I’ve been recommended two of them with very high calories and carbs rate, so… What are your thoughts on “Super Mass Gainer” Vs. “Serious Mass” Vs. The protocol?
On a second look to this, which one do you thin might help me to increase weight faster? I’m an actor and will be playing a role that demands me to be fit as F by end of October. The instruction given to me was “We need you to fit in a suit as good as Christian Grey haha”, my cousin (and roommate) bought your program and for what I ve seen is absolutely great.
One las question would be… which kind of supplement would you recommend for diabetic people?, my cousin wants to try one but he has diabetes and most supplements are high on glucose and sugars.
Thanks in advance for everything, have a nice week.
Congrats on the gains, Emmanuel! 4.3 pounds in six weeks is awesome. Stoked to hear that your cousin has done so well with the Bony to Beastly program too 🙂
Generally the pre-made gainers are far more expensive per calorie than the ones you would mix up yourself. This is usually due to maltodextrin being very cheap when bought separately. However, if you can find a premade gainer for a cheaper price then go for it.
I haven’t heard of Super Mass Gainer. Optimum Nutrition’s Serious Mass is good though. ON has been tested by third parties and seems like a really great supplement company.
Which will help you increase weight faster? The one that allows you to consume more calories. Rate of weight gain is determined by the degree of the caloric surplus.
Regarding your cousin’s diabetes question, we aren’t doctors and it would be irresponsible of us to pretend to be. I’d recommend he pose that question to his doctor before getting into weight gain supplements. (Everyone should talk about fitness/nutrition/supplements with their doctor.)
I hope that helps, and keep up the gains!
Hey, first of all i love your postas i’ve been 3 days in a row reading your articles and studies. Although I have a few questions about creatine:
1. Which type of creatine is the best?
2. In which time of the day should I drink it (pre workout /post workout)?
3. 5 grams of creatine it’s okay?
4. I have read that the best way to have creatine it’s too have it for 2 months and stop 1 , have it for 2 months again and stop 1, and continue that Cycle.
Thanks for the support ,best wishes ,Manu , from Uruguay.
Thanks, man. Really glad you’ve been enjoying the blog 🙂
1. Creatine monohydrate has the most research behind it, it’s the cheapest, and it seems to work at least as well as all of the other variations.
2. You can view it like a multivitamin rather than like a coffee. So long as you take it every day your levels will be high and you’ll get the benefits.
3. 5 grams of creatine each day is perfect.
4. As far as I know creatine has never been shown to have a downside when taken indefinitely—just benefits. However, cycling your intake is a good way to play it safe.
Good luck, Manu!
Hey Shane, great work on the article! I’m close to turning 20, about 5’7″, and a slim 137lbs. I lift normally about 4 days a week so I’m a little stalky, but I’m not big on taking supplements. I’m hoping that your program here will help me out. Now I’ll have a protein shake now and then, but I was just wondering about the training mix? Would I mix together the protein, creatine, and maltodextrin all into one drink? I know it’s sort of a dumb question. But if you do take it all together in one mix, do you increase the amount of water that you mix it all with? Or is that just a question of preference?
Hey Ryan,
If you mix it all into one drink you can try to squeeze as much water into the shaker as you can, but chances are the shake will be pretty sludgy. That’s okay, that’s what I do. Just make sure you don’t get dehydrated or anything while training.
[…] Luckily there’s a good fix for this one, and we wrote up a big blog post on ectomorph workout nutrition here. […]
Hi, extremely useful article. I just have one question. I’m intolerant to dairy, so I’m taking a vegan protein shake (link below). Was wondering if taking this vegan shake instead of a whey one would prevent me from achieving the gaining goals? Thanks!
Plant-based powders are great too. Personally, I like SunWarrior quite a lot. It’s a pea/rice blend and very similar to whey protein in terms of amino acid profile. Fantastic for building muscle.
Hey guys! I’m an ectomorph, 131 pounds looking to build more muscle, I have the routine and nutrition but I’m wondering what your take on weight gainers like “Precision Big Time” and “Mutant Mass” and “Incredibulk” are? I know it is loaded with creatine and protein and calories but is it recommended? Thanks!
Yeah those are fine to use instead of mixing up whey, maltodextrin and creatine to make your own. They’re basically the same thing, it’s just those pre-mixed gainers are usually a bit more expensive, a bit less customizable… and they usually taste a little better (but still awful).
Creatine is the most effective supplement that can help a hard-gainer. It not only increases the athletic performance, but will also increase the muscle volume and will give you strength to lift better than before.
Hi Shane,
Great article! I have one question: I’ve been doing triathlons for a year now (sprints, olympics and on half-iron man). I am planning on racing a full iron man summer of 2017. While I plan to continue to swim/bike/run, strength training is a very important component to triathlon training. My question is, do you believe your recommendations from above would still be recommended for someone who is swimming 2x a week (1x HIIT, 1x endurance), biking 2x a week (1x HIIT, 1x endurance), running 1x a week (distance) and strength training 1x a week?
I am 28, weigh 130, eat clean (no fast food, no dairy, minimal processed grains) and have only reached 140 lbs once in my life (2 summers ago)
Thanks for you time and effort to reply to all the comments you receive.
-Marc
Hey Marc, thanks for the kind words, man!
If strength were a factor then these supplements would help, but help a triathlon newbie out here—how could strength training help with a triathlon?
I’ve heard of triathletes who are also into power/strength sports, but I’ve never heard of strength helping with triathlons. Seems like an endurance thing, no?
Shane,
Strength training in the world of triathlon is said, by several credible sources, to be geared towards increased injury prevention and increased anthropometric efficiency. Check out this article if you’re interested in reading further: https://www.t-nation.com/workouts/weight-training-for-endurance-addicts
There are MANY ectomorphs in the world of triathlon that seem to be stuck with the notion that cardio solves everything. From my research, professional Ironman triathletes incorporate strength training as a vital component of their already busy work out schedules. Even more on this topic can be found in Joe Friel’s Triathlon Bible.
Thanks for the quick reply!
Marc
Ahh! Okay I see what you’re saying. So it’s not necessarily to improve your triathlon performance, but rather to build a healthier, more injury resistant body. Sort of like how my friend, who is a professional violinist, lifts weights to maintain her posture, symmetry and strength. It doesn’t directly make her a better violinist, but it improves her quality of life and lengthens her career.
You may have success with alternating your goals now and then. When you have a chance to gear down your triathlon training you could spend a few months focused on building muscle. Then when you rev your triathlon training back up all you’d need to do is maintain your lifting progress, which isn’t time consuming or physically demanding.
To get good weightlifting progress you may need to lift 2-3 times per week and devote a lot of your body’s resources to recovering from those workouts. Extensive cardio work would get in the way of that and introduce the demand for competing adaptations, so you’d do a reduced amount of cardio—just enough to maintain your current conditioning. After those few months of focused lifting, to maintain your lifting adaptations you could just do a lower intensity lifting workout every week or two. That would slot in alongside your other training a lot more easily and allow your body to make more optimal adaptations towards your other goals.
You could then alternate between goals as needed.
Does that help at all?
Shane,
Yes, that makes sense to me, and I like the example of the violin player. Sometimes people get so intellectually and emotionally focused into a skill that they forget to take care of themselves physically which can ultimately limit them.
Also, I sent over an email to us@bonytobeastly.com which I found on this website the day I sent that last comment your replied to on this article. I’m assuming the email did not reach you. Do you have a direct email I could contact you at? I’d like to discuss your website further with you and your team.
Best,
Marc
Hrmm, I don’t have any emails from you here. None in our junk mail folder either. That’s the most direct email for us. I’m not sure what went wrong—we’ve been getting messages steadily from guys this whole time. Maybe try sending it again?
Hello. I’m fairly skinny as you can imagine (6’1, ~145lb’er) and I just recently got a bench press and one of those indoor pull up bars that you hang from the doors. I’ve noticed some days after working out that I get these ‘hunger attacks’ where I get this sudden urge to want to eat something sweet and down it with half a gallon of milk and will start getting jittery as well. I looked up the symptoms and read about non-diabetic hyperglycemia. I have a protein supplement that I use but I don’t have any carb or creatine supplements. After reading this article, I plan on getting both but I wanted to know if taking the carbs specifically might help with this, what I assume to be low blood sugar, issue that I’m getting.
Thanks
I’m no expert but I’ll take a stab at your question… firstly, I believe you are referring to hypOglycemia (hyper = high, hypo = low) which means that you have low blood sugar which is also why your body is craving sweets. I also get hypoglycemia after workouts and at any point in the day when I haven’t eaten for a while. You body is crying out for energy but since you haven’t slowly provided the right amount your brain is telling you to eat sweets (fast calories, fast energy). I believe the carbs would help with this, definitely taking them before your workout so that your body can provide fuel as you’re working out and it will cause less of a drastic drop in energy. If you are really putting your body through the works I think you’ll always have that huge craving afterward but you can mitigate it slightly by providing fuel upfront and then getting more during or immediately after.
I consume simple carbs pre and complex after, I’m no expert and you’ll find just as many that say it works as you will that say it doesn’t but that is what works for me and I get that same thing you do. BTW, having the protein supplement is great for building muscles but your body needs energy which preferably comes from carbs and fat. Protein can be broken into amino acids in order to be converted to energy but it’s not your body’s desired method of getting energy and, more importantly you want those amino acids for protein building blocks, not energy.
Just my two cents… hopefully this helps until someone who knows more can chime in.
Just curious what can be done to make the face look fuller. I have the sunken eye look and my cheeks also have that hollow look to them. I recently put myself on a fairly consistent food / workout plan and I’m slowly making gains but, I haven’t noticed much of a difference in my face. Will this change with weight gain or am I pretty much stuck with what I have regardless?
I recently bought protein powder but have yet to purchase a carb supplement. I read a lot about how this may actually help so, I guess that’s one thing to look forward to.
Your face will fill in too. As you gain weight you’ll build a little muscle everywhere, even if you aren’t directly training every muscle group. So you’ll gain a little muscle in your face, and even a little bit more muscle in your face will make a big difference 🙂
Just keep gaining each week. After a couple dozen pounds I suspect you’ll find that your face is looking fuller and stronger.
Thanks for the reply!
Also. For whatever reason, I accidentally ordered Dextrose instead of maltodextrin. Serving size wise, there’s a bit of a difference between the two as shown below but, I could always just up the serving I guess. Those are pretty close to one another ingredient wise right? Nothing that would warrant a return.
Dextrose: (what I got)
160 cal
48g carb
Maltodextrin: (what you recommend)
250 cal
63g carb
Also, I’m sure this is another question that has been asked and answered many times throughout the years of comments built up above but, should I only take the dextrose supplement during workout days? Or is this supposed to be a daily intake as part of meeting my “macros” (protein/carb/fat).
Thanks for this site as well! Wish I had guys like you who lived around me so I can actually get motivated enough to go to the gym rather than working out from my house.
Hey OP, no worries about mixing up dextrose and maltodextrin. They’re both essentially just glucose. Just match up the serving sizes, yeah. And yes, only take it during workout days unless you really, really need some last minute easy carbs on a rest day. Good luck!
Shane, i have a few cuestiones about the program, i dont know where to ask them so i write here. Where can i ask them? Thanks
Hey Manu, shoot us an email at us@bonytobeastly.com 🙂
Hi!
Ok, so as a “skiny-fat” trying to cut, am I right thinking Creatine + Whey is what I should be doing (in addition to lifting, hahaha!) ? I’m good at eating less to keep the calories low, but you often mention the risk of loosing muscle mass if in protein deficit.
And so stuff like “Aminodrive” is no use, right?
Thank again and keep up the good work. Looking forward to joining you guys soon.
Creatine and whey would be great for your situation, yeah 🙂
Amino Drive is an essential amino acid supplement. Whey protein is made up of a perfectly optimal mix of amino acids already so there’s no need for that. You could have it instead of whey though if you really wanted, but I’d still recommend whey.
Hello shane ive just started to work out my weight is 55 kgs and im not a big fan of food ill be buying thoses three supplements but what should i do with my bad appetite?, and one other thing can i replace the whey with a weight gainer?
What to do about your appetite? I feel ya, man. Check out our article about ectomorph appetite 🙂
A weight gainer is usually protein + carbs (oftentimes whey + maltodextrin). So a weight gainer would replace both the whey and the maltodextrin.
Hi Shane,
would it also be possible to take instant oats instead of the maltodextrin? They have like 60g of carbs, and around 8g of protein and fat.
Totally possible. We’ve got a lot of members who do just that. There’s more fibre (and protein) in the oats so they won’t be quite as easy on the appetite. Still a great option though 🙂
When I ordered my tub of ON gold standard whey a few weeks ago, I received a free tub of ON Creatine monohydrate with it.
I wasn’t really planning on taking it. But after reading this post again I think I actually might give it a try.
But there is one thing that scares me off a little bit, dehydration. You see, I study at University and I like to go out with friends every week. Sometimes we all drink a bit too much (nothing too extreme really! 😉 ) and get a bit of a hangover the next day.
Won’t the creatine make the dehydration that comes with an hangover far worse or even dangerous? I searched on the internet but I didn’t really find any evidence. Only on those bodybuilding forums where everyone is shouting that alcohol is bad and you would better not drink it all. But yeah, I don’t think I need to take this advice too seriously..
What are your thoughts/experiences?
Thanks!
Ah no way! What an awesome bonus to get 🙂
Having a couple drinks per night is totally fine and won’t get in the way of your gains at all. Binge drinking is generally not recommended for building muscle or your general health. Does that stop anyone? Nope. And when I was in university it didn’t stop me either.
Combining drinking a little too much alcohol with creatine? Hrmm. I haven’t heard of that ever being an issue, and we’ve got a lot of guys in the community who disregard our “don’t binge drink!” advice while simultaneously following our supplement advice.
Could give it a try and see what happens? Maybe start small (fewer drinks) and see if it even has any noticeable impact at all? If not, go back to your more normal drinking routine if you want? We’re not medical professionals though, so you’d be doing it at your own risk. It’s just my experience that it’s okay, nothing more.
Taking the creatine for almost 4 weeks now. Weight has gone up with 4lbs wich feels awesome 🙂
My workouts don’t go exceptionally better but I keep setting PR’s every workout. So everything goes well. I’m 140lbs at 5ft8 now (coming from 115lbs at the end of 2014). Looking to gain another 10lbs before 2017. This site has helped me so so so much… Really, thank you guys!
Oh yeah went out a couple times in these 4 weeks and just kept drinking like before. Not experiencing anything at all (I don’t even had a single hangover). So I guess it’s all good.
Just so you know 😉
Glad to hear it, man. Getting PRs every workout sounds pretty damn good! And congrats on those four pounds. Glad we could help 🙂
Great article Shane. The training shake sounds pretty solid, however, isn’t maltodextrin harmful for the body, Wouldn’t it be better to add other carbs such as bananas, oats and such?
Glad you liked it, Andrew!
We have a bunch of members who use ground up oats instead of maltodextrin (most of them from Australia, for some reason). It works well, but oats have a lot more fibre and thus take longer to digest. This means they aren’t as much of an ectomorph appetite hack. They’re harder to digest too, and could result in some stomach upset or bloat in some guys. Bananas have some micronutrients in them and aren’t very filling per calorie, but contain fructose as well as glucose (which in large quantities like this can be problematic).
Research has shown that this kind of protocol results in pretty gnarly lean muscle gains with no observed downsides. Just to be on the safe side though we consulted a nutrition PhD who specializes in this kind of thing to make sure we weren’t forgetting anything. He agreed that in this context it was fine, and effective.
What makes you worried that it’s harmful for the body when taken in this way for this purpose?
Great article shane.
I’m from India and couldn’t get hold of any good US maltodextrin products(too much shipping fee), so I went ahead and bought dextrose monohydrate.
I’m a 120 pound ectomorph with bad appetite.
If I take, say, 100g of dextrose,I’m guessing that would give me around 400 calories (assuming its all carbs).
Now, I was just wondering, if that 400kcal would really facilitate a caloric surplus??
400 sounds kinda little. or should I may be increase serving size?
I dont have much knowledge about all this. So pls help me out.
You can use dextrose exactly like the maltodextrin. I used to do that. No worries there.
400 calories will help you get into a calorie surplus. Keep in mind that a 500 calorie surplus per day (3500 per week) will get you around—very roughly—a pound of muscle per week. So 400 calories from dextrose and a couple hundred calories from protein every workout… that’s nearly your whole calorie surplus for the week right there!
You can increase the serving size though, yeah. If you check out the protocol at the bottom of the article we’ve got some examples of ways to up the dosage 🙂
[…] Muscle-building supplements for ectomorphs (these are optional) […]
is it good for ectomorph to take the supplement Optimum Nutrition Serious Mass?
why it is not included to your supplement above?
You can, sure! Ahaha if you do a search for “Serious Mass” in the article you’ll see it addressed a bunch of times in the comments. In the article we just mention generic gainers, and Serious Mass is just a generic gainer. It’s essentially just whey protein + maltodextrin + a bunch of flavouring things + a markup. No benefit to it that whey + maltodextrin wouldn’t give you, but it’s also a very suitable alternative if you don’t want to make your gainer shake yourself 🙂
can you recommend something for me to gain weight..Im 5′.6″ tall and my weight is only 99 pounds and i need some help to expert..can you help me to gain weigt thats suits my height..shane? and Thank you 🙂
Hey Kelly. This whole site! If you want tons of free tips and tricks, every article around here is written with your specific goals in mind. And if you want a full workout program, to full bulking nutrition plan, a membership in the community, and coaching from us throughout the whole process, check the Bony to Beastly Program out 🙂
Hi Guys,
I’m just starting out at 5’10, 159.8lbs. To put body in perspective, my top two abs are visible and hard as a rock, but the little bit of lower belly fat lingers on. I’m eating clean (brown rice, lentils, meats, veggies), taking supplements (creatine ((5g per day)), whey protein, and fish oil). Also, taking in 3k a day. Your liquid calories advice is spot on. Macros are: 55% carbs, 25% protein, and 20% fats).
Been at it for about 3 weeks (combo of HIIT (2x per week) and Weightlifting (3X per week) and I’m down to 158. I also play basketball once a week (league is almost over).
I have a question for you guys— Am I not eating enough calories? I was going to bump it up to 4k a day in order to reach my goal of 170-175 of muscle. I want to be putting on weight instead of losing and dropping almost two pounds in 3-3 and 1/2 weeks is a concern. Thanks!
Hey AV,
Sounds like you’ve got a very healthy and active lifestyle going on! It also sounds like your energy output is just a little bit higher than your energy input if you’re dropping weight. While 3000 calories might seem like a lot, it’s all relative to what you’re doing. Playing basketball, doing HIIT twice a week, and lifting 3x a week is a decent amount of of exercise. I’m not sure what kind of job you have either or how you spend your time during the rest of the day, but 3000 may be too little for what you’re doing. So it’s time to either eat more or move less. (Eating more and moving more is healthiest but also tricky if you’re already full to the brim). If maintenance is around 3200 calories (since you’re dropping weight at 3000), you could try bumping it up 200 calories daily to 3400 for a week and re-evaluate!
[…] energy from the sun (photosynthesis). Muscles use glucose as fuel too. You’ll see it in most workout drinks listed either as simple glucose (called dextrose) or as a starch (maltodextrin, […]
[…] you want our recommendations for ectomorph post-workout nutrition check this post […]
[…] The first issue is that protein is incredibly filling. Try eating three chicken breasts and tell me you’re still hungry. Having a protein shake like whey makes this a lot easier as it uses the tricks from earlier (no chewing and no fibre). If you want to see what protein powders we recommend, see our supplement guide. […]
“Training drink: 30-90 grams Whey + 60-180 grams maltodextrin + 5 grams creatine. A typical guy would want 30g whey, 60g maltodextrin and 5g creatine ”
In what situation would you use more than 30g whey, 60g maltodextrin?
The article says 30-90g of whey and 60-180g of maltodextrin but doesn’t explain when you would use the larger amounts over the standard amounts.
Hey Jack. That’s a good point. I’ll clarify that in the next update.
You’ll fully stimulate muscle growth with the standard dose, so the main difference with the larger dose is the extra calories. A lot of the more ectomorphic, naturally skinny guys (like myself) struggle to eat enough to gain weight. What this drink does is cram in an extra few hundred calories in a way that’s easy on the appetite at a specific moment in time where it’s unlikely to be stored as fat. The composition of the drink is pretty good for building muscle leanly as an ectomorph as well, since it’s high in protein and carbs, low in fat. So it’s more of an appetite hack, you could say.
[…] The Best Muscle-Building Supplements for Ectomorphs – The Best Muscle-Building Supplements for Ectomorphs. Written by Shane Duquette on November 11, 2012 […]
Hey Shane,
Love you guys work. I have just started working out recently and I was wondering something about this article. I am 5′ 8″ 130lbs. I wanted to know if I can only afford one of these supplements which should I get? The whey, creatine or maltodextrin?
Thanks guys, never stop what you’re doing, you guys are the best!
Thanks, Jay! Glad you’ve been digging our stuff 🙂
Okay, so the basics of building muscle are:
1. Follow a good lifting program
2. Eat enough calories
3. Eat enough protein
Supplements can help with points 2 and 3, with maltodextrin being the best for boosting calories, whey being the best for boosting protein. However, maltodextrin wouldn’t be something that I would take alone. If you’re taking just one supplement surrounding your training, whey would be the go-to.
If you don’t have a problem getting in enough calories or protein, though, then your fundamentals are handled anyway, and creatine is the only supplement on the list that can allow you to go above and beyond what you can accomplish with just food and lifting.
Oh, you could also say that caffeine could help with point 1. So if your energy in the gym were your weak point, some pre-workout caffeine (coffee or pre-workout supplement) would work well. In that case, it might bump a supplement like Tier One to the top of the list because it has both caffeine and creatine.
Hey Shane, I’ve always been a fan of your work and this website. You guys are great! Would consuming a banana or another sugary fruit with a post workout shake would be as effective as consuming the maltodextrin? I know it might be a simple silly question, but I am a tall skinny guy (6’2), so I just want to maximize my ability to increase my gains. Thanks so much!
So glad you dig it, James!
Maltodextrin is processed to the point where it’s just a bunch of easily digested chains of glucose (starch). Fruits contain fructose as well as glucose, the sugar is contained within a plant cell, and they’re quite a bit more filling. So fruits are indeed different, and it’s not a silly question at all.
Looking at the larger picture, though—can you still build muscle optimally if you have fruit instead of maltodextrin? Definitely. I wouldn’t eat more than a couple bananas at a time, though. You could have some whey, a couple bananas, and then a little extra milk, rice, pasta or potatoes with your next meal 🙂
Thanks for creating such a great resource for all of us skinny guys. I have a question about meal replacement options. I wanted to know what you recommend maybe as a breakfast shake to get a great jump start on daily intake. I usually work out in the evenings and can definitely do the main shake you recommend during my workouts. But wanted something that I can use almost like a meal for breakfast or when Im traveling for work.
Thanks
I’d blend some greek yoghurt (or whey protein powder), a banana or two, some frozen berries, maybe a little spinach or kale, some nuts or an avocado, and a little lime juice together. That way it’s not only a meal replacement shake, it’s also an all-around rad meal 🙂
[…] can lift heavier and stress the muscles even more than usual to promote additional muscle growth. Creatine also has the added benefit of promoting fat loss, by aiding insulin sensitivity. This ensures that what you eat is being used for muscle growth […]
Hey Shane, been reading you site/forums for weeks now about to return to the gym in a few weeks time and was shopping around my town in Canada. I have a few questions…
1st – Carbo Gain Powder, 8-Pound is hard to find at GNC and other local stores and I am not willing to buy online due to the wait and cost to ship to canada among other reasons and come to the conclusion that it is a old brand and was recommended Muscle Tech Mass and the Optimum Nutrition Gold Std 100% Whey Protein Powder. My concerns are that both have protein listed in there products and was wondering if I were to purchase one of these as a replacement with how would I use them in my training cause not sure I am willing to double my intake of Protein if its just wasted $$$, or do I use Muscle Tech Mass Pre/During working out and then the Whey Protein Isolates Post work out???
2nd – Muscle Tech Mass has 10g of Creatine Mono in the ingredients is there then no requirement to get AllMax Nutrition CREATINE Powder.
Thanks and looking at getting program in a few weeks.
Hey Pete,
We’re Canadian too. Check this maltodextrin supplement out.
To answer your other questions, that Mass Tech supplement is a weight gainer based on the same principles we outline in this article. They’ve combined maltodextrin, whey protein and creatine to create a supplement that’s good for skinny guys trying to bulk up. That’s cool, and all the same principles still apply. You’d mix up a shaker full of it and sip on it during your workout, then chug what’s left right afterwards. If it were me, I’d have about 1,000 calories of it per workout.
You do still want creatine, though, because you’ll want to take creatine every day for the best results. If you rely on the MassTech for your creatine, then you’d have to take the Mass Tech every day, which isn’t ideal for your health and might not lead to the leanest of gains.
So use the creatine on rest days, then use the Mass Tech on workout days 🙂
Great to know you are all a fellow Canuck, EH! Thanks for the response was pretty quick my only other question then to your response is whether or not I require the Optimum Nutrition Gold Std 100% Whey Protein Powder as well to be taken on off days or is that a no no as well. But in the end, after doing other research the intake of all the extra ingredients from MassTech is not ideal, where as strict carbo with whey isolate 2:1 ration on work outs and then protein/carb 1:2 ration on non training days and stick to nuts and olive oil for my fatty intakes.
We recommend treating whey protein like chicken or milk. It’s fairly minimally processed and contains some minerals and whatnot. So it’s just a matter of: do you need protein? If yes, have some protein, whether that’s whey, chicken or cottage cheese.
I like having whey protein on hand, which is one of the benefits of buying the weight gainer ingredients separately, but it all depends on your lifestyle.
As for how much protein you should be eating, check out our article on protein intake. Spoiler: protein is very important but you don’t need to eat THAT much of it. Most people fairly easily hit their protein targets while bulking without needing supplements, especially if they don’t shy away from dairy, eggs or meat. Vegans and vegetarians will often rely more on (plant-based) protein powder to hit their targets.
I also prefer to avoid all the other ingredients. I get simple unflavoured whey protein, plain old maltodextrin, and regular creatine monohydrate. There’s little research proving downsides to artificial sweeteners and flavours, though.
Just curious if you have any recommended smoothie / shake recipes. Although I stopped working out a while ago, I’d like to -try- and get into shape but, I’d like to work on obtaining a good diet plan before I dedicate time to working out. The biggest thing for me would be my protein intake and drinking it in liquid form would be my best route, imo. Unfortunately, my past experiences with protein shakes were that they were too damn thick just using one serving (25g scoop). If I tried to thin it by adding more liquid, it would end up being this big blender full of shake to drink. I’d like to go the smoothie route simply because of having the benefits of fruits in the mix but I’ve never attempted to make one, especially a protein based smoothie. Smoothie king has this new 45g mango(?) protein smoothie which looked amazing but it got me wondering how they packed 45g of protein into that without it turning into a cake batter.
Also, if I go the smoothie route, I’d probably want to stick with unflavored protein powder. I could of sworn those were more expensive when I looked them up in the past but is there any specific brand you recommend?
If you like mango protein smoothies, give this mango lassi a try:
-3 cups frozen mango
-1/4 cup lime juice
-1 cup orange juice
-500g tub of greek yoghurt
-garnish with mint
You can boost the protein even higher by adding whey, but you’ll get enough protein per serving with that one as is. The greek yoghurt is a little more expensive than whey, but it tastes way, way better in most smoothies. For whey to work well, you generally want more of a milkshake flavour. Milk/yoghurt + whey tends to be a pretty good base because the flavours work well together.
The trick with whey is to blend up your smoothie then add the whey. Blend it for another couples seconds after that. If you add the whey too early into the blending process it’ll froth up into this thick airy batter mess.
Does that help?
Haven’t tried it yet but it sounds good! In terms of adding whey, would you, or do you, use a specific flavor when doing smoothies or do you use unflavored? If unflavored, do you know of any unflavored tubs of whey protein that are priced fairly? Thanks again
Hey Keiv, I do use unflavoured whey protein powder. I like IsoNatural by AllMax. The is expensive if you forget to consider how many servings of protein are in there. When you realize how epically long the thing will last you, the price is actually pretty reasonable 🙂
Hi,
if you had to choose between Whey Protein or Maltodextrin, just to gain weight, what would you suggest? Let’s say my budgget it’s not great. Thanks!
I’d go with whey. Protein is always expensive, so investing in whey can actually save you money because you won’t need to buy as much fish, chicken, dairy, meat, etc.
Maltodextrin is great for getting in lots of easy calories that are easy on the appetite, but you can also accomplish that quite easily with cheap whole foods such as rice, potatoes and bread. Not quite as easy on the appetite, but it should still be manageable 🙂
Shane – In addition to your supplement during/post workout, would you recommend another protein shake before bed with milk (e.g. Casein protein and milk)?
Hey Rob, great question.
You’ve got it totally right. Having some protein before bed, supplement or not, can help you build more muscle more quickly.
Having slowly digested protein before bed does seem to help, and some of the best protein sources to have before bed are: cottage cheese, greek yoghurt, and casein protein powder. (The only reason I didn’t include milk there is because it might make you have to pee during the night. If that’s not an issue for you, then you can include milk there also.)
So yep, having your milk and casein shake before bed would definitely help 🙂
For others reading, here’s a good casein protein powder.
You forgot one thing: the problem of the ectomorphs is not that they have a decreased ability for building muscle.
In other words, we are skinny not because our systems cannot absorb nutrients or we don’t take enough of them.
We are skinny type because we have an extremely fast metabolisms!
WE BUILD MUSCLE AT THE SAME PACE AS ENDOMORPHS OR OTHERS, BUT OUR SYSTEM MAKES AN OVERLY EFFECTIVE JOB AT BREAKING DOWN OUR ACHIEVEMENTS. Our system digests the nutrients very fast and we the solution is not MORE, MORE, MORE.
We need to slow down our metabolism.
Our task is to counterweight the breaking down process.
Our main weapon in this fight is CASEIN.
If you are an ectomorph, forget whey completely! We take tons of whey and we think we’ve already had enough protein for that day. Yes we had but all has been used up by our system as fuel and none of it goes to muscles.
Casein is the holy grail of ectomorphs, because it fights the breaking down process.
As ectomorphs, our focus should be not on maximizing the muscle building even further (which is actually not possible over a given amount of protein), but on HOW TO REDUCE THE EFFECT OF OUR OVERLY STRONG PROCESS OF MUSCLE BREAKDOWN.
Slow your metabolism, eat 3 times a day max! (calorie rich foods)
Use casein instead of whey.
Give it 3 months and you’ll see what I’m talking about.
Hey Zoltan, thank you for the comment, man!
Oftentimes we can actually build muscle more quickly than the other body types. This seems to be because we start off further away from our genetic muscular potential. More room on our frames for growth 🙂
Skinny guys don’t generally tend to have high metabolisms, per se, but rather we tend to have adaptive metabolisms. This aspect of our metabolism is called non-exercise activity thermogenesis (NEAT). Essentially, this means that when we try to eat more, our bodies respond by fidgeting more, producing more body heat, pacing more, standing instead of sitting—tons of little subconscious things that cause us to burn away those surplus calories.
Fortunately, this seems to happen after building muscle. If you follow a good muscle-building program, what will happen is that you will go into a calorie surplus, your muscles will use as much of those calories as they need, and the leftover calories will be burned up by NEAT instead of being stored as fat. It allows us to make leaner gains. So I would count this among our genetic advantages 🙂
Casein does digest more slowly, and digestion is indeed an aspect of metabolism (within the subcategory of catabolism), but that just means that the energy from the casein becomes available to your system more progressively. What we’re more concerned about is consuming enough energy overall so that we can facilitate the other aspect of metabolism: anabolism.
There’s some truth to the idea that more slowly digested protein can be useful while bulking. Casein performs well when taken before bed, as does cottage cheese, milk, meat, etc., as we’re going quite a while without eating. Whey protein seems to perform better post-workout, when we need the protein more rapidly. We’re really splitting hairs here, though, and the differences in your results wouldn’t be noticeable. People don’t need to buy both different types of protein.
Eating 3 times per day is fine, but eating more would be slightly better still. The more we can stimulate muscle growth, the better, and each meal with protein stimulates muscle growth for a few hours. So if you eat every few hours, you can stimulate more muscle growth. That makes eating around 5 times per day ideal for building muscle. Again, though, we’re splitting hairs here. The differences between 3 meals and 5 meals would be small.
The link between meal frequency and metabolism is fairly tenuous. I wouldn’t count on a lower meal frequency even reducing your metabolism at all. (This has been the topic of a bunch of research over the past decade, and many textbooks are being re-written to feature this more updated stance on meal frequency.)
In our program we teach you how to optimize every single factor, but these factors are lower down on the priority list. First we teach guys how to do the stuff that has a huge impact on gains.
However, guys who want to buy a second protein powder to have before bed could get a small benefit from casein. Alternatively, they could get the same benefit by having a small bowl of cottage cheese (perhaps with some strawberry jam to make it taste better!).
I hope that helps 🙂
im an ectomorph .
age-18
weight-65kg
height-6’2
is pro antium protien powder good for me?
We don’t review brands, but I can say that given that you’re an ectomorph who’s eager to build muscle, whey protein concentrate or isolate would probably be your best bet.
Hey Shane,
Thanks fo the info provided. Just one question, I’ve been taking (3 weeks so far) Serious Mass weight gainer because of the good reviews it has.
After I read your article, I’m doing good because the gainer is basically maltodextrin as a carb source. But (there’s always a but), I also read an article in BB.com that says…
” Of course, many supplement companies try to trick the consumer by using ingredients like maltodextrin instead. While maltodextrin is technically a complex carb, it breaks apart very rapidly in the body and spikes blood sugar and insulin levels even faster and higher than sugar does. This allows manufacturers to list less sugar—or even no sugar—on the product label. The unsuspecting consumer has no idea that the carbs in that product are sugar in disguise.”
I’m so confused right now. Any thoughts?
Hey Francisco, that’s a really good question.
So, first of all, yes, maltodextrin is often used as a cheap filler ingredient. That’s one of the reasons that we recommend buying it separately and making your own weight gainer supplement. That way you pay fair value for your maltodextrin and can use as much or little as you choose when making your workout drinks.
Is maltodextrin sugar in disguise? No. It’s a starch. I don’t see maltodextrin trying to hide that in any way, although some supplement companies may indeed use it to mislead people—I’m not sure.
Will it spike insulin? Absolutely! So will whey protein, which is highly insulinogenic as well. And that’s a good thing if you’re having this drink as a post-workout drink. Our muscles become insulin sensitive when we lift weights, and then we funnel all of these protein and carbs right to them. These nutrients are funnelled to your muscles via your blood stream, which is why (very temporarily) having higher blood sugar can be good as well.
Should you be having a weight gainer instead of a regular meal? No. It’s more similar to cake than a healthy meal. I’d only use these gainer supplements surrounding your training, and only in the right doses for your goals, training, body type and body fat percentage. Not just because of insulin and blood sugar, but also because weight gainers have so few micronutrients, such as vitamins and minerals, prebiotics and probiotics, fibre, and etc.
If you’re looking for a weight gainer to have instead of meals, I’d recommend smoothies instead.
I hope that helps! (And as always clear all of this with your doctor.)
You could think of this like the difference between a guy having a coke at his office desk vs a football player chugging some gatorade before running back on the field. Both are nutritionally similar, but the contexts are totally different.
Yes, I think making a smoothie would be the best choice to reach my macros. Blending some maltodextrin with dry oats, bananas and whey should work better.
Thanks for clarifying this.
Hey Shane! Going to start the B2B program in the next week or so, and I have a few questions about supplements (which I’m definitely going to use as an addition to everything else). Just random things that I was wondering while reading the article—apologies if they’ve already been answered elsewhere.
First, would the benefits of using supplements be significantly lessened if only one of the three you recommend is being used? In other words, does combining all three instead of using, say, just creatine, make a significant difference?
Second, how do you measure out the servings in grams? Do you just eyeball it or use a scale or what?
Finally, is it bad to start using supplements with everything else right away? When in the program would you recommend adding them?
Thanks!
Right now I have creatine on standby and am considering getting whey and maltodextrin as well, which is the reason I ask.
Woot, glad to hear it, Alexa! This is a great time of year to be starting the program. New Years is always an exciting time in the community 🙂
Creatine will work just as well with or without whey and maltodextrin… provided that you’re lifting weights, eating enough protein, and eating enough calories. Similarly, whey and maltodextrin will work wonderfully well even without creatine, as they will help you to eat enough protein and to eat enough calories. (And they also help with nutrient timing as explained in this article, but that’s a secondary benefit.) If you combine all three, the creatine will accelerate muscle growth while the whey+maltodextrin will help make your diet easier to follow.
I wouldn’t eyeball your serving sizes. Given how important calories are for weight gain, and how dense a source of calories these are, getting a more precise measurement is crucial. The most accurate way to measure whey, maltodextrin and creatine is with a little digital scale. However, you can also measure by volume. Creatine by volume is around 3 grams per teaspoon, so you’d have 1.5–2 teaspoons of creatine each day to hit your 5 gram target. Whey by volume is about 100 grams per cup. Maltodextrin by volume is about 140 grams per cup.
Whey protein also tends to come with a serving scoop that will give you roughly 27 grams of protein. That same scoop will give you roughly 40 grams of maltodextrin. (Maltodextrin is about 1.4x as heavy as whey.)
Is it bad to start using supplements right away? No. You can start using them right away. That’s not a problem. Some people recommend learning to gain weight without creatine first, as creatine can cause a bit of movement on the scale with or without muscle gain, but if you want the best results right out of the gate, you’ll gain muscle more quickly if you just start using everything at once.
I hope that helps, and I hope to see you in the community soon, man!
[…] example, I started looking into supplements to help build muscle and found out that vitamin D can help you build more muscle if you’re deficient in […]
I have tried lot of supplements to gain weight of none of that has ever worked for me.After reading this posting i think i should give it a try but i am feeling little reluctant.Because every time when i am not unsuccessful in archiving what i wanted i feel very bad about it and just want to give up on it.
Hey Karan,
Don’t give up! Almost all of our bulking success stories, including my own, came after numerous failed attempts, and several years feeling helpless. Almost all of us have moments of feeling doomed to remain skinny forever.
However, make sure that you aren’t blaming supplements for your lack of progress. If you aren’t gaining weight on the scale each week, that’s not creatine’s fault, that’s because you aren’t eating enough calories. Go back to the fundamentals when you aren’t making progress. Don’t try to put a bandaid over the issue by upping your supplement intake. That will just make you poorer, not stronger.
Love the article man, lots of info regarding us skinny dudes. Just a quick q. I started liftinf seriously about two years ago. Before I weight around 115-125 and as I trained I gained muscle to weight at about 145. My body fat is 6% and I tend to go back between 145-155. I am mostly into calisthenics using chest dips and the like over bench presses.
Anyway, my q is have I hit a platue? I feel like my diet doesn’t cut it anymore (I eat pretty clean, lots of chicken and rice here). I usually take a protien shake in the morning and a premade gainer I got makes me feel bloated. Will these supplements along with my siet help put me back into the right path to gainz city?
Thanks!
Hey Ra, sorry about the delay getting back to you, man! I took a bit of a paternity leave after my son was born. Getting back to work now 🙂
First of all, congrats on the gains! That’s awesome!
As for your plateau, I’ve got a new article in the works on plateaus, but I’d start by reading this one on newbie gains. Once you understand newbie gains, you understand why you hit plateaus so easily afterwards:
https://bonytobeastly.com/ectomorphs-newbie-gains-guide/
If your gains in the gym have plateaued, that’s complicated, and that above article will help. If you’re just talking about your weight having plateaued, though, the first step would be to increase your calorie intake until you start moving the scale up again!
Again, though, since we need to factor in both diet and training, while increasing calories will get the scale moving again, you’d need to make sure that your workout program is also good enough to help blast you through that plateau 🙂
Supplements don’t have anything to do with the plateau, per se, but if they help you eat more calories and/or more protein, then they could help you on that front. Similarly, creatine could help improve your workout performance, so assuming your workout program is good, then it could help you get better gains out of it.
Thanks alot for the article. Will read it asap man!
Hi, I like the article along with several others by you guys that I have read. I have followed this site for some time now(about 2-3 months) and I thought about joining this but I’m still not sure right now if it’s the right thing for me.
I started recently going back to the gym, due to wanting to get more exercise, more physically fit, and maybe gain some more pounds as I was and still am very underweight, not just skinny. I have gained a few measly pounds so far in about a months time.
I have a question or 2 on pre-workout drinks and possibly other supplements. About a few days ago, I took a pre-workout drink called, “MP muscle pharm Assault” just before I entered the gym, then did several minutes of cardio and then did resistance exercises with my trainer. I also just started to drink a creatine drink by “Body Fortress” immediately before training. Anyways, after several minutes getting into my training I was sweating heavily and then I started to get to feeling faint and just about nauseas to where I almost felt like I could vomit. I did sit down immediately upon feeling like that, plus drinking water and I did feel a little better. I then did some more exercises on another machine and I still felt ok but not like before I started working out. Just what the heck was going on there with my body at that time.?? I think it could have been attributed to maybe the pre-workout stuff I took because of the high caffeine content and other ingredients including amino acids.? The other things I thought about was my intake of water. Maybe it was still not enough, even though I was drinking some at the gym and also drinking those supplements. I was diagnosed with high blood pressure and am taking a dieretic (water pill) for it which the dosage is very minimal. Well, I did my own research on blood pressure (on the low part) and on Creatine in Wikipedia, and the article on Creatine says if you take any blood pressure meds that are thiazides (like I do which is “Hydrochlorthiazide) and they mentioned a few other names of some meds that they recommend NOT to take Creatine. I think they say that because they work against each other.? Creatine I guess, tries to get more water to the muscles.? and the blood pressure meds want to get the water out of the body due to getting rid of excess sodium. It all just seems to be a “no-win” situation here, and I hate as hell, going through this crap having to take these d—– meds but what else can I do.? Another thing about these pre-workout drinks is that they have so much caffeine in them which is more than a cup of coffee. They say it’s for more energy and focus. The problems with caffeine especially with persons like me is it can get you more nervous, more hyper-aware and increase anxiety levels. Even a psychiatrist from years ago told me that caffeine raises anxiety levels. I’m not saying caffeine is all totally wrong or not good for you, but not sure whether or not to take a pre-workout drink because caffeine is in there. I take mine just before entering the gym, not 30 minutes before I get there. I don’t want to get too nervous and anxious while driving is why I don’t take it at home before leaving.
I tried this one pre-workout drink that I heard about through my trainer. It seems to be ok, but not sure how it will work for me.? He said he patented it and it has been verified of what is on the label is in the package. He’s done the research on all this through the help of other doctors and Wikipedia articles, not on other products. He said he’s tried several pre-workout drinks and either didn’t get good results or got side-affects. I’m going to just stick with his formulated drink next time to see if I get like I did the last time I went to the gym. If I do, then it’s not his drink but who knows.? Here’s the website for this drink if anyone is interested: https://movingmatterlabz.com/
There’s more information on that site on that product. My trainer also sells a protein whey product as well. I havn’t tried that one yet. If anyone through these forums buys and tries these out, please let us know how you like them and if they really help out. I’de be curious to know. Sorry if this was too “long winded.” but I just had a lot to say.
It’s hard to say what gave you that bad reaction. If it were me, I would start with just caffeine and then go from there, adding in, say, beta alanine next. That way you can narrow it down to which specific supplement you’re having a bad reaction to.
To make things more complicated, sometimes it can take a while to get used to the various supplements. For example, take a supplement like Greens+, which is just blended up veggies. It’s known to cause stomach cramping when you first start taking it, so they recommend starting with small doses and gradually working your way up. Your body just needs time to learn how to digest it.
Also, when you’re just getting back to the gym, sometimes you can be out of shape, and pushing yourself hard when you’re out of shape can make you feel pretty crumby. It may be a matter of gearing back into the gym more progressively.
As for that website you linked, the supplement there isn’t a good one. Seven grams of protein isn’t nearly enough; there’s far too little beta alanine; and there’s no reason for there to be BCAAs in there, especially when in such a small amount. These are not effective doses.
Shane, thanks for commenting back. I will try to see what made me have that reaction from that last or near last gym visit. I think what happened to me was that when I was taking my meds and working out, I guess I didn’t have enough water in my system and when I was sweating excessively, it probably cause my blood pressure to plunge the other direction(it got real low) and that can make a person feel faint and nauseated. I looked it up to make sure. So I know to be very hydrated cause of the meds I’m on, plus if I’m going to take a Creatine supplement.
I can’t believe on what I heard from you that the supplement I was going to take through my trainer isn’t any good.? This is a pre-workout supplement, so that’s why I guess it has very minimal protein in it as usually other pre-workout drinks don’t have protein in them.
Maybe I was a little harsh. I don’t know that it’s not GOOD, I should just say that it isn’t IDEAL.
I’m not sure why you’d want a little bit of protein in a pre-workout drink if you aren’t getting an effective dose, so that doesn’t make much sense to me. Either having an adequate amount of protein OR having none at all would seem like the better option.
I should also point out that the caffeine in that supplement IS in an effective dose. That alone should reliably improve your workout performance, especially if you aren’t already in the habit of having caffeine. It’s just the other supplements mixed in that aren’t in ideal doses (or that don’t even need to be in there in the first place).
With a pre-workout supplement, though, use whatever has you feeling pumped to train! While Tier One is a totally optimal pre-workout supplement, I find that I also get great workouts after having a Rockstar energy drink. It’s not that Rockstar is ideal by any means, just that the mix of stimulants leaves me feeling great, and that great energy translates into a great workout 🙂
Thanks for the reply back & also the additional comments on the supplements. I’m pretty new to using these pre-work out supplemental drinks. With so many supplements out there for body building, etc. it can be so confusing and then on top of that all these different opinions on them. In the past I’ve taken protein whey and also Creatine by “Body Fortress”. Yeah, I don’t know why that one supplement has such a small amount of protein in it. The label says it has milk products in it. I did take my trainer’s recommended pre-workout drink last time I was at the gym yesterday and I felt just fine and was able to do my workouts with no problems, no faintness or nausea, etc. I will consider the pre-workout drink you suggest in the near future, to try. I’m about to place an order on Amazon anyways, so why not.? I don’t mind caffeine at all in drinks like coffee, tea, etc. it’s just that the amount is so much in a pre-workout drink, but I think that part of it helps me push harder to get my last rep done. Interesting to hear you drink those “Rock star” drinks before workouts. I know they are just energy drinks. I’m not against them at all, even though other people say to me that they’re bad for you. I like to drink some energy drinks but as a quick pick-me- up in the afternoons. I got started on those several years ago through a co-worker and that was the “Monster” brand, then I tried “Rock Star” and a few others. My favorite one is the regular “Red Bull” but they’re more expensive.
[…] (ถ้าคุณต้องการสารอาหารหลังออกกำลังที่เราแนะนำสำหรับเอ็คโตมอร์ฟ อ่านได้ที่โพสต์นี้) […]
I am in the UK so can’t use the links!
Hi Shane, great article!
Two questions:
1) If the training drink is only for training days, should you still be taking protein and/or maltodextrin on your rest days?
2) You say 30-90g of protein and 60-180g of maltodextrin. Why such a big range? How do you determine how much is right for you?
Cheers,
Adam
Hey Adam, thanks!
1. Yeah, the training drink is only for your workout days. You can have protein powder on your rest days if it helps you hit your protein goals. No real problem there. You can think of whey protein like you do other dairy products. You don’t need to put a strict limit on your consumption. Maltodextrin is a different beast, though, and I’d save for your workout shake unless you really really need extra carbs on your rest days. I mean, it’s not the end of the world, and it can save you in a pinch, but as a general rule we want at least 80% of your calories coming from whole foods, and that’s going to be hard if you start plugging maltodextrin in on rest days.
2. The range is big because it depends on how badly you’re struggling to eat enough. Your typical gymgoer will do just fine with protein. Once you start dealing with naturally skinny guys, it’s often better to toss some carbs in there—more calories. Makes it easier to get into a calorie surplus and gain weight. And then once you get to the ultra hardgainers—the guys who are naturally super skinny and lean, and who have a miserable time getting into a calorie surplus, these are the guys who, first of all, NEED tons of calories, and second of all, they’re super lean and extremely insulin sensitive, so they’re not going to have any issues processing a bunch of simpler carbs.
(I’m naturally very skinny. I had the largest doses. And even after gaining 55 pounds that way, all testable health markers were better than when I started. Not everyone needs such an extreme workout shake, though.)
Since the training shake sounds quite nasty, would it be wise to add a water enhancer or some gatorade powder for taste?
Sure! If you can make your shake taste better by adding flavour to it, why not, right?
[…] Creatine is an extremely effective supplement for bulking up. Creatine can help you lift heavier weights, lift those heavier weights more times, and reduce your risk of injury while doing it. Given that its main “downside” is bulkier muscles, well, this isn’t even a problem for skinny guys—it’s a benefit. So it’s only upsides for us. This is why it’s one of our core Beastly supplements, at the top of our list of recommended bulking supplements. (Here’s our article about the other best bulking supplements and how to take them.) […]
Shouldn’t the Whey, Maltodextrin and Creatine doses be given according the person’s weight or eating habits?
We all eat differently and weight differently, but the Creatine level is fixed and the Whey and Maltodextrin have a range where we can’t decide ourselves where we are into that range. More protein can be harmful, as it will put your kidneys into pressure and increase your creatinine blood-levels.
Could you update the article then in a way were we can measure by ourselves how much of each supplement to add to our shakes?
For example:
“You should have X grams of protein by Y pounds of bodyweight, each Z grams of Whey have U grams of protein (or check your preffered brand), so you should have T grams of whey in your shake if you weight 150 pounds. This is similar to Q pound of red meat.”
Than same thing for Creatine and Maltodextrin, comparing with real food and etc, when applicable.
Thanks.
Hey Michel, I see where you’re coming from. You’ll definitely have different protein, creatine, and calorie requirements depending on how big you are. So it absolutely makes sense to adjust your supplement doses based on your size.
With these supplements, the main goal is to use them to hit your daily protein and calorie goals. And those goals do depend on your size. You want to aim for around 1 gram of protein per pound bodyweight per day, so you could adjust your whey intake to help you hit that goal. With calories, you want to eat enough calories to gain a little weight on the scale each week. For example, if you’re trying to gain a pound per week, that’d be roughly 500 extra calories per day. You’d use the maltodextrin to help you get into that calorie surplus, using more or less depending on how much weight you gain on the scale.
With creatine, the vast majority of men are going to benefit from getting 3–5 grams per day, with 5 grams being a more surefire way to ensure that you’re taking enough. Since creatine is so cheap and healthy, I’d err on the side of taking the full 5 grams, even if I were fairly small. Or perhaps, especially if I were fairly small.
Is too much protein bad for your kidneys or general health? Your kidneys do clear protein metabolites from your body, but even with very high protein intakes, there’s a lot of research showing that it tends to improve overall health and isn’t in any way harmful to your kidneys unless you already have kidney disease (study, study, study, study, study, study, study). Some studies have even measured protein intakes up to twice as high as what we’re recommending, still not finding any health downsides whatsoever—just benefits (study, study).
You can absolutely compare whey protein and maltodextrin to real food. Whey protein is nutritionally very similar to lean chicken breast, but you can get protein from a wide variety of sources. The important thing is that you get 1 gram of protein per pound bodyweight per day. Maltodextrin is very similar to white rice and white pasta, but again, you can get carbs/calories from anywhere. The main thing is to make sure that you’re eating enough calories to gain a little bit of weight on the scale each week.
Creatine is also found in food, but in too-small doses. I don’t think you’d be able to get any performance-enhancing benefits by trying to eat more creatine-rich foods.
I really hope that helps!
It helps a lot, just one thing to clarify though, when you say that Maltodextrin is similar to white rice, you mean same amount of calories per gram?
Thanks a lot!
Ah! Sorry. That was unclear. I mean that it’s similar in the sense that both are simple starches that are easy to digest. For skinny guys who are trying to eat more calories and carbs while bulking, they’re both great choices 🙂
If you want to know more, here’s our article about the best bulking diet for ectomorphs, including which foods are the best when trying to eat more calories.
Have you guys ever tried or studied the effects of plant steroids? There are a couple different compounds of them depending on how they bind. Nevertheless, there are natural plant steroid supplements sourced from plants, “steroids” such as as ecdysterone and (5 alpha hydroxy) laxogenin.
A recent study of ecdysterone had the researchers claiming the effects of ecdysterone were so great for muscle-building compared to the placebo group that they called for ecdysterone to be placed on WADA’s prohibited list of substances.
Anecdotally, I started stacking ecdysterone and laxogenin a couple weeks ago while deep into a cut. Up until that point I was losing strength across the board. Within a few days of maximum doses of both aforementioned supplements I began regaining strength while still in a calorie deficit. After nearly 3 weeks, 90% of my lifts are back to my PBs, which is unheard of for me. My lifts rarely, if ever, go up except when I’m in a calorie surplus.
Part of me wants to believe it’s a placebo effect. But the other part of me was skeptical to begin with and thus the placebo effect wouldn’t make sense.
Any thoughts?
Yeah, that’s a great question. Ecdysteroids (such as ecdysterone) are making headlines right now because of this new study showing that they could potentially produce steroid-like muscle gains. Definitely a relevant supplement for guys bulking up. It’s a spinach extract, too, which is kind of cool. I’ll add it to the supplement overview at the top of the article.
So, the first thing to note is that this is really new research. Even if this were a huge and totally Kosher study, it’d still be too soon. However, this was a very small study, and there are some anomalies.
The first anomaly with the ecdysterone study is that it didn’t find a dose-response relationship. The group who took a small amount of ecdysterone saw a similar improvement in strength as the group who took a larger amount. What makes that weirder is the fact that the supplement they were testing hardly contained any ecdysterone. The spinach extract they were testing was labeled as containing 100mg of ecdysterone but only contained 6mg. That’s a tiny dose, and yet it’s producing full-on steroid effects.
The next term, at least when it comes to it being a potential bulking supplement, is that tested muscle gains by using Bioelectric Impedance Analysis (BIA), which can’t really tell us much. It’s not an accurate enough way to measure small changes in muscle mass. More on body-fat percentage analysis here.
There’s nothing shady about the study, it’s just still too preliminary, especially given the odd results and the high possibility of false positives. I think we need to wait and see.
As a general rule of thumb, it’s not a good idea to be an early adopter with supplements. Being an early adopted means, first, that you don’t know if the supplement is actually going to be effective, and second, you don’t know what the side-effects and harms of that supplement might be. You don’t know if it’s going to be safe.
I appreciate the response. There are other studies too, if I remember, back a couple years done on rats that compared some of the anabolic properties of ecdysterone to that of Dianabol. And it was alleged to be the Russian secret for their Olympic athletes in the 1980s. I’m going by memory here, though, so don’t quote me 🙂
Yeah, I should have been more clear. It’s just the one study on human subjects that’s relevant for guys interested in gaining muscle size and strength. But you’re right, there’s a lot of prior research pointing to its efficacy, which is why they’re moving into human trials, and so far the human trial continues to point towards its efficacy. I’m sure there will be more.
However, having one human trial showing that it might help at an unclear dosage with unknown side-effects isn’t much. For example, compare that to something like creatine, where there are many hundreds of studies conducted over several decades giving us an extremely clear idea of what it does, how to take it, and how safe it is. Even with all of that, it’s still recommended that women avoid it during pregnancy and breastfeeding because we simply don’t know enough yet.
If someone wanted to gain muscle at all costs, I can see why it might be worth experimenting with ecdysterone at this stage. But I think that’s mainly applicable to professional untested bodybuilders and strength athletes, you know? Which is why it might be banned as a performance-enhancing drug at such an early stage.
You could also compare it to Dianabol, yeah. That has FAR more research behind it, clearer guidelines on how to use it, and I believe it’s legal where I live (although certainly not everywhere). But who wants to deal with the negative side-effects unless they’re elite athletes or bodybuilders, you know? It’s just not worth it.
To be clear, I don’t have anything against you experimenting with it, and it very well may work. It’s just so, so early that I can’t give any kind of recommendation on it. That would be totally reckless of me.
We’re also not really a site that deals with steroids, regardless of how good for bulking they are, although it’s not like I would deny their effectiveness. I know insect steroids (ecdysteroids) are a little different, and I know it’s a spinach extract (although in totally unrealistic doses to what you’d find in spinach), but still, I’m very cautious about making a recommendation on it, especially this early.
Absolutely, Shane, I wouldn’t recommend steroids either. The real kind, that is. But Dianabol is legal in Canada? Crazy. I have access to a Dianabol and testosterone through a friend—and I’ve seen him get 3x my size in a quarter of the time—but I’ve yet to touch it because you’re right that the possible side effects aren’t worth it. Ecdysteroids, however, do not appear to have those same issues as say Anavar, Dianabol, Trenbolone, etc.
Ah, I’m living in Cancun right now, where my wife is from. I haven’t looked into it, but I was talking to a guy who was getting them from the pharmacy while playing college football. From my experience in Canada, I’m used to there being a stigma surrounding steroids, but here it’s just something you can get from the drug store.
I believe steroids are illegal in Canada. Ephedrine isn’t, though, which surprises some Americans.
Ecdysteroids are definitely different, especially in that they aren’t androgenic, which presumably raises their safety profile, but I wouldn’t say we have enough evidence to suggest that taking extremely high doses of it wouldn’t present other kinds of side-effects. (High doses in the sense that in this recent human trial on ecdysterone, they used the amount you’d find in 4kg of spinach, if I recall correctly, which is far beyond what someone could consume naturally. However, it seems like the researchers made some sort of mistake with reporting of the dose. It’s unclear whether they were talking about the amount of spinach extract or the amount of ecdysterone in the spinach extract.)
It could be totally effective and totally safe. I just think it’s too early to know. I’m super curious, though.
[…] It worked. We found that we seemed to recover faster and it became a little easier to eat enough to gain weight. (If you’re curious about muscle-building supplements, here’s our article on the best bulking supplements for ectomorphs.) […]
[…] We have a great fix for this one: drinking a calorie-rich blend of protein and carbohydrates while working out. Not only does it boost workout performance and make our gains leaner, it also makes it far, far easier to eat enough calories to build muscle. Here’s our workout shake recipe. […]
[…] eating that much protein that often seems daunting, you might want to get some protein powder. If you sneak in a scoop of protein powder between your main meals, that will probably do the […]
[…] The first issue is that protein is incredibly filling. Try eating three chicken breasts and tell me you’re still hungry. Having a protein shake like whey makes this a lot easier as it uses the tricks from earlier (no chewing and no fibre). If you want to see what protein powders we recommend, see our bulking supplement guide. […]
[…] Citrulline malate still doesn’t work very well: Citrulline malate initially had some promising results, resulting in a lot of hype. It was added into a ton of popular pre-workout supplements. However, the early promising results aren’t being replicated by follow-up studies, including this new one. Seems like citrulline malate might not be so great after all? Time will tell, but it’s not looking good. (Here’s our guide on the bulking supplements that are actually proven to work.) […]
I’m a 45 year old 5’11”, 130lb man who used a similar routine 14 years ago and it worked great. From June-Dec I went from 138 to 173lbs and enjoyed it more every day. I got injured and couldn’t workout for a couple years. Caught a bad flu at that time, lost all the weight plus some. I was down 122lbs last year with no appetite and decided to make a change.
I’m having a hard time gaining. I blame my age, less productive workouts, 3-4hrs of sleep most nights due to my work schedule, and my upset stomach with most shake brands. I found a gluten free shake that’s working better and this article reminded me of the creatine benefit so I just ordered some. I’m working on the sleep issue slowly.
14 years ago, I also took a vitamin twice per day. I avoided multi-vitamins because so much seems to pass to waste. I can’t recall what that vitamin was.
Are there any vitamins that would help my scenario at my age?
Thanks for the article and any suggestions.
-Steve
[…] Supplements can help, but they’re a cherry on top of the cake, so treat them as such—put the bulk of your bulking focus on regular foods. […]
[…] some creatine. Then, once they’re already muscular, they’re asked to promote various bulking supplements that they never used while they were bulking […]
[…] The Best Bulking Supplements for Ectomorphs […]
[…] could build muscle if you were stranded on a desert island with nothing but your body weight and a weight-gainer supplement. But I’m also confident that you could clean your house with a toothbrush. There’s a […]
Hi Shane, thanks for your informative article. As you know most people are not strict endos or ectos. For example following a recent test, i found out that I am 68 percent ectomorph and 32 percent endomorph. I stand at 5’11” and weigh 90kgs. However much of my weight is concentrated on my torso therefore I have slim legs and arms. For supplement therefore, I’m thinking a combination of weight gainer and whey. What would be your response to that?
Hey Eryk, are you trying to build more muscle in your limbs or lose the fat around your torso? I mean, presumably, you’re trying to do both eventually, but which one are you trying to accomplish right away? Also, have you seen our skinny-fat article?
If you’re trying to cut off the fat, there’s no real need for any weight gainer or maltodextrin or anything. Whey and creatine are very useful, though. But the main things will be to follow a good hypertrophy-focused workout program, eat enough protein (around 200g per day), and get good sleep.
If you’re trying to build muscle, a weight gainer could be useful if you have trouble eating enough, but again the main supplements will be creatine and whey. The weight gainer aspect is mainly to make eating enough calories easier. (Mind you, the high carb content is also a good thing. But you could get that from foods if your appetite isn’t an issue—oats, rice, bananas, gains, legumes, fruits, etc.)
Hey there, I enjoyed reading this article.
During my workout, is it okay to just drink water? Then, post-workout, take 30 grams of whey protein concentrate + 60 grams of maltodextrin? (This brand of maltodextrin says to take 3 scoops?)
And should I use cold or hot water? I feel that hot water can burn belly fat so I suggested.
Thanks a lot.
Oh, I forgot to ask. Will 3 grams of creatine do the job as a beginner? Or is that too little?
I’m a skinny guy who eats a lot of meat, but gaining weight is hard for me.
5 grams is the best default, and it has the most research to support it. But 3 grams is okay, too, and there’s some research showing that it’s enough. I think you’ll do great either way 🙂
Hey Aristide, thank you!
Drinking water while working out is totally cool. Go with your preference 🙂
And, yeah, having some whey and maltodextrin afterwards is great, for all the reasons mentioned in this article. No need to follow the serving sizes on the tubs, especially with maltodextrin and weight gainers, where they’re simply a means of consuming enough calories.
You can use any water temperature. Again, go with your preference.
Super usesful article, as always.
I’m currently trying to figure out if vitamin supplements are worth it. I started taking a multivitamin capsule a day to be sure to get at least a small amount of all important vitamins and minerals everyday. At that point I started reading about vitamins and how they help in muscle growth and it was like opening Pandora’s box: high suggested dosages of vitamin C, E, D, etc. on one hand, while on the other hand articles debating the importance of vitamin C and E in muscle development to the point of saying they actually hinder muscle growth. Aside from vitamin D (which I was deficient of and am currently supplementing under medical supervision), would you recommend supplementing with other vitamins? Do you think a multivitamin is even worth it?
Thank you!
Thank you, man!
Vitamins aren’t really my area of expertise, but from what I can tell, the research seems pretty underwhelming. They’ve been incredibly popular for a long time now but there isn’t much proof that they actually help. There’s no reason to suspect they hurt, either, though.
Taking specific vitamins for specific deficiencies does seem to work. The popular deficiencies for bodybuilders to focus on are magnesium and zinc. I think the justification is that zinc and magnesium are lost in sweat, and serious bodybuilders tend to sweat more than the average person. Fixing deficiencies can increase testosterone and improve hormone production and all kinds of great things. If you eat a good diet, you might not be deficient in anything, though. At that point, supplementing with vitamins and minerals won’t really help. There’s even the possibility it can cause problems.
What you’re doing with vitamin D sounds like the right way to go about all of it. Get tested, find a solution to your specific deficiencies, try it out, and keep getting tested.
If you want to look up a specific vitamin, mineral, or supplement, I recommend searching it on Examine dot com.
I’d put more emphasis on eating a balanced diet than on supplementing with vitamins. That’s the most effective way to give your body what it wants.